I was reading a few posts on the main board, regarding peoples thoughts on John Elliott.
Do you guys think he is a positive or negative person for Carlton?
Do you guys think he is a positive or negative person for Carlton?
John Elliott
- Thread starter meg
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Status
Bernie
Senior List
My views on Elliot are very clear. He's now entering the realm of self-parody - where the real guy is actually the anachronistic , bombastic big noter that is constantly being portrayed. His efforts with Jim Stynes on the ABC last weekend were just ordinary.
He seems to act like he can get away with anything because he's rich and important, so we'll all just say' ..oh that's Jack, what a character '. This guy was once actually being touted as a future PM and I know that, in the 80's, he'd 'hold court' at the footy and could be approached thru' trusted toadies to gain an audience, so that you could become part of the 'magic circle'. He doesn't seem to have any friends that can tell him to lose the act he has. Someone said that '.. some of the things he says are quite astute' Why aren't ALL the things he says quite astute.
And then there's the unacceptable behavior and the dickhead defence of 'I was too drunk to remember'. Our club must rise above all this crappy behavior.
I think he really has held us back - compare him with the Geelong guy, who comes over as a together and considered spokesperson.
Elliot belongs to another era - it was fun but now it's mutton dressed as lamb. I can't believe that others more suitable don't aspire to the role.
He seems to act like he can get away with anything because he's rich and important, so we'll all just say' ..oh that's Jack, what a character '. This guy was once actually being touted as a future PM and I know that, in the 80's, he'd 'hold court' at the footy and could be approached thru' trusted toadies to gain an audience, so that you could become part of the 'magic circle'. He doesn't seem to have any friends that can tell him to lose the act he has. Someone said that '.. some of the things he says are quite astute' Why aren't ALL the things he says quite astute.
And then there's the unacceptable behavior and the dickhead defence of 'I was too drunk to remember'. Our club must rise above all this crappy behavior.
I think he really has held us back - compare him with the Geelong guy, who comes over as a together and considered spokesperson.
Elliot belongs to another era - it was fun but now it's mutton dressed as lamb. I can't believe that others more suitable don't aspire to the role.
Blue Blood
Debutant
It's just a shame that there isn't any free trading in the AFL because Elliot would have been more successful.He may open is mouth sometimes when not wanted.But on a whole i think he has done alot for this club.He has developed optus oval and shown to everyone that Carlton FC won't be walked all over.The best thing about him is his passion towards the club.He won't settle for nothing more then the best and his attitude shows through the rest of the team.At this stage i can't think of anyone better to lead the club.
- Thread starter
- #4
You make a good point BlueBlood.
Heaps of people bag him, but really, who else is there to become the President of carlton?
Heaps of people bag him, but really, who else is there to become the President of carlton?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2000
- Posts
- 97,914
- Reaction score
- 131,143
- Location
- Wherever I am
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Nottingham Forest
- Staff
- #5
Agreed Meg, but nobody is beyond reproach. If he was a player, the club would reprimand him for being undisciplined. He doesn't have to behave as he does. He just doesn't particularly care. Even the Carlton players distance themselves from his comments or worse, publicly comment that they wish he wouldn't comment. Now how arrogant is he to believe that he doesn't have to listen to voices within his own club? He does NOT own the Blues. He is there to lead us on the right path for the future, not to make enemies and enforce stereotypes. He is living in the past and needs to evolve.
Hellacopters
Debutant
Elliot is a joke...fancy HIM of all people calling the three carlton players a disgrace!!
HA
Jack..youve got the money..BUY A TIP...do everyone a favour and SHUT THE F*$K UPP!
A Definate Embaressment!
HA
Jack..youve got the money..BUY A TIP...do everyone a favour and SHUT THE F*$K UPP!
A Definate Embaressment!
John Elliot is letting Carlton down on a regular basis, he arms the opposing team with plenty of ammo with his stupid drunken outbursts.As a carlton supporter I say we need a new president with more brains who is more of the quiet achiever type.
Maybe Mike Fitzpatrick would be a better choice.
Maybe Mike Fitzpatrick would be a better choice.
blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
Jack was proved to be have been wrong in the way he dealt
But never doubt he is a Blue 100%
Regardless I will always share a beer with the bloke...did then and will now.
Never agreed with his politics, business or the way he crippled our club but you wear your heart on your sleeve = good enough for me
Always did and does go out of his way for the wablues
But never doubt he is a Blue 100%
Regardless I will always share a beer with the bloke...did then and will now.
Never agreed with his politics, business or the way he crippled our club but you wear your heart on your sleeve = good enough for me
Always did and does go out of his way for the wablues
- Banned
- #9
John Elliot was ok,can't blame him for everything.The salary cap stops at the managers of the players. I had a go recruiting 30 players with the budget of not going over the cap and i run out after the 26th player. The team had some great players along with some reasonably good players added with a few first year players.
blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
I thank the serial troll for bumping this thread
Last I spoke at length to Jack was at the GF function last year. Whilst he smoked he made it clear I was not young blonde nor female but was happy to say G'day as I was a Blue
Last I spoke at length to Jack was at the GF function last year. Whilst he smoked he made it clear I was not young blonde nor female but was happy to say G'day as I was a Blue
- Status
