_RT_
Not A Minion
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2006
- Posts
- 50,480
- Reaction score
- 103,542
- Location
- Southern Stand Punt Road End
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Staff
- #1
I've tried to be positive, I've tried to see the positives in every loss and I've tried to believe that Wallace was the right man to get this club back into the finals. Well after today, I've had it.
Today I got the chance to sit near the coaches box (thanks UTG) and when we were getting smacked in the 2nd/3rd/4th quarters I spent a bit of time looking up at the brains trust and quite frankly they looked clueless. Didn't seem to have any spark as to how they could stop the way things were going or at least try and wrestle back some sort of control. Wallace had that same expressionless look on his face as he did every other time we have been belted under his tenure. Even the assistants seemed to be lacking any spark.
Perhaps it was them realising that we are a long way off of being a contender for anything. Perhaps they were realising that the odds on them being there next year are getting longer and longer each week.
You see today IMO, it was worse than Round 1, because it came after such a spirited showing against the Cats where all the wrongs that occured then were seemingly addressed and we seemed to be getting things worked out. However, once the pressure was applied by the Dogs today we folded like a house of cards. Same old dumb errors were made time and again, same lack of belief was on show by the same players. When it gets a little too difficult these blokes seem to turn on their survival mode and look after themselves rather than stepping up to lead the side. It simply isn't good enough and should not be accepted by us the fans anymore.
As far as I'm concerned the following players should be told they have 5 weeks to save their careers: Simmonds & Bowden, both seem to be struggling to have the same impact they used to have on games and we can't and shouldn't carry them through the season. If they don't turn it around by then, they should be given the Gaspar speech and told that younger players will be given first crack at their spots. Johnson should be told that already. You've been a decent player for the club but we're going with the kids for the rest of the year.
As for the other players we have above 30 they should only be kept on as long as they are servicable. This means Brown Cousins & Richo. Now this will draw some heat, but in all honesty Richo should retire at the end of the season. Not because he can't compete but because he is not going to be playing when we are a contender for a flag. So instead of him going around another year and ending up as a player who spends most of the season in the stands rather than on the park, I would rather Richo goes out on his terms and at the top of his game. Brown should only be kept on if he can be servicable, in the same way Akermanis is for the Dogs, play a role and every now and then be a match winner for the side. Cousins