List Cloggers?

[Jumpin' Jimmy]

Ok lets see the stats... 7 games and 3 of them he was close ____ing shitful. How wrong was l?

Tosser

What a Wally you are. Unable to admit you got it wrong. McMahon has done many things including allowing us to tell Bowden and Tivendale to "shape up or else" even with Raines unavailable.

 

[Wally Matera]

What a Wally you are. Unable to admit you got it wrong. McMahon has done many things including allowing us to tell Bowden and Tivendale to "shape up or else" even with Raines unavailable.

Ok.. l'm the joke.

Since when has Tivvo ever played off a half-back flank?

Where has Bowden been playing the last 2 years? Answer: CHB. Now, Bowden was dropped because poor defensive skills and his intent on not tackling.

Where has McMahon improved us in these areas?

A - he doesnt tackle either
B - he doesnt play in a key defensive role
C - he still doesnt hit a target (Bowden did)

The only value in McMahon is he is quick, carries the pill and moves it quickly. Which is great in theory, but not when you continue to turn it over.

Raines is injured you tool.

Thank-you, come again.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

What a Wally you are. Unable to admit you got it wrong. McMahon has done many things including allowing us to tell Bowden and Tivendale to "shape up or else" even with Raines unavailable.

Will agree with Wally on this McMahon is overrated. He very rarely hits targets in the corridor, and struggles to compete one on one with his direct opponent. He has been towelled up significantly this year whilst playing on a wing or half forward. No greater example than the first 1/4 and a half rnd 1 v Carlton. To hit a target when kicking to a wing where the target is 20-30 meters clear doesn't make him a good player with exception skill. When he clearly beats his direct opponent in a tight game I will give him credit , but at the moment he's blocking the process of developing another junior who is prepared to compete. Will go down as one of the clubs worst ever trades, just hope it doesn't effect our list management to much.

 

[Wally Matera]

Will agree with Wally on this McMahon is overrated. He very rarely hits targets in the corridor, and struggles to compete one on one with his direct opponent. He has been towelled up significantly this year whilst playing on a wing or half forward. No greater example than the first 1/4 and a half rnd 1 v Carlton. To hit a target when kicking to a wing where the target is 20-30 meters clear doesn't make him a good player with exception skill. When he clearly beats his direct opponent in a tight game I will give him credit , but at the moment he's blocking the process of developing another junior who is prepared to compete. Will go down as one of the clubs worst ever trades, just hope it doesn't effect our list management to much.

Bada BING

However, l dont think he'll be recognised as one of the worst trades ever. He has far too many to compete with.

Where do l start:

Paul Hudson
Shane Morrison
Justin Blumfield
Paul Biddiscombe
Clay Sampson

And, not sure who the dogs picked up for pick 19... but it may not hurt us too much. But you're right, McMahon is very very average. And pitiful against top opposition.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Now back onto the thread title , I believe Tivendale, Hyde, McMahon are all list cloggers and still are extremely concerned about Polak, Raines and Hughes. In saying that Hydes form is currently as good as it has ever been. Rookieing Howat is also a clogging of the list.