Jamie Charman is Comin to Richmond

[Foley Tigers]

______________________________________________

Not a snowflakes chance in hell.

Hardwick is rebuilding and your saying that we are going to trade away our 2nd round pick.
Hardwick has said over and over... that we are going to the draft.

It will not happen. Complete BS. Bored were you? Troll are you? Yep.[/quote
ok thats fine
thats your opinion ***

 

[ohhhBigMalcho]

______________________________________________

Not a snowflakes chance in hell.

Hardwick is rebuilding and your saying that we are going to trade away our 2nd round pick.
Hardwick has said over and over... that we are going to the draft.

It will not happen. Complete BS. Bored were you? Troll are you? Yep.[/quote
ok thats fine
thats your opinion ***

the afl website suggests a straight swap of tuck to charman

 

[Foley Tigers]

Could work with a swap of 2nd rounders (19 for 28), perhaps?

its kind of pointless dont ya reckon?

 

[Foley Tigers]

the afl website suggests a straight swap of tuck to charman

see link?

 

[rado]

you have got to be joking we get shafted big time tbh
in effect that is charman for pick 19 which would be an absolute disgrace for someone who can hardly ever get his body right, and getting on in the age department.
pretty sure it won't happen as we have signed simmonds to a 1 year contract apparently (god knows why)

 

[SunKing]

Sounds like a good deal win/win in my opinion

 

[folester41]

why would we trade a pick inside the top 20 for someone turning 28 next year, it makes no sense?

we are rebuilding (or atleast trying to), if we ever make finals he will be too old and even then when we do, if we were to go on and challenge for a premiership he would be long gone.

i dont mind him joining us but not for 19, we need to keep 3 and 19

 

[dee64]

Why would Richmond trade for Charman and retain Simmonds on their list?

 

[Obeanie1]

the afl website suggests a straight swap of tuck to charman

And that sounds a hell of alot more reasonable.

I'd be surprised if Hawthorn don't have a crack at Charman. He's a big bad bully type ruckman, just Clarksons style.

Why would Charman go to Richmond when he could be playing finals and winning flags with the Hawks?

 

[coke_zero]

Why would Richmond trade for Charman and retain Simmonds on their list?

hopefully it is juat a rumor. but while were at it we'll delist Simmonds aswell. we have a few young rucks on our list who have shown some great signs lets stick with them instead of top ups.

 

[__aria__]

terrible trade for richmond

wont happen

 

[beaver fever]

Sounds like a good deal win/win in my opinion

LMAO, not surprised you think that

 

[Delids]

Will never happen,
Unless Hardwick is like WALLET FOS
We wont trade our second pick.
And for some tiger fans to suggest this is a good deal, well i think u need to have a look at the term rebuilding a footy club means.
Get used to the fact of keeping draft picks, and developing our own players.
Thats what good footy clubs do

 

[Dunn - Well Done]

If pick 19 gets to Brisbane some how i would like it to be passed onto essendon in exchange for Lovett.

 

[Boof09]

if we trade pick 19 I will be pissed

look what happened last time we did that.

I would like Charman but not for 19.

Charman for Raines a straight swap

Callan Ward....

 

[Copulator]

bad trade for lions, charman is a gun.

 

[whiteTiga2k]

i want charman at hawthorn... please don't let this trade be true

 

[Quigley]

And that sounds a hell of alot more reasonable.

I'd be surprised if Hawthorn don't have a crack at Charman. He's a big bad bully type ruckman, just Clarksons style.

Why would Charman go to Richmond when he could be playing finals and winning flags with the Hawks?

Because that would involve Pelchen making a trade.

FWIW I think we are overpaying with a third rounder for Raines so it could be a balancing act. Still I would be happy doing a straight swap Tuck for Charman. I think Tuck has been pretty harshly treated by Richmond and Richmond supporters. He is what is he and he is pretty consistently good at it. He is never going to be GAJ but there are very few better players on the Richmond list.

 

[BABYBOMBERS2007]

How can he be "Coming to Richmond" when trade week starts next week?

 

[tigerwill]

Seems like we're looking at Martin with pick 3.
"It was critical the club got quality players with 2 picks (3 and 19) inside the top 20" according to Francis Jackson

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/tigers-lock-on-dustin-martin/story-e6frf9jf-1225782480791

Not so sure on the rumours with Charman at pick 19 going by this article.

 

[Azzleberry]

No chance in HELL that this Charman trade will happen!!

Don't know if anyone else has read some of Foley's posts but he seems like a troll or a school kid bored on holidays...

The only way pick 19 will get traded is if its in a package for upgrade of picks.....

 

[TigerTime88]

THIS IS BS...

Quote our recruiting manager from the Dustin martin article on the HUN website:

He said it was critical the club got quality players with two picks (3 and 19) inside the top 20.

"We had a dismal year so we needed to get something out of it," Jackson said.

19 for Charman is a joke. IF that happened I would be pissed. No disrespect to Charman he is a good Ruckman but is not worth pick 19 considering Jolly is going for 14 and Charman is 27. Raines for Charman seems more fair..or Raines and Tuck for Charman! I would do that deal

Plus as stated above they signed Simmonds for another year

 

[Jamie007]

Jamie Charman is reportedly signing with richmond
BL: Get Raines, 2nd round
Rich: 3rd round, Charman

edited

 

[one eyedtiger]

I wouldn't mind Charman but not for pick 19.
A straight swap for Tuck would be fair

Here is the article from the AFL site
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/85623/default.aspx
Its saying what Brisbane needs from trade week and metions Charman being traded to us in the last paragraph.

 

[Lions1024]

The Op of the thread shud change the title and 1st post to Trade suggestion for Charman to RIchmond or soemthing like that. Coz you made it sound like its official that Charman is going to Richmond.