Jimmy Bartel- Now is the time

[Juddtastic]

His breakeven is hovering very close to the scores he was consistently getting before the concussion and especially against the doggies i was thinking that now is the time to pounce for those that do not have the little gun...

I have 5 trades left but would have to use 2 to trade petterd from emergencies and place that hack hasleby on my bench

Thoughts?

 

[fjm9]

ive got the same dilemma but tad different, 5 trades and would have to use 2 to upgrade shaun burgoyne to bartel. i dno wat to do

 

[DanA]

He is clearly carrying an injury other than concussion. Why would you pick up a player that looks like he is carrying a groin injury.

Much better options

 

[Clanger]

I'm not sure about having someone like Haselby on the bench. What I mean is keep him or upgrade him but I don't see the point of having someone like him on the bench.With the cash you get from Petterd upgrade Haselby next week.

 

[fjm9]

He is clearly carrying an injury other than concussion. Why would you pick up a player that looks like he is carrying a groin injury.

Much better options

much better options than bartel?

 

[Clanger]

Is Bartel carrying a groin injury? Hadn't heard that before?

 

[DanA]

Is Bartel carrying a groin injury? Hadn't heard that before?

Well there is something which has significantly reduced his time in the middle and it isn't concussion. You may miss a week for precautionary reasons but concussion does not affect your performance 2 weeks later.

He is definitely not 100% and hasn't looked 100% since we played Brisbane in round 12.

 

[banana_bus]

He is clearly carrying an injury other than concussion. Why would you pick up a player that looks like he is carrying a groin injury.

Much better options

yeah great call knobend do you even watch geelong games.

 

[DanA]

much better options than bartel?

Yeah I reckon he will be rested for a couple soon. Better to go for someone with a clean bill of health.

 

[hotdish]

Hows his TOG been in the last 3 weeks since he's been injured.

I can't find it anywhere on the net.

If he's playing 90+% of TOG, i'd select him. if they're nursing him through the rest of the season i wouldn't.

 

[fjm9]

Hows his TOG been in the last 3 weeks since he's been injured.

I can't find it anywhere on the net.

If he's playing 90+% of TOG, i'd select him. if they're nursing him through the rest of the season i wouldn't.

i think it was 79 or sumfin last week

 

[Juddtastic]

I'm not sure about having someone like Haselby on the bench. What I mean is keep him or upgrade him but I don't see the point of having someone like him on the bench.With the cash you get from Petterd upgrade Haselby next week.

Hasleby will be there as an insurance policy. Better to have mediocre scores from him if need be then a zero which petterd will rack up. Plus if any of my mids were to go down with 2-3 week injuries Haze will fill in wheras petterd wont and it wont be worth using another trade to get som1 better who i wont be using on the field

 

[hawka_fan]

So is he really injured? Would Kornes be a safer option?

 

[Buckley is ripped]

Well there is something which has significantly reduced his time in the middle and it isn't concussion. You may miss a week for precautionary reasons but concussion does not affect your performance 2 weeks later.

He is definitely not 100% and hasn't looked 100% since we played Brisbane in round 12.

He spent a bit of time on the bench cos he copped a knocked to the head.... i saw him at the supermarket and he was sporting a black eye !!!!

I asked him about the knock... " it looks worse than it is !!!!"... i tell ya something !!!!! this guy is fit....don't worry about that !!!!

 

[Clanger]

I think you're right. His game time was reduced because of that knock he had not because they were giving him a lighter load because of his concussion.

 

[sheller891]

So is he really injured? Would Kornes be a safer option?

TOUGH ONE.

bartel is probably carrying a niggle which could restrict him but if not is a freak dter

kornes is usually a freak dter but has been tagging really well, and may get more lock down roles nullifying him a bit

about the same risk

 

[DanA]

I think you're right. His game time was reduced because of that knock he had not because they were giving him a lighter load because of his concussion.

So why has he started on the HF line the last few weeks? If fit he clearly belongs in the middle

 

[Benno_900]

Love it, not only scaring people off getting him but the ones who have him into trading him as well.

 

[Juddtastic]

I reckon that this is the week Jimmy gets a ton. He copped a knock to the very head he had concussion with and still managed a respectful 87. he is a gun

 

[hawka_fan]

I reckon that this is the week Jimmy gets a ton. He copped a knock to the very head he had concussion with and still managed a respectful 87. he is a gun

lol its not like he can cop a knock to another head then the one he got concussed week. Agree though he is due for 100 this week.

 

[[ToTTi]]

His B/E is 153 this week isn't it?

 

[Clanger]

129 for dreamteam.

 

[Jan Juc]

Hows his TOG been in the last 3 weeks since he's been injured.

I can't find it anywhere on the net.

If he's playing 90+% of TOG, i'd select him. if they're nursing him through the rest of the season i wouldn't.

Jimmy Bartel TOG

R1-R12 Average - 88.7%
MIN - 76%
MAX - 95%

TOG Since Injury

R13 - 36%
R14 - 79%
R15 - 79%

 

[Clanger]

Thanks for those time on ground stats!

 

[DanA]

Jimmy Bartel TOG

R1-R12 Average - 88.7%
MIN - 76%
MAX - 95%

TOG Since Injury

R13 - 36%
R14 - 79%
R15 - 79%

Also started the game at half forward