Jonathan Brown

[unplugged]

What would they do with them at Lions HQ? Geez, they'd need a lot of room to store 'em given that we're all Magpie supporters. They're what give us our deep, resonant tone when barracking. ;-)

Hahaha. I can just imagine if that was apart of such trade. Jonathan Brown about to crumb and goal for Collingwood, but the opposition concedes under pressure... our famous boos would become screeches.

 

[Paddywhackers]

We'd HAVE to give up something like Pendlebury plus a first rounder.

But we wouldn't.

I wouldn't give pendlebury in a straight swap. Maybe that is extremely biased and I am very attached to Pendles, but he is probably the best young midfielder coming through the ranks in the comp, Brown is star but is 27. Who could only have three years left at a new club.

 

[Vampire013]

Forget J.Brown lets get M.Brown.

J.Brown is not nor ever will be a true blooded collingwood player, stuff him.

I agree with you
The Prick hates Collingwood.
He'd only come for the money, like Judd went to Carlton.
We want someone who loves Collingwood.
Nathan's brother Mitchell Brown was a Collingwood supporter
Would be great having these 2 twins in our side
Most unlikely that West Coast would want to part company, but why not have a go. He is younger and his value would have dropped after knee injury.
I would take a punt on him if he became available

 

[macleodboy07]

I wouldn't give pendlebury in a straight swap. Maybe that is extremely biased and I am very attached to Pendles, but he is probably the best young midfielder coming through the ranks in the comp, Brown is star but is 27. Who could only have three years left at a new club.

if we give away any of pendlebury thomas dawes shaw cloke clarke or any1 who is a regular senior player i will hand in my membership. no young player or draft pick in this draft is worth JB. this draft is going to be a very good one so lets keep our pick keep our young gun and look towards the future!
we should go after cousins but. he would be good to have for a couple of year. more so to teach the young fellas like pendlebury thomas clarke ect. the guy is a proven gun and legand! it would be priceless to tap into his football brain. just aslong as he is over all his off feild stuff. having mick as coach might help him to.

 

[Somebody]

Hahaha. I can just imagine if that was apart of such trade. Jonathan Brown about to crumb and goal for Collingwood, but the opposition concedes under pressure... our famous boos would become screeches.

Hopefully the remaining one grows to compensate. Rather disconcerting not having a spare though - would you give your spare for Collingwood? How about to guarantee a 4-peat, or to stop the club merging with Carlton?

 

[UltraMagnus]

Anyone and anything not named Shaw, Pendlebury, Thomas, Cloke and Brown.

haha so basically anything but the only decent young players you have.

so nice of you to offer average players past their prime.

 

[BEEG]

Andy Maher said on SEN today someone in the know is saying we are having a fair dinkum crack at Brown and will do what ever it takes including a 5 year deal

 

[popathon]

Andy Maher wouldn't have a clue. Forget about J Brown he isn't our main priority. If we could get M Brown & Kerr we would be set. Give up Fraser, 1st pick & Reid/Rusling.
Of course WC probably wouldn't oblige but these two players would seriously put us up there with the best.

 

[Mental Magpie]

He's only coming to us if Brisbane drop him this week

Why would Brisbane drop him?

 

[WakeUpPies]

haha so basically anything but the only decent young players you have.

so nice of you to offer average players past their prime.

Exactly!

Better than getting a packet of chips for return for Judd.

 

[Shangalang]

if this bloke wanted to come come to collingwood what would we give up for him

Irrelevant - when was the last time Collingwood actually attracted a high profile player that htey were chaing to their club lets see...

Fraser Gehrig - No
Nick Stevens - No
Chriss Judd - No
Steve Johnson - No
J Brown - No

Seems to be a pattern here !!!!!!

 

[spartan-magpie]

u have both stevens and judd and 3 no. 1 draft picks.. and u u guys are still a crap team.. im glad u guys got judd.. he will never be what he was at west coast.. that is, a premiership captain or a brownlow medalist. u guys can keep getting the high profile players.. if we are lucky we might find a kerr or cousins to fill in a hole or or two... u guys still need a backline and a forward line (fevola is ur only true avenue to goal and he might not even be there next year). the pattern is we dont do under the table deal deals... whereas ur shambles of a team does..

 

[Shangalang]

u have both stevens and judd and 3 no. 1 draft picks.. and u u guys are still a crap team.. im glad u guys got judd.. he will never be what he was at west coast.. that is, a premiership captain or a brownlow medalist. u guys can keep getting the high profile players.. if we are lucky we might find a kerr or cousins to fill in a hole or or two... u guys still need a backline and a forward line (fevola is ur only true avenue to goal and he might not even be there next year). the pattern is we dont do under the table deal deals... whereas ur shambles of a team does..

This crap team who you say only has one true avenue to goal, is still in need of both a backline and a forward line owned you tiwice at the G this year mate !!! So where does that leave Collingwood fancy getting pumped by a team with no backline or forward line not once but twice !!!!

