Remove this Banner Ad

Melbourne: Player List

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

The Passenger

The passenger, I am...
Veteran 10k Posts 30k Posts Sensible Type WCE Wings Guernsey
Joined
Mar 25, 2003
Posts
35,681
Reaction score
28,351
i'm trying to compile a database for Footy Fanatic (amongst other things) and just posting the guys on your list in the order i believe to be the best players to the worst on your list.

Please feel free to comment on any players i have grossly out of position in terms of their rank, positions, D/O/B, State of Origin etc,. etc,.

also it would be good if you could tell me what guys have now made their debuts

I am also unaware of who are the veterans on any AFL list.

Also note I have players approximate salaries on here. If any of these are majorly off just let me know, and if any of you know how what guys are off contract at years end, or how long to some of the guys on the team are coming off contract it would be appreciated. The salary cap for the game is $5,500,000 and the total salary for Melbourne is around $5,400,000 (about 97.5%)

Rank, Club, First Name, Surname, DOB, Hgt, Wgt, Debut, Type, SOO, KPP, Pos1, Pos2, Pos3, Salary
1, Melbourne, David, Neitz, 22/01/1975, 193, 101, 1993, Normal, Vic, Yes, F50, F50, For, $500,000
2, Melbourne, Jeff, White, 19/02/1977, 195, 95, 1995, Normal, Vic, Yes, Ruck, F50, Ruck, $460,000
3, Melbourne, Adem, Yze, 21/09/1977, 186, 89, 1995, Normal, Vic, No, Mid, B50, Back, $410,000
4, Melbourne, Cameron, Bruce, 30/09/1979, 190, 85, 2000, Normal, Vic, No, Mid, For, For, $210,000
5, Melbourne, Russell, Robertson, 24/11/1978, 184, 86, 1997, Normal, Tas, No, For, F50, For, $360,000
6, Melbourne, Clint, Bizzell, 28/06/1976, 188, 89, 1996, Normal, Qld, Yes, Back, B50, Back, $220,000
7, Melbourne, Brad, Green, 13/03/1981, 183, 84, 2000, Normal, Tas, No, For, F50, Mid, $150,000
8, Melbourne, Scott, Thompson, 14/03/1983, 184, 80, 2001, Normal, SA, No, Mid, For, For, $125,000
9, Melbourne, Jared, Rivers, 18/10/1984, 191, 85, 2003, Normal, SA, Yes, Back, Back, B50, $ 70,000
10, Melbourne, Matthew, Whelan, 13/11/1979, 180, 83, 2000, Normal, NT, No, B50, Back, Mid, $105,000
11, Melbourne, Travis, Johnstone, 17/07/1980, 186, 83, 1998, Normal, Vic, No, Mid, Wing, Mid, $180,000
12, Melbourne, Nathan D., Brown, 14/08/1976, 180, 78, 1998, Normal, SA, No, Mid, Back, Wing, $160,000
13, Melbourne, Ben, Holland, 10/05/1977, 197, 100, 1996, Normal, SA, Yes, Back, Ruck, For, $185,000
14, Melbourne, Paul, Wheatley, 12/04/1981, 189, 89, 2000, Normal, Vic, No, B50, Back, B50, $130,000
15, Melbourne, James, McDonald, 05/10/1976, 180, 78, 1997, Normal, Vic, No, Mid, For, Mid, $165,000
16, Melbourne, Aaron, Davey, 10/06/1983, 177, 67, ****, Rookie, Vic, No, F50, F50, For, $ 30,000
17, Melbourne, Phillip, Read, 20/10/1979, 178, 78, 1998, Normal, WA, No, Mid, Back, Mid, $ 80,000
18, Melbourne, Brad, Miller, 06/07/1983, 192, 89, 2002, Normal, Qld, Yes, For, Back, For, $100,000
19, Melbourne, Steven, Armstrong, 12/01/1984, 180, 79, 2002, Normal, WA, No, Mid, For, Mid, $115,000
20, Melbourne, Simon, Godfrey, 18/10/1980, 184, 83, 2000, Normal, Vic, No, Mid, Back, Mid, $115,000
21, Melbourne, Alistair, Nicholson, 04/03/1978, 197, 103, 1997, Normal, WA, Yes, B50, B50, B50, $125,000
22, Melbourne, Chris, Heffernan, 29/01/1979, 186, 83, 1997, Normal, Vic, No, Back, Mid, Back, $160,000
23, Melbourne, Darren, Jolly, 06/11/1981, 198, 95, 2001, Normal, Vic, Yes, Ruck, Ruck, Ruck, $110,000
24, Melbourne, Daniel, Ward, 09/07/1977, 185, 83, 1998, Normal, Vic, No, Mid, Back, Wing, $ 90,000
25, Melbourne, Peter, Walsh, 24/07/1976, 180, 84, 1999, Normal, SA, No, Back, Back, B50, $120,000
26, Melbourne, Mark, Jamar, 09/08/1983, 197, 95, 2003, Normal, SA, Yes, Ruck, Ruck, Ruck, $100,000
27, Melbourne, Nathan, Carroll, 20/10/1980, 191, 90, 2003, Normal, WA, Yes, B50, Back, B50, $ 85,000
28, Melbourne, Troy, Broadbridge, 05/10/1980, 189, 88, 2001, Normal, SA, No, B50, Back, B50, $ 80,000
29, Melbourne, Guy, Rigoni, 27/07/1974, 181, 84, 1998, Normal, Vic, No, Mid, Mid, Back, $125,000
30, Melbourne, Peter, Vardy, 26/01/1976, 181, 83, 1996, Normal, SA, No, F50, For, F50, $ 90,000
31, Melbourne, Brock, McLean, 11/03/1986, 183, 86, ****, Normal, Vic, No, Mid, Mid, Mid, $ 30,000
32, Melbourne, Luke, Williams, 29/12/1979, 185, 79, 1999, Normal, Vic, No, Back, Back, Back, $ 30,000
33, Melbourne, Colin, Sylvia, 08/11/1985, 184, 85, ****, Normal, Vic, No, Mid, For, Mid, $ 30,000
34, Melbourne, Daniel, Bell, 13/04/1985, 186, 82, ****, Normal, SA, No, For, Mid, Back, $ 30,000
35, Melbourne, Ryan, Ferguson, 29/09/1981, 195, 85, 2003, Normal, Vic, Yes, Back, B50, B50, $ 45,000
36, Melbourne, Chris, Lamb, 11/03/1981, 192, 94, 1999, Normal, Vic, Yes, Back, B50, Back, $ 55,000
37, Melbourne, Chris, Johnson, 25/01/1986, 188, 78, ****, Normal, WA, No, For, F50, Wing, $ 30,000
38, Melbourne, Nick, Smith, 27/08/1984, 195, 91, 2003, Normal, SA, Yes, F50, Ruck, For, $ 30,000
39, Melbourne, Adam, Fisher, 11/04/1984, 180, 80, ****, Rookie, Vic, No, Mid, For, F50, $ 30,000
40, Melbourne, Cameron, Hunter, 30/03/1984, 183, 64, 2003, Normal, Vic, No, F50, For, F50, $ 30,000
41, Melbourne, Luke, Molan, 13/12/1983, 192, 92, ****, Rookie, Vic, Yes, Back, B50, For, $ 30,000
42, Melbourne, Joel, Campbell, 21/12/1985, 181, 78, ****, Rookie, Vic, No, , , , $ 30,000
43, Melbourne, Paul, Newman, , , , , Rookie, Vic, , , , , $ 30,000
44, Melbourne, Dale, Carson, 12/05/1984, 192, 88, ****, Rookie, Vic, Yes, F50, For, F50, $ 30,000

No Idea of any ideas for what Paul Newman's positions or attributes are, whilst i wasn't able to find out where Joel Campbell plays at.


please feel free to comment. I know not all are going to be right so it helps me if you tell me that because i would like to make this as accurate as possible.
 
Robertson too high, Bizzell and Johnstone too low.

IMO:

1. Neitz
2. Yze
3. Bizzell
4. Bruce
5. White
6. Johnstone
7. Green
8. Rivers
9. Robertson
10. Thompson
11. McDonald
12. Holland
13. Whelan
14. Heffernan
15. Brown
16. Davey
17. Wheatley
18. Ward
19. Read
20. Armstrong
 
Originally posted by lamby29
Robertson too high, Bizzell and Johnstone too low.

IMO:

1. Neitz
2. Yze
3. Bizzell
4. Bruce
5. White
6. Johnstone
7. Green
8. Rivers
9. Robertson
10. Thompson
11. McDonald
12. Holland
13. Whelan
14. Heffernan
15. Brown
16. Davey
17. Wheatley
18. Ward
19. Read
20. Armstrong

this would be my top 20 or so

Nietz
Yze
Bruce
Bizzell
White
Green
Robertson
Johnstone
Thompson
Mcdonald
Rivers
Brown
Heffernan
Whelan
Wheatley
Nicholson
Jolly
Ward
Davey
Vardy
Holland
Armstong
Read
Miller
Godfrey
Walsh
Broadbridge
Carroll
Williams
Jamar
Lamb
Fergeson


Not taken into consideration: mclean, bell, sylvia, smith

also you have davey on rookie list but he aint in real life anymore
 
We have no veterans & that's why Davey is able to play seniors as a Nominated rookie, a lot like your mate Aaron Rogers.

Paul Newman would be F50 D F KP yes

Campbell F D M i guess, KP no

1 Neitz
2 Yze
3 Bruce
4 White
5 Bizzell
6 Johnstone
7 Green
8 McDonald
9 Robertson
10 Rivers
11 Brown
12 Thompson
13 Heffernan


38 Johnson
39 Lamb
40 Fisher
41 Molan
42 Newman
43 Carson
44 Campbell


That'll do for now
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

1. Nietz
2. Yze
3. Bizzell
4. Bruce
5. Green
6. Whelan
7. Thompson
8. Johnstone
9. White
10. Rivers
11. Godfrey
12. Wheatley
13. Nicholson
14. Ward
15. Davey
16. McDonald
17. Brown
18. Read
19. Vardy
20. Miller
21. Armstrong
22. Jolly
23. Robertson
24. Broadbridge
25. Holland
26. Williams
27. Carroll
28. Jamar
29. Heffernan
30. Walsh
31. Rigoni
32. Lamb
 
Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
1. Nietz
2. Yze
3. Bizzell
4. Bruce
5. Green
6. Whelan
7. Thompson
8. Johnstone
9. White
10. Rivers
11. Godfrey
12. Wheatley
13. Nicholson
14. Ward
15. Davey
16. McDonald
17. Brown
18. Read
19. Vardy
20. Miller
21. Armstrong
22. Jolly
23. Robertson
24. Broadbridge
25. Holland
26. Williams
27. Carroll
28. Jamar
29. Heffernan
30. Walsh
31. Rigoni
32. Lamb

man u obviously didnt watch robertson play in the Melbourne vs west coast match
 
1. Neitz
2. Yze
3. Bizzell
4. White
5. Bruce
6. Green
7. Thompson
8. Rivers
9. Johnstone
10. Whelan
11. Robertson
12. Brown
13. Wheatley
14. McDonald
15. Nicholson
16. Davey
17. Miller
18. Ward
19. Heffernan
20. Armstrong
21. Holland
22. Read
23. Godfrey
24. Jolly
25. Vardy
26. Carroll
27. Smith
28. Sylvia
29. McLean
30. Bell
31. Walsh
32. Broadbridge
33. Rigoni
34. Jamar
35. Williams
36. Lamb
37. Johnson
38. Hunter
39. Ferguson
40. Fisher
41. Molan
42. Newman
43. Campbell
44. Carson
 
robbo aint ahd the best year and his choice as club champ last year might have been questionable but he still warrents a spot in the top 10 IMO
 
Originally posted by melbournemartin
robbo aint ahd the best year and his choice as club champ last year might have been questionable but he still warrents a spot in the top 10 IMO

Robbo is JUST out of mine.

It's bloody hard ranking our list though isn't it?
:)
 
1. Neitz (champion)
2. Bizzell (consistant and special)
3. White (the barometer of our success)
4. Yze (our second barometer of that exists)
5. Bruce (developing into a gun)
6. Green (starring on ball)
7. Robertson (the best and fairest)
8. Johnstone (potential not fully activated)
9. McDonald (vastly underrated and important)
10. Thompson (stepped up to the plate this year)

After that it is very hard. Heffernan, Whelan, Holland, Rivers, Nicholson, Brown, Wheatley, Vardy, Godfrey and Davey would be in the next category. Armstrong, Ward, Read, Jolly and Miller are next and then you wouyld have the young, but unproven guns like Jamar, McLean, Sylvia, Bell and Smith. Walsh, Rigoni, Broadbridge, Williams, Carroll and Lamb are lagging behind and then the other batch of youngsters and rookies at the end.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

cheers guys, anyone got details on Paul Newman such as date of birth, state, height and weight?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom