Roast Judd

[Blue Bawls]

If we're going to nail to the wall everyone who "played poorly" in the first half, then Judd should be included. Apparently we haven't taken into consideration the almost fanatical fervour that Adelaide used to crowd the ball and nullify possible disposal in the first two quarters so that even CJ was found wanting - only 50% effective I heard at one stage.

Shame on you Judd for not singlehandedly shutting down a team that played out of their skins, for getting caught with the ball by 2-3 opposition players who showed intensity the likes we've not seen since we played Hawthorn. Shame on you for failing to hit targets in that hour of extreme opposition pressure, for succumbing to the implied pressure that hurried your decisions, for not setting an example for everyone else to rise to.

Right, so he's the guy at the top of the list... who's next?

 

[R Truth]

Judd did not play a good game last week but this week he will Bounce back.

 

[incog43]

I thought I saw Jezza bludging on a wing...not sure..

 

[R Truth]

I just dont know how he could have had a bad game we realy should have won.

 

[NWTYRX]

He doesn't play well against Adelaide at anytime. Only averaging 20 disposals in 12 games

 

[R Truth]

Next time we play Adelaide we should win and Judd will play a good game you would think.

 

[Blue Bawls]

*sigh*

 

[Silvagnis]

After 30 games in Navy Blue, Judd should have assimilated every other member of the 22 like Agent Smith so they can play to his level and talent. Judd should also be able to beat four players single handedly and burst out of gang tackles to kick the winning goal. Anything less than that isn't good enough and proof that we should have kept Kennedy and picks three and 20.

What were we thinking?

2007 was the last chance Carlton had to draft young footballers.

 

[out of harmes' way]

Even the greats are entitled to a bad day every now and again. Quite clearly targeted-as is the case every week- and at certain stages tackled by four crows.

 

[R Truth]

I somewhat agree with you we should have kept Kennedy and still got Judd.

Just give someone eles and not Kennedy.

 

[Bluebear]

Right, so he's the guy at the top of the list... who's next?

I can't believe our runner escapes criticism..........and the water dude with the Tommy Alvin hair......can't be anything but a distraction for the players.

 

[Blue Bawls]

After 30 games in Navy Blue, Judd should have assimilated every other member of the 22 like Agent Smith so they can play to his level and talent. Judd should also be able to beat four players single handedly and burst out of gang tackles to kick the winning goal. Anything less than that isn't good enough and proof that we should have kept Kennedy and picks three and 20.

What were we thinking?

2007 was the last chance Carlton had to draft young footballers.

Hehe - thank god somebody saw this thread in the vain in which it was intended...

 

[Blue Bawls]

I can't believe our runner escapes criticism..........and the water dude with the Tommy Alvin hair......can't be anything but a distraction for the players.

Didn't we get a free kick from their runner being in our forward 50? That'll be the next humiliation for us...

 

[MBIB]

I can't believe our runner escapes criticism..........and the water dude with the Tommy Alvin hair......can't be anything but a distraction for the players.

I think Judd missed out on getting water late in the second quarter. Sack the water boy

 

[MBIB]

Didn't we get a free kick from their runner being in our forward 50? That'll be the next humiliation for us...

That happened a few years back when Peter Dean was our runner

 

[Faz 2000]

Selwood >>>>>>> Judd and it's not even close.

 

[Malifice]

Hack. Total Hack. Shit Shit Shit. If he ever pulls on the Carlton jumper again I will punch Ratten in the face. A disgrac...

Hang on - isnt this the weekly Russell thread?

 

[bodazoka]

I somewhat agree with you we should have kept Kennedy and still got Judd.

Just give someone eles and not Kennedy.

In truth you blokes probably could of kept Kennedy. I dont see what other options we would of had, we couldnt of traded him to anyone else really. And he was un contracted so he could of walked anywhere he wanted without any say from us.

Mabye the AFL interviened?? or mabye the coaching staff there really didnt rate the big guy at all.

*EDIT* feel a bit sorry for Kennedy actually.. been through the wringer at Carlton when you guys were loosing games and then traded to another team in the rebuilding phase just when you start to win games. Has only been in one winning game for us.

 

[Sam The Doc]

reckon Hadley has been pretty disappointing.
thoughts?

 

[Jack TY]

If we're going to nail to the wall everyone who "played poorly" in the first half, then Judd should be included. Apparently we haven't taken into consideration the almost fanatical fervour that Adelaide used to crowd the ball and nullify possible disposal in the first two quarters so that even CJ was found wanting - only 50% effective I heard at one stage.

Shame on you Judd for not singlehandedly shutting down a team that played out of their skins, for getting caught with the ball by 2-3 opposition players who showed intensity the likes we've not seen since we played Hawthorn. Shame on you for failing to hit targets in that hour of extreme opposition pressure, for succumbing to the implied pressure that hurried your decisions, for not setting an example for everyone else to rise to.

Right, so he's the guy at the top of the list... who's next?

Would be nice if Carlton did these things.......... you know, just for a change

 

[Jack TY]

reckon Hadley has been pretty disappointing.
thoughts?

Started the season in fantastic fashion but now just looks slow, not finding the footy enough and isn't clean with his possesions when he does.