Remove this Banner Ad

Next Cab Off The Rank

  • Thread starter Thread starter _RT_
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

If Hardwick Goes Who Gets Your Vote?


  • Total voters
    86

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Mark Bickley
Age: 44
Player: 272 games, 1991-2003, Adelaide (premierships: two)
Assistant coach: Adelaide*
The dual premiership captain at the Crows coached Adelaide for six matches in 2011 after Neil Craig resigned. He was overlooked for the senior position at the club when Brenton Sanderson was appointed but he is now the senior assistant. Has dealt with a public profile his whole career and is as at home in a corporate setting as a football setting. Bickley has a great reputation as a people person, manages the media well and has a good eye for the game. He is also a natural leader, winning the captaincy under Malcolm Blight in 1997 because of his leadership abilities rather than his natural talent. Only knock on him would be his lack of work experience at a club other than Adelaide.

Luke Beveridge
Age: 43
Player: 118 games, Melbourne, Western Bulldogs, St Kilda
Assistant coach: Collingwood, Hawthorn*
Signed 11 one-year contracts in 11 seasons as a player with Melbourne, the Bulldogs and St Kilda before becoming the first person in VAFA history to coach a team from a C-Grade to A-Grade premiership in three seasons, when he took St Bede's Mentone to three flags between 2006 and 2008. Left a management position in taxation to join Collingwood as a development coach in 2009, being at the Magpies during its 2010 premiership. Went back to 'the real world' in 2011 before Hawthorn knocked. The Hawks reached Grand Finals in both years for one premiership, with Beveridge as an assistant coach. A good people person he has his own opinions and is happy to think differently.

Brett Montgomery
Age: 40
Player: 204 games, 1997-2007, Western Bulldogs, Port Adelaide (premierships: one)
Assistant coach: Carlton, Western Bulldogs*
A premiership player with Port Adelaide, he was an assistant coach at Carlton between 2008-2010 before returning to the Western Bulldogs where he played 78 games in two stints. He played under Terry Wallace, Mark Williams and Rodney Eade and has coached alongside Brett Ratten, Eade and now Brendan McCartney. The Blues averaged 16 points a game fewer in 2010 then they did in Montgomery's first season in 2008.

Scott Burns
Age: 39
Player: 264 games, 1995-2008, Collingwood
Assistant coach: West Coast Eagles, Collingwood*
Has been touted as a senior coach in waiting for a while now but has only been in the business since joining West Coast as an assistant in 2009. Burns moved back to Victoria this year to coach Collingwood's midfield. Known as a straight-shooter he was Collingwood captain in his final season and is a long-time fan favourite at the Magpies. A no-fuss type he knows he still needs to develop before being ready for senior coaching.

Simon Goodwin
Age: 37
Player: 275 games, 1997-2010, Adelaide
Assistant coach: Essendon*
He is the senior assistant coach at Essendon in his fourth year at the club after a brilliant playing career with Adelaide. Played in two premierships at the beginning of his 275-game career before the three best and fairests and 76 games as skipper. He interviewed for the Lions job last season and has been unfortunate to be at Essendon during a tough period for the club. However he has shown resilience throughout.

Garry Hocking
Age: 45
Player: 274 games, 1987-2001, Geelong
Assistant coach: Port Adelaide, coaching Port Adelaide Magpies*
Has done some hard yards since his brilliant playing career ended 13 years ago being a coach and assistant coach at North Ballarat, Western Jets, Peel Thunder and Geelong Falcons before joining the AFL system as an assistant coach at Port Adelaide. Will benefit from coaching Port Adelaide Magpies to round off that experience.

Robert Harvey
Age: 42
Player: 383 games, 1988-2008, St Kilda
Assistant coach: Carlton, St Kilda, Collingwood*
Has developed a varied resume with assistant coaching gigs at Carlton, St Kilda, and now Collingwood where he is a senior assistant at the Magpies alongside Nathan Buckley. Has taken time to develop confidence in the role and probably needs to coach his own team at some stage to really stake a claim as a senior coach.

Brendon Bolton
Age: 35
Now: Assistant coach at Hawthorn
Built his resumé taking North Hobart to the 2005 premiership as a playing coach, before coaching the Tassie Mariners at just 26 and then led Clarence to a preliminary final in 2008. He impressed Hawthorn when given the opportunity to spend a week observing them and was subsequently appointed coach of the Box Hill Hawks. He led the club into consecutive finals series in 2009 and 2010 before Hawthorn made him midfield coach. Upon his promotion Box Hill president John Ure paid tribute to him, saying his strength was to "create a positive environment so that the AFL-listed players actually enjoyed playing at Box Hill."

