Kildonan's Player Assessments - Week 1

[Kildonan]

[B]Wk1  Player[/B]
[COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR]   Nick Dal Santo
[COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR]   Nick Riewoldt
[COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR]   Sam Fisher
[COLOR="SeaGreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Max Hudghton
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Jarryn Geary
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD [/COLOR]  Steven King
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Leigh Fisher
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Leigh Montagna
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Lenny Hayes
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Xavier Clarke
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Charlie Gardiner
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Luke Ball
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Michael Gardiner
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Robert Harvey
[COLOR="seagreen"]GD[/COLOR]   Sam Gilbert
FR   Raphael Clarke
FR   Jason Gram
FR   Aaron Fiora
FR   Adam Schneider
FR   Clinton Jones
FR   Justin Koschitzke
FR   Stephen Milne

 

[Rough_Edges]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

Very good as always but perhaps a bit harsh on Koschitzke?

2 goals - 3 behinds...5 shots on goal. He converts 4 of them and he gets a VG.

He should get a Gd for me.

 

[St DAC]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

If you only get a handfull of opportunities you need to make the most of them. Kosi missed some very gettable goals. I agree with Kildonan; only fair.

 

[Squizz]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

Kildonan - would like to see the "PR" used, like with the pre-season assessment. Fair to me indicates they were OK - a couple weren't. Otherwise seemed about right.

 

[TassieSaint]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

Yeah I would have put Kozi as a Good. Also if you think about it what more could Leigh Fisher have done right? His job was to nullify the influence of one of the games best players and he did just that, not much more he could have done right so I would have considered having him a very good. But otherwise pretty spot on I reckon.

 

[Rough_Edges]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

Wowee, L Fisher only a good.

A Very Good without a doubt.

Holding goodes to 7 possessions, fantastic!

 

[Kildonan]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

Kildonan - would like to see the "PR" used, like with the pre-season assessment. Fair to me indicates they were OK - a couple weren't. Otherwise seemed about right.

I felt that there were no poor efforts last week, so that explains why I didn't use it

 

[bluejay]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

I agree with all Kildonan's assessments but with Lenny, as I though he was very good. Not spectacular but, as nearly always, he delivers all his arsenal in the middle and never goes missing even when tagged fiercely.

 

[Squizz]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

I felt that there were no poor efforts last week, so that explains why I didn't use it

OK - just like to see a bit of granularity! (having Fiora and Kosi and the same grading wouldn't seem right).

Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair, Poor (or maybe Ordinary, Very Bloody Ordinary and Shite).

 

[Kildonan]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments



I have a numerical record which I wont post, but it is my assessment which uses some of the available stats and I give bonuses for extraordinary efforts and intangible stats (an example is Goodes or Hall's average SC score minus the score they produced Sat night = taggers bonus)

 

[Cohzee]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

Did Kosi do anything of value tonight? From what I heard he deserves the rating Kildonan gave him.

 

[Rough_Edges]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

Did Kosi do anything of value tonight? From what I heard he deserves the rating Kildonan gave him.

these are the ratings for last week, 'mate'

 

[Cohzee]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

these are the ratings for last week, 'mate'

Defensive much?

But I thought he was better last week than he was this week. OK?

 

[Rough_Edges]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

How was that defensive at all?

 

[Cohzee]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

How was that defensive at all?

Unnecessary sarcasm.

 

[Rough_Edges]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

I didn't see any smily.

No sarcasm at all tbh.

Just explaining to you what happened.

 

[Cohzee]

Re: Kildonan's Player Assessments

these are the ratings for last week, 'mate'

That is all.