Just a neutral Comment

[hahaha]

But I don't think St.Kilda can win the flag carrying Fisher, Schwarze, Fiora, McGough and old Maxy boy in their side.

They are just a class below the AFL standard let alone a premiership standard.

Do you guys agree with this or can you see something I can't?

 

[R Man]

But I don't think St.Kilda can win the flag carrying Fisher, Schwarze, Fiora, McGough and old Maxy boy in their side.

They are just a class below the AFL standard let alone a premiership standard.

Do you guys agree with this or can you see something I can't?

Yeah, thats a fair call 'hahaha' and I welcome your opinion... One can't judge the season on one match, and I have been critical in other threads, notably the 'About Reiwoldt' thread with a couple of players... I love Maxie for his courage and passion; his downside can be his skills and judging of the play.. top players have murdered him on occasions..but every backman has their horror day. Sam Fisher I think needs more games.. he did appear to be a little bit nervous on occasions last night, dropping an easy mark that was costly in the circumstances of the match.. Fiora, although he got the ball on a few occasions.. needs to prove to the StKilda faithful that he will put his body on the line for the club and take his second chance at AFL by the throat.. His skills can be divine at times.. and on occasions he can make stuff ups you wouldnt see at local level.

I was impressed with Schwarze last night.. I really think he is/will take the next step this year.. I really believe Troy can be a very handy attacking defender this year..
McGough needs desperately to add a few metres in his pace.. It was found out last night.. he will be pivotal in the winter.

What our side needs is someone like a Brendan Goddard to take his game to the next level.. He knows it and so do the StKilda members/supporters.. Number 1 NATIONAL draft pick and in his 3rd season.. this is his defining year where clubs have to think more closely about 'who gets put on Goddard.' He has it in him, we've all been saying it.. But he is one of many keys to the StKilda Football club creating their own destiny...

 

[evertonfc]

St Kilda look fine to most astute pundits.

Last night was just a terrific game of footy that could have gone either way.

Good luck to Essendon. And yes, you'll need it.

 

[Tezmyster]

But I don't think St.Kilda can win the flag carrying Fisher, Schwarze, Fiora, McGough and old Maxy boy in their side.

They are just a class below the AFL standard let alone a premiership standard.

Do you guys agree with this or can you see something I can't?

You only need to make top 8 to make the finals and have a shot at the premiership, in my book St Kilda is still a top 8 team even after the injuries and possible suspensions from last night.

 

[Tim the Toolman]

Bit harsh on Fiora. I thought he carved us up in spots on Thursday?

 

[Fassbasstd]

St Kilda look fine to most astute pundits.

But they look like a one man band to everyone else.

Up the toffees!!!!!

 

[Tezmyster]

But they look like a one man band to everyone else.

Up the toffees!!!!!

nah, the Saints do have some good players, it will just be interesting to see how well they hold together over the weeks Riewoldt is out.

 

[hahaha]

Good luck to Essendon. And yes, you'll need it.

Big Understatement.

Need a new coach, too much margin for error in our game plan.