John Barker
Age: 39
Now: Assistant coach at Carlton
Recognition for Barker's abilities continues to grow and he is said to have strong people skills. Has coached alongside Ross Lyon, Alastair Clarkson and Mick Malthouse so is capable under three people who don't suffer fools but support those who win their respect.

Michael O'Loughlin
Age: 37
Now: Sydney Swans' Academy
Has gained experience through the AFL system and coached the Indigenous All-Stars and International Rules teams. Has moved to a development role and if he makes the decision he wants to be a senior coach he has the ability to make progress in that direction.

Blake Caracella
Age: 37
Now: Assistant coach at Geelong
Retired from playing in 2006 due to injury after two premierships in 187 games with three clubs. Collingwood offered him a job on the coaching panel and he excelled at the Magpies in different roles from 2007-2009 before joining Geelong to work under mentor Mark Thompson. Adapted well when Chris Scott arrived, as the Cats re-invented themselves to win the premiership. He has a strong football brain, challenges conventional thinking and works closely with Scott on match-day.

Adam Kingsley
Age: 38
Now: Assistant coach at St Kilda
Impresses good judges at the Saints with his organised approach and has held his nerve under three coaches at St Kilda since joining the club in 2011. Played in a premiership with Port Adelaide and won a best and fairest before being an assistant coach there for four years.

Tim Clarke
Age: 32
Now: Richmond VFL coach
Raised in discussions as one to watch, the fitness fanatic is a popular figure at the Tigers. He played 96 games at the Hawks between 2001-2008 and then spent two years as a development coach at Richmond. Travelled before returning to coach Coburg last season. He managed this difficult assignment well and is now coaching in the VFL

James McDonald
Age: 37
Now: Assistant coach at Greater Western Sydney
McDonald proved a leader of men as a player and has started his coaching career in a tough environment. The former Melbourne skipper is not one to put himself in the public spotlight but he shapes as a players' coach with a fierce team first attitude.

Matthew Nicks
Age: 38
Now: Port Adelaide defensive coach
Was an underrated player under Paul Roos and Rodney Eade at the Sydney Swans. Although the club made the Grand Final in his first and last season, he played in neither game. Moved on to coaching his own team in Sydney before taking up a role at Port Adelaide. Great rapport with the players and speaks well. Has the makings of a senior coach.

Former Senior Coaches:
John Worsfold
Michael Voss
Brett Ratten
Bomber Thompson

So with plenty calling for Hardwicks head here is a chance to throw some early support behind the next cab off the rank. As you can see there are plenty of options available, either from a new untried head coach or an experienced coach who can come in and command instant respect.
 
What if you dont think he's going to be sacked? I know you have said "if", but lets be honest its a "who will we replace Dimma with" thread
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Who knows who will be available at the end of 2016! Or if a next cab is needed!
 
Whoever gets the nod next be it this year or heaven forbid in 2017 only gets two years to make their mark. No playing favourites or copying of other clubs game styles.

Need a hard arse that pulls no punches and demands 100% commitment. Anything less will not be tolerated.
 
What if you dont think he's going to be sacked? I know you have said "if", but lets be honest its a "who will we replace Dimma with" thread
Personally I don't believe we will sack him, he might walk though. All this was designed for was for those who constantly call for his head to pick out who they'd like in his place.
 
This club needs a strong personality.
Bomber all the way. Lingy can be assistant and Voss midfield coach.
If we are not going to use our war chest on players we may as well use it on a formidable coaching staff.

Edit: Knights can come back to the club also. Very good at developing youth. Geelongs kids are coming along nicely and people forget very quickly that Essendons current squad was built be Knights.

Knights to coach our VFL please
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Personally I don't believe we will sack him, he might walk though. All this was designed for was for those who constantly call for his head to pick out who they'd like in his place.

