Mike's TOP 50

[WOTTAMACHINE]

Tomorrow in the HUN Mike Sheahan will post his TOP 50 players, who do you think he will have in his top 5?
My top 5

J Brown
J Bartel
D Kerr
M Pavlich
C Kornes

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Ablett?

 

[ripitup27]

1. G.Ablett
2. J.Brown
3. C.Cornes
4. M.Pavlich
5. J.Bartel

Judd would be there if not for injury.

 

[Eddie Dingle]

Ablett?

His pants get tighter whenever Ablett is mentioned so you would think he would be in the top 3.

That and the fact Ablett is an absolute gun.

 

[WOTTAMACHINE]

His pants get tighter whenever Ablett is mentioned so you would think he would be in the top 3.

That and the fact Ablett is an absolute gun.

Fair enough..
I think he will have Kerr right up there as well...
IMO i think he is the best player in the league..

 

[weagles_fan]

1. J Brown
2. C Judd
3. G Ablett
4. D Kerr
5. M Pavlich

 

[dobbo_18]

1. J. Brown
2. G. Ablett
3. D. Kerr
4. J. Bartel
5. S. Black/D. Cox/C. Cornes
Judd would be numero uno if not for his groin.

 

[Farmy]

He will have Nick Riewoldt at no.1

Cause hes the best player in the comp guys, forget about the 100 other players better than him.

 

[Carlton Kid]

Judd and Kerr are the Best 2 players in the land IMO.

Judd speaks for itself, if not injured would have steamrolled the Brownlow and every othert football award. Best playe4r of modern era.

Kerr could have one three Brownlow's by now. In 2005 2nd by one vote, 2006 suspended and 3rd in voting, 2007 missed 5 games yet still came 2nd in voting whilst being suspended.


EDIT: note this is not about Mike's top 5o or even on this year. I just thought I'd say who I thought was the best player(s).

 

[jko'neal]

He will have Nick Riewoldt at no.1

Cause hes the best player in the comp guys, forget about the 100 other players better than him.

You can lock it in that some players will be picked on name alone, and not their efforts over season 2007!

 

[Beau_Waters for PM]

There was a thread in here a month or two ago where one poster made up his top 50 list. I thought it was a pretty good effort.

 

[banana69]

Brent Harvey anyone ?

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

For me

Kerr
Judd
Goodes
Brown
Bartel

On recent form

Ablett
Brown
Bartel
Goodes
Pavlich

 

[NEON]

I wouldn't be surprised if he doesn't list a single Collingwood player this year.

 

[wce4premiership]

Is it of this year or for next year?

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

To justify his salary Sheahan always throws in a few wildcards early to get people talking. Expect something stupid like Franklin in the top 3.

 

[borgy]

In the paper today they had 5 pictures, one was of Scarlett and read 'who will be number 1?'

If Scarlett is even in the 10 top its a disgrace. And moreso if hes higher than Glass or Rutten.

 

[jacko57]

Brent Harvey anyone ?

Top 10 maybe ; not top 5.

 

[AC for PM]

Is it of this year or for next year?

I think it's for 2011.

 

[larkis]

I just hope that the starting 22 for Geelong are not all included in the top 50. Well I would like to know where he rates Hird and Buckley (if he makes it).

 

[sexyhunk]

To justify his salary Sheahan always throws in a few wildcards early to get people talking. Expect something stupid like Franklin in the top 3.

duno what you getting at but i wil have buddy in my top 5 for the start of next year.

 

[Spinksme]

In the paper today they had 5 pictures, one was of Scarlett and read 'who will be number 1?'

If Scarlett is even in the 10 top its a disgrace. And moreso if hes higher than Glass or Rutten.

Just wondering whether you happened to catch the grand final champ?? Very close to taking home Norm-Smith. Best rebounding Full Back ever and sets up so much play for Geelong, could easily be in the top 10 and should be far higher than Rutten.

 

[Hoffy95]

Ablett or Brown for top spot.

I've got a gut feeling he will have Stevie Johnson top 20 as well.

 

[tigertiger]

i heard he has Michael Voss in his top 10,

 

[citizen-erased]

typical shehan top 5

1-Voss...er i mean Brown. oops
2-Riewoldt
3-Black. close brownlow count will justify this.
4-Bartel-obligatory brownlow inclusion
5-Bowden. dont ask me why but he makes top 5 every year

other silly inclusions
Lucas around 8th
Barry in there somewhere
possibly may have the audacity to put Buddy in top 10 despite an inconsisten year.