Rabish Binney
Left out overnight
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2021
- Posts
- 3,264
- Reaction score
- 4,777
- Location
- Off the land, rural SA
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Sturt; Man City
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Fantasy Footy Notice Image Round 12
SuperCoach Rd 12 SC Talk - Trade Talk - Capt/VC - 2026 Fight MND Comp ,//, AFL Fantasy Rd 12 AFF Talk - AF Trades - Capt/VC
I'm staggered that no-one has ever called out or questioned Michaël Vaughan over his players using mints in the 2005 ashes.Yep. This is what annoys the hell out of me with England. They are quick to look down their noses at anything they perceive to be unsportsmanlike from other countries, but history is littered with England cheating or bending rules to suit their own needs. The recent Ashes series was the final straw for me.
Lol, loving the own goals the England team keeps dishing out trying to drum up sympathy on this "incident".Broad said he called Cummins an 'absolute disgrace'. Cummins simply said to Broad 'oh yeah, you're hardly an up keeper of the spirit of cricket'.
Unsurprising, since in order to do that one would have to actually speak to Michael Vaughan which is something I think everyone can agree is best avoided.I'm staggered that no-one has ever called out or questioned Michaël Vaughan over his players using mints in the 2005 ashes.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
We can only hope that Bairstow is selected in their Ashes squad in 2 years time.The entire whinging falls down due to Bairstow doing dodgier s**t previously (trying it with Marnus, and stumping someone in County who NEVER LEFT THEIR CREASE) - but, even more so; Stokes reviewing the Smith catch, when he knew he dropped it.
Any (alleged) moral high ground they had relating to the 'spirit of cricket' was shown to be a complete joke at that point.
Their ******* sooks, and I think it'll take them a long time to regain any respect in Australian (and world) Cricket circles.
Glad to hear Cummins gave that retort, simple but spot on.
the fact that he also did it IN THE SAME MATCH but missed is infuriating about the whole scenario tooif Bairstow did that to one of our batsman, he would have been hailed as a hero.....
Please don't get me started on ball tampering. Just about every other country has been guilty of it, some more than once. Australia has been the only country with the balls to suspend people for it, and yet other countries call us cheats. It really grinds my gears. I'm happy to accept punishment for the Aussie players, but I'm not happy to have other countries (especially England) looking down their noses at us.I'm staggered that no-one has ever called out or questioned Michaël Vaughan over his players using mints in the 2005 ashes.
It was rumored to be happening at the time and none of the English press were interested (or didn't want to) in chasing it up (Trescothick admitted to it in his autobiography years later).
Vaughan would have known what was going on.
And yet on the 2019 ashes tour, Vaughan and the rest of the pommy crowds dined out on the ball tampering affair - all in the knowledge of what happened in 2005.
And on the Carey run out - if Bairstow did that to one of our batsman, he would have been hailed as a hero......
100% the Aussies we're likely to miss a game or two under the ICC punishment for ball tampering (at worst), only cause we actually believe I'm the spirit of cricket did we step in and do more.Please don't get me started on ball tampering. Just about every other country has been guilty of it, some more than once. Australia has been the only country with the balls to suspend people for it, and yet other countries call us cheats. It really grinds my gears. I'm happy to accept punishment for the Aussie players, but I'm not happy to have other countries (especially England) looking down their noses at us.
The poms have been doing it way earlier than the 1930s. WG Grace one of the biggest cheats in the 19th century ran out Aussie Sammy Jones in the 1882 test series when he walked out of his crease to tap the pitch down with his bat. Or when the Poms using Vaseline to shine the ball in the 70s against india. But 'spirit of cricket' and all that.There is nothing more hilarious than a pommy trying to take the high moral ground.
A short history:
1932 Bodyline - Instigated by the Poms.
1979 England tour of Australia - Lords refused to put the Ashes up for grabs (albeit it was only a 3 test series) but they knew, with the WSC players back that they would get thumped.
1995 - Michael Atherton fined for shining the ball with dirt that was in his pocket.
2005 - Marcus Trescothick admits in his biography that English players used breath mints to help shine the ball. Michaël Vaughan (who was captain of that side and would have known what was going on) was one of the most vehement critics of Warner and Smith.
2013 - Campaigner Broad refuses to walk despite hitting the cover off the ball (FWIW I don't think that a batsman should walk but there's no way Broad can take any high moral ground when it comes to the 'spirit of cricket')
2018 - The ECCB cut the residency requirements from seven years to three for overseas cricketers to qualify to play for England.....just in time so that Jofra Archer could play in the 2019 series.
I'm amazed that no-one from the mainstream media has ever challenged or called out Vaughan for his part in the 2005 series
What does everyone think of this stumping at 3:56:46?
I agree with you and as a batsman I’d never get out like that. As a captain I wouldn’t have appealed for that and I would’ve withdrawn the appeal. Totally different to the Carey/Bairstow one.They paint that line for a reason.
I know the parents of and the captain of that side. He said that they even sledged the batter as she walked off and he thought that it was hilarious.This one is a legit grey area. I think not out. The ball imo was dead and the umpire had clicked his counter over.
The batsman copped it sweet though. Good on her.
Ahead of Jonny Bairstow's 100th test, Joe Root paid tribute to the red headed Yorkshireman. Root finished his little speech by reminding Bairstow to stay in his crease. Not sure Jonny found it funny but St Brendan found it hilarious which is ironic given his almighty sook about Bairstow's famous dismissal on day 5 of the Lord's test last year.
Imagine the outcry if this was executed today at the top level.
Deliberate wide (an infringement) leading to a wicket. Just not in the spirit of the game.