Fair call dude

often these threads are passive aggressive attempts to push an agenda

FWIW I think it would be interesting to look back at the post Wally thread. I was initially a Richo supporter, who after his rejection backed Hinkley, but was happy with Dimma (so this isn't a "told ya so" comment, I was and am still happy with Dimma). Seem to remember I was in the minority however, and the same ones saying Dimma was the only choice, are now the ones calling loudest for his sacking

People have very short term memories here :) (not referring to you BTW - think we know each other well enough to know we dont play that "oh I called this years ago and no one listened to me" crap)
 
No Leigh Tudor or Nathan Basset on that list?
Couldn't fit everyone on the list. Might do another poll later in the year with a few extra options, especially if things keep going the way they are ;)
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Oops, put this in the wrong thread!

Anyway, you blokes need to think outside the square, we don't need old hack recycled coaches or untried assistants. We need a Big Footy coaching committee!
Head Coach: Groupie_ - I can't think any further outside the square than that!
Ruck Coach: The Rusty Trombone - Has all the answers re: what makes a bad ruckman ergo find us a good one.
Motivational Coach: Deliberate - Before every game he will done his robes, groom his flowing white beard, grab his rune carved staff and stand on the mount (Punt Road Hill) and make his pronouncements in a deep, booming voice! Well that's how I imagine him, scary dude!
Opposition Analyst - _RT_ - Well, just has to be.
Defensive Coach: Me - I do seem to spend a lot of time defending the indefensible!:p
Midfield Coach: Rodney Dangerfield - Can use his family influence to get Patrick to the Tiges.
Forward Coach: nut - Talk the talk, walk the walk, nutcase;)

2015 - prelim.
2016/17/18/19/20. Five in a row, guaranteed!
 
Mark Bickley
Age: 44
Player: 272 games, 1991-2003, Adelaide (premierships: two)
Assistant coach: Adelaide*
The dual premiership captain at the Crows coached Adelaide for six matches in 2011 after Neil Craig resigned. He was overlooked for the senior position at the club when Brenton Sanderson was appointed but he is now the senior assistant. Has dealt with a public profile his whole career and is as at home in a corporate setting as a football setting. Bickley has a great reputation as a people person, manages the media well and has a good eye for the game. He is also a natural leader, winning the captaincy under Malcolm Blight in 1997 because of his leadership abilities rather than his natural talent. Only knock on him would be his lack of work experience at a club other than Adelaide.

Luke Beveridge
Age: 43
Player: 118 games, Melbourne, Western Bulldogs, St Kilda
Assistant coach: Collingwood, Hawthorn*
Signed 11 one-year contracts in 11 seasons as a player with Melbourne, the Bulldogs and St Kilda before becoming the first person in VAFA history to coach a team from a C-Grade to A-Grade premiership in three seasons, when he took St Bede's Mentone to three flags between 2006 and 2008. Left a management position in taxation to join Collingwood as a development coach in 2009, being at the Magpies during its 2010 premiership. Went back to 'the real world' in 2011 before Hawthorn knocked. The Hawks reached Grand Finals in both years for one premiership, with Beveridge as an assistant coach. A good people person he has his own opinions and is happy to think differently.

Brett Montgomery
Age: 40
Player: 204 games, 1997-2007, Western Bulldogs, Port Adelaide (premierships: one)
Assistant coach: Carlton, Western Bulldogs*
A premiership player with Port Adelaide, he was an assistant coach at Carlton between 2008-2010 before returning to the Western Bulldogs where he played 78 games in two stints. He played under Terry Wallace, Mark Williams and Rodney Eade and has coached alongside Brett Ratten, Eade and now Brendan McCartney. The Blues averaged 16 points a game fewer in 2010 then they did in Montgomery's first season in 2008.

Scott Burns
Age: 39
Player: 264 games, 1995-2008, Collingwood
Assistant coach: West Coast Eagles, Collingwood*
Has been touted as a senior coach in waiting for a while now but has only been in the business since joining West Coast as an assistant in 2009. Burns moved back to Victoria this year to coach Collingwood's midfield. Known as a straight-shooter he was Collingwood captain in his final season and is a long-time fan favourite at the Magpies. A no-fuss type he knows he still needs to develop before being ready for senior coaching.

Simon Goodwin
Age: 37
Player: 275 games, 1997-2010, Adelaide
Assistant coach: Essendon*
He is the senior assistant coach at Essendon in his fourth year at the club after a brilliant playing career with Adelaide. Played in two premierships at the beginning of his 275-game career before the three best and fairests and 76 games as skipper. He interviewed for the Lions job last season and has been unfortunate to be at Essendon during a tough period for the club. However he has shown resilience throughout.

