Judd '05-'06 V Ablett '07-'08

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

who got the brownlow?
who got a norm smith?
who has the most club best & fairest?
who has made the most all-australian teams?

JUDD!

AS BB said, your logic is terrible

 

[SA HAWK]

Why Judd '05? He had an average year (despite a decent finals campaign) - he wasn't even All Australian.

Based on those two years for each - Ablett. Two stellar years vs. one.

I agree with this one. Ablett just. Judd won his brownlow in 04 don't forget.

I also think abletts gf game this year was easily better than judds when he won the norm smith.

 

[Quinz]

Who got 2 MVP's, which are more respectable than brownlows.

Anyway Ablett only lost by 2 votes and if he didn't miss those 5 games with injury he would definately have won it.

And if Judd hadn't been injured in 07 he would have won the MVP and the Brownlow by a mile the way he was going.

 

[STC]

Who got 2 MVP's, which are more respectable than brownlows.

Anyway Ablett only lost by 2 votes and if he didn't miss those 5 games with injury he would definately have won it.

And he deserved a Norm Smith, and he deserved another B&F, which like his Brownlow, he only missed out because he missed 5 games.

 

[Carlton_Blues]

who got the brownlow?
who got a norm smith?
who has the most club best & fairest?
who has made the most all-australian teams?

JUDD!

Judd all the way!

 

[Big Nasty]

Problem with this poll is your gonna get 2 sets of biased fans for Judd, as oppossed to 1 set of biased fans for Ablett.

 

[__aria__]

Problem with this poll is your gonna get 2 sets of biased fans for Judd, as oppossed to 1 set of biased fans for Ablett.

or maybe judd was better and it's obvious to everyone but geelong fans

 

[Kaladin Stormblessed]

Problem with this poll is your gonna get 2 sets of biased fans for Judd, as oppossed to 1 set of biased fans for Ablett.

What about 14 sets of Judd haters???

 

[wce4premiership]

Problem with this poll is your gonna get 2 sets of biased fans for Judd, as oppossed to 1 set of biased fans for Ablett.

lol talk shit.

What about everyone who hates judd now, including a lot of eagles supporters.

 

[alberto_cat]

One player over their 2 years recieved 2 x All Australian Starter, 2 x AFLPA MVPs, 2 x AFLCA MVPs, 1 x The Age POTY, 1 x Herald Sun POTY, 1 x Premiership, 0 x Norm Smith, 1 x Club B&F...

The other player over their 2 years recieved 1 x All Australian Starter, 1 x AFLPA MVPs, 0 x AFLCA MVPs, 0 x The Age POTY, 0 x Herald Sun POTY, 1 x Premiership (as captain), 1 x Norm Smith, 1 Club B&F, 1 GOTY...

Now if you showed me these two options, I'd happily take the first one, given that the question clearly states that the comparison is only over 2 years.