Do say Judd will never be a premiership Captain or Brwonlow medalist at Carlton is indeed taking liberites and very presumptious i think a lot of more educated and knowledgable football followers than your good self would think that he has a live chance of achieving both. Give Juddy a full pre season next year and he will be close to his best again mate... All along Judd was never expected to peak this year - although even on one leg still managed to tear the Pies a new one when it counted on two occasions. Didn't you watch his last quarters v your rabble !!!!

 

[Magpie Phil]

This crap team who you say only has one true avenue to goal, is still in need of both a backline and a forward line owned you tiwice at the G this year mate !!! So where does that leave Collingwood fancy getting pumped by a team with no backline or forward line not once but twice !!!!

Do say Judd will never be a premiership Captain or Brwonlow medalist at Carlton is indeed taking liberites and very presumptious i think a lot of more educated and knowledgable football followers than your good self would think that he has a live chance of achieving both. Give Juddy a full pre season next year and he will be close to his best again mate... All along Judd was never expected to peak this year - although even on one leg still managed to tear the Pies a new one when it counted on two occasions. Didn't you watch his last quarters v your rabble !!!!

Pi** Off to your own board you cheating scum bag follower, COME ON MODS why do we have to put up with these Pric*s, most of them need to be banned automatically. You only need to look at the scum abg board and they ban you.

You all make me sick you arrogant F*** Wits. Cheats Cheats Cheats.

 

[Chase the Ace]

Forget J.Brown lets get M.Brown.

J.Brown is not nor ever will be a true blooded collingwood player, stuff him.

You mean like Jimmy Clement?

 

[Chase the Ace]

Umm id be preparing to give up Toovey Nicholls Egan Cox 1st Rounder and Stanley= Brown

Oh yeah, that should get the deal done

And wouldn't Nicholls need to be on our list before we can offer him up for trade?

 

[popathon]

Irrelevant - when was the last time Collingwood actually attracted a high profile player that htey were chaing to their club lets see...

Fraser Gehrig - No
Nick Stevens - No
Chriss Judd - No
Steve Johnson - No
J Brown - No

Seems to be a pattern here !!!!!!

Mate nick stevens is not a high profile player. High cholesterol yes but not high profile.

 

[BEEG]

Pi** Off to your own board you cheating scum bag follower, COME ON MODS why do we have to put up with these Pric*s, most of them need to be banned automatically. You only need to look at the scum abg board and they ban you.

You all make me sick you arrogant F*** Wits. Cheats Cheats Cheats.

100% got a piss weak infraction yestday

 

[Seeks]

Irrelevant - when was the last time Collingwood actually attracted a high profile player that htey were chaing to their club lets see...

Fraser Gehrig - No
Nick Stevens - No Port wouldn't deal because be beat them in the finals the year before. Indicated he wanted to go to Collingwood.
Chriss Judd - No We we're the better option but didn't have the picks, you did because you tanked!
Steve Johnson - No Failed a medical test I believe, his ankle.
J Brown - No Will not be going anywhere!!

Seems to be a pattern here !!!!!!

No not really!

Go Pies!

 

[Shangalang]

Mate nick stevens is not a high profile player. High cholesterol yes but not high profile.

Your right I would much prefer Shane O'Bree he is a jet !! Balance, silky skills, floaters he really has it all Mr O'Bree..

 

[lenny&carl]

If Mitch Brown stays out of contract and is homesick and says he wants to go to Collingwood, then we could get him cheap - 2nd round pick plus Shannon Cox?

 

[UltraMagnus]

Exactly!

Better than getting a packet of chips for return for Judd.

packet of chips ?

i think we did pretty well out of that trade considering he was going anyway, 3 young talented players in exchange for one player past his prime.

Dont get me wrong judd is still a good player but i think he's shown this year he will never be as good as he was. Carlton supporters keep saying "give him a full preseason" but the problem isnt his fitness its his groin so no ammount of training will fix that, just the opposite.

 

[Chase the Ace]

packet of chips ?

i think we did pretty well out of that trade considering he was going anyway, 3 young talented players in exchange for one player past his prime.

Dont get me wrong judd is still a good player but i think he's shown this year he will never be as good as he was. Carlton supporters keep saying "give him a full preseason" but the problem isnt his fitness its his groin so no ammount of training will fix that, just the opposite.

Judd is 24 isn't he?

 

[Mental Magpie]

Irrelevant - when was the last time Collingwood actually attracted a high profile player that htey were chaing to their club lets see...

Fraser Gehrig - No
Nick Stevens - No
Chriss Judd - No
Steve Johnson - No
J Brown - No

Seems to be a pattern here !!!!!!

You seriously have no idea. Out of that list of players, the only one we chased (made an offer to) was J Brown.
If you remember correctly; Steven's wanted to come to the Pies. He chose us. We wouldn't bow to Ports ridiculous request for the trade. That's how Carlton ended up with him.

Fraser Gehrig - Not chased
Nick Stevens - Not chased
Chriss Judd - Not Chased - Chose the Blues
Steve Johnson - Not chased
J Brown - Still chasing!!!!!!! LOL

 

[Mental Magpie]

100% got a piss weak infraction yestday

I'm still banned from that Board.

How funny!