Garry Hocking
Age: 45
Player: 274 games, 1987-2001, Geelong
Assistant coach: Port Adelaide, coaching Port Adelaide Magpies*
Has done some hard yards since his brilliant playing career ended 13 years ago being a coach and assistant coach at North Ballarat, Western Jets, Peel Thunder and Geelong Falcons before joining the AFL system as an assistant coach at Port Adelaide. Will benefit from coaching Port Adelaide Magpies to round off that experience.

Robert Harvey
Age: 42
Player: 383 games, 1988-2008, St Kilda
Assistant coach: Carlton, St Kilda, Collingwood*
Has developed a varied resume with assistant coaching gigs at Carlton, St Kilda, and now Collingwood where he is a senior assistant at the Magpies alongside Nathan Buckley. Has taken time to develop confidence in the role and probably needs to coach his own team at some stage to really stake a claim as a senior coach.

Brendon Bolton
Age: 35
Now: Assistant coach at Hawthorn
Built his resumé taking North Hobart to the 2005 premiership as a playing coach, before coaching the Tassie Mariners at just 26 and then led Clarence to a preliminary final in 2008. He impressed Hawthorn when given the opportunity to spend a week observing them and was subsequently appointed coach of the Box Hill Hawks. He led the club into consecutive finals series in 2009 and 2010 before Hawthorn made him midfield coach. Upon his promotion Box Hill president John Ure paid tribute to him, saying his strength was to "create a positive environment so that the AFL-listed players actually enjoyed playing at Box Hill."

John Barker
Age: 39
Now: Assistant coach at Carlton
Recognition for Barker's abilities continues to grow and he is said to have strong people skills. Has coached alongside Ross Lyon, Alastair Clarkson and Mick Malthouse so is capable under three people who don't suffer fools but support those who win their respect.

Michael O'Loughlin
Age: 37
Now: Sydney Swans' Academy
Has gained experience through the AFL system and coached the Indigenous All-Stars and International Rules teams. Has moved to a development role and if he makes the decision he wants to be a senior coach he has the ability to make progress in that direction.

Blake Caracella
Age: 37
Now: Assistant coach at Geelong
Retired from playing in 2006 due to injury after two premierships in 187 games with three clubs. Collingwood offered him a job on the coaching panel and he excelled at the Magpies in different roles from 2007-2009 before joining Geelong to work under mentor Mark Thompson. Adapted well when Chris Scott arrived, as the Cats re-invented themselves to win the premiership. He has a strong football brain, challenges conventional thinking and works closely with Scott on match-day.

Adam Kingsley
Age: 38
Now: Assistant coach at St Kilda
Impresses good judges at the Saints with his organised approach and has held his nerve under three coaches at St Kilda since joining the club in 2011. Played in a premiership with Port Adelaide and won a best and fairest before being an assistant coach there for four years.

Tim Clarke
Age: 32
Now: Richmond VFL coach
Raised in discussions as one to watch, the fitness fanatic is a popular figure at the Tigers. He played 96 games at the Hawks between 2001-2008 and then spent two years as a development coach at Richmond. Travelled before returning to coach Coburg last season. He managed this difficult assignment well and is now coaching in the VFL

James McDonald
Age: 37
Now: Assistant coach at Greater Western Sydney
McDonald proved a leader of men as a player and has started his coaching career in a tough environment. The former Melbourne skipper is not one to put himself in the public spotlight but he shapes as a players' coach with a fierce team first attitude.

Matthew Nicks
Age: 38
Now: Port Adelaide defensive coach
Was an underrated player under Paul Roos and Rodney Eade at the Sydney Swans. Although the club made the Grand Final in his first and last season, he played in neither game. Moved on to coaching his own team in Sydney before taking up a role at Port Adelaide. Great rapport with the players and speaks well. Has the makings of a senior coach.

Former Senior Coaches:
John Worsfold
Michael Voss
Brett Ratten
Bomber Thompson

So with plenty calling for Hardwicks head here is a chance to throw some early support behind the next cab off the rank. As you can see there are plenty of options available, either from a new untried head coach or an experienced coach who can come in and command instant respect.


You have to be joking RT??? seriously... The all time greatest Flip Flopper has out flipped flopped himself. Well done.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/hardwick-gets-extended-contract-to-2016.1043902/page-10
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom