Matthew Warnock

[AllenJakovich13]

Warnock has been thrown around a bit during the trade week and is apparently wanting more opportunities elsewhere. He is 26 and in his prime.

Whats he worth and which clubs do you think would want him? Have heard Carlton, Hawthorn & St Kilda so far.

 

[AP Erebus]

I just posted this in the Melbourne boards rumour thread... Found via Saintsational via Sportal forums...

"Trade murmur: Sam on the email: A deal has been done between St.Kilda and Melbourne. Robert Eddy and Jarryn Geary to Melbourne for Matthew Warnock, just soughting out a shuffle of draft picks."

Off Foxsports

http://forum.sportal.com.au/yaf_postsm2113766_Potential-player-movement.aspx#post2113766

 

[Skippos]

WOuld be a very very good deal for the dees getting rid of a guy they dropped this year and is surplus for two young kids.

 

[AP Erebus]

WOuld be a very very good deal for the dees getting rid of a guy they dropped this year and is surplus for two young kids.

Are they the type of player that Melbourne needs though?

Both getting better, but not overly pacy.

Geary is a ok small defender (in the Baker mould)

 

[On the bench]

I just posted this in the Melbourne boards rumour thread... Found via Saintsational via Sportal forums...


http://forum.sportal.com.au/yaf_postsm2113766_Potential-player-movement.aspx#post2113766

If true i would be happy with Jarryn Geary,they can keep Eddy!

 

[The Professor]

Are they the type of player that Melbourne needs though?

Both getting better, but not overly pacy.

Geary is a ok small defender (in the Baker mould)

No. That's a terrible deal fro MFC.

 

[Spirit of 39]

Geary and Eddy are list cloggers of the highest order.

 

[BigSexc]

Geary and Eddy are list cloggers of the highest order.

100% true

 

[Neville Bartos]

Does this mean we can trade Gary Moss and Beau Muston for Warnock? If so, I'll sign the papers myself!

 

[Bartram_Class]

Harrington confirmed today Warnock was a required player and we weren't entertaining offers.

Next.

 

[Neville Bartos]

Is he contracted? Where will he fit into your backline?

B: Garland - Frawley - Bartram
HB: MacDonald - Rivers - Davey

 

[Bartram_Class]

Is he contracted? Where will he fit into your backline?

B: Garland - Frawley - Bartram
HB: MacDonald - Rivers - Davey

Contracted for 2011.

Certainly not in our first-choice back six, but he's a great depth player to have. Trade Warnock away and when Rivers or Frawley go down, we'd have to turn to Tommy McNamara who would struggle.

 

[Igloo]

Harrington confirmed today Warnock was a required player and we weren't entertaining offers.

Next.

The club HAS to say they are a required player if they are contracted.
We said Everitt was required 2 days before we traded him

 

[Easy Slips Catch]

Harrington confirmed today Warnock was a required player and we weren't entertaining offers.

Next.

Really surprised we are not having a real dip at Warnock.

Cant see what is in it for Warnock. The Ds have better options and he will struggle to get a run. He'd walk into our FB spot.

 

[ROB48]

Warnock will play games this year, his form slipped a bit last year but he is ok, I for one would be unhappy if we lost him. He is tall has a bit of aggro and is quite quick so when the right match ups are there he will be in. Rivers is keeping him out at the moment but he has had a history of injury problems so we cannot afford to let Warnock go.

 

[RIOLIUSTAR]

Harrington confirmed today Warnock was a required player and we weren't entertaining offers.

Next.

PHEW...I was getting worried we might entertain picking him up

 

[die hard dee]

PHEW...I was getting worried we might entertain picking him up

you could do a lot bloody worse....like Bret Thornton which has been rumoured

 

[RIOLIUSTAR]

you could do a lot bloody worse....like Bret Thornton which has been rumoured

Yeah I hear ya... but that was a rumour and we know what they're worth at the minute

 

[Demon 16]

you could do a lot bloody worse....like Bret Thornton which has been rumoured

..or David Hale.

But seriously - Mathew Warnock is definately a player. He shouldnt be playing VFL footy.

 

[melbournemartin]

Robert Eddy must be extremely valuable after his two Grand Finals

I can see why Lyon left him out of the 2009 one.

 

[Radical Roo]

Yeah this baffles me, Warnock is 26, Hale is 26, we do with a key back, melbourne can do with a backup ruck who could kick 20 goals a year. Whats the problem here?

 

[Roosurgence]

Yeah this baffles me, Warnock is 26, Hale is 26, we do with a key back, melbourne can do with a backup ruck who could kick 20 goals a year. Whats the problem here?

If Hale is a spud then Warnock is the sprout that grows out of potatoes when you leave them in the pantry too long.

I'm guessing Casey hope Melbourne delist him or do a mercy trade, so they don't have to give the dud a game anymore.

 

[Demon 16]

If Hale is a spud then Warnock is the sprout that grows out of potatoes when you leave them in my panties too long.

You are sick.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Yeah this baffles me, Warnock is 26, Hale is 26, we do with a key back, melbourne can do with a backup ruck who could kick 20 goals a year. Whats the problem here?

Pretty simple really, the following summaries it for me:

• Melbourne fans aren't banging on about Warnock being worth a first round draft pick, then spending 35 pages engaged in a pissing contest about every player on their list
• The MFC aren’t prostituting Warnock. He is a required player, clubs have inquired and been told nothing doing.
• He wasn’t signed up on a grossly negligent 4 year, $400,000 per year contract
• He would be teams like Hawthorn or Carlton’s best KPD, not a back up ruckman/forward decoy that is superfluous.

Norf supports need to get over their inferiority complex, particularly in respects to Melbourne.

 

[Roosurgence]

Pretty simple really, the following summaries it for me:

• Melbourne fans aren't banging on about Warnock being worth a first round draft pick, then spending 35 pages engaged in a pissing contest about every player on their list
• The MFC aren’t prostituting Warnock. He is a required player, clubs have inquired and been told nothing doing.
• He wasn’t signed up on a grossly negligent 4 year, $400,000 per year contract
• He would be teams like Hawthorn or Carlton’s best KPD, not a back up ruckman/forward decoy that is superfluous.

Norf supports need to get over their inferiority complex, particularly in respects to Melbourne.

LOL!

Josh Gibson plays better as a key defender than Warnock and he isn't even key defender size.

Jamieson has more talent in his left toe than Warnock.

We can spend 35 pages of talking about how shit Warnock is, if that will keep you happy?