Meyers or Neagle?

[McLean_4_Captain]

Need a cheap back and I'm thinking that these essendon players are likely to keep getting a game under knights' youth policy. But i'm not sure who's a better player and which one is more likely to keep playing?

Or if there are are other sub 200,000 defenders that are better and going to keep getting a game, i'm open to suggestion.

I've already fallen for getting young NM defenders twice this year, the junk yard dog must be one of the most fustrating men in supercoach.

 

[lamaros]

I've said it elsewhere, I might as well say it here.

Myers. 10 times out of 10.

 

[OneEyedHawk]

I just had the same choice about 10 minutes ago. Went with Myers.

 

[footyfan_25]

Im going to do Edwards (Carl) to Myers

Edwards doesnt look close to getting a game and my other emerg Proud will only get the occational game. Therefore needed some backline cover.

Myers seems like he will hold his spot, especially with youth policy.

 

[Headless]

I went Myers..

 

[Tippaz]

wtf

Neagle for SuperCoach fellaz
last week
- 10 of his 11 possessions were contested
- 2 of his 3 marks were contested

 

[footyfan_25]

wtf

Neagle for SuperCoach fellaz
last week
- 10 of his 11 possessions were contested
- 2 of his 3 marks were contested

Contested possession means little when you use it at 55% effectiveness and 4 clangers.

Also played 30% more game time than Myers and still scored the same.

Myers also more likely to hold his spot throughout season.

Go MYERS

 

[Tippaz]

Myers also more likely to hold his spot throughout season.

no way dude.
i'm a pretty obsessed Essendon supporter. Neagle has impressed me. Myers has not.

Neagle is cool.

 

[d4vE]

still got this week to watch them play, and make you decision next week when they are to go up in value

 

[dougthelegend]

Myers will keep his spot, Neagle PROBABLY will, but when Lucas comes back his output may lower even if he stays in the side. I'd definatley go Myers.

 

[Impromptu]

Myers will keep his spot, Neagle PROBABLY will, but when Lucas comes back his output may lower even if he stays in the side. I'd definatley go Myers.

I'd go Myers due to his draft rankings...but I guess tomorrow's game will tell..and I think your comment about Lucas coming back is valid....

Donkey boy Lucas (my favourite player) will run a muck when he gets back..

 

[lamaros]

See why I said Myers?

 

[Team Mo']

no way dude.
i'm a pretty obsessed Essendon supporter. Neagle has impressed me. Myers has not.

Neagle is cool.

never give advice again

 

[Tippaz]

never give advice again

we'll see who's laughing after 5-10 games.

and i might point out that Neagle scored his 49pts from just 4 possessions.
i'm telling ya he's got the makings of a good SuperCoach pick.
in fact, i am supremely confident Neagle will outperform Myers barring injuries.
Neagle is a 3rd year player. Myers in his 1st. i see Neagle playing more games than Myers this year
i would argue the inclusions of Lucas & McPhee would only enhance Neagle's output because he'd draw lesser opponents.
26votes Myers vs 2votes Neagle... that's appalling... i commend the other bloke who voted for him.

 

[jimbob7085]

i voted for neagle tippaz!


neagle is cool

 

[Biggie]

Went Myers in for Barlow.

Happy with that, should provide excellent cover as emerg until Cornes gets back.

 

[McLean_4_Captain]

we'll see who's laughing after 5-10 games.

Its not about his career, just his supercoach scoring and ability to get a game. Neagle will have more competition for his spot because of Lucas & McPhee, Meyers looks likely to stay in the rest of the year.

Took Myers, played him because of Pratt's injury and was very happy with his 88pts.

 

[Tippaz]

rd9 check

29pts for Myers. 8pos, 1mark, 75% eff, 80gt%
43pts for Neagle. 8pos, 6marks, 1goal, 38% eff, 79%gt

after 3 games, it is clear to me that Neagle is performing well in contested pos/mark, and has a very good kick-h/ball ratio. effective disposal is the area letting him down the most. but he's been scoring pretty well without even playing a decent game. i can't see him getting dropped. he looks dangerous. they just need to get the ball down there and he'll get a good score.

2 more votes have come in since last week. good.
show Jay Neagle some love.

 

[Satan]

I have had neagle since rd 1, just went up by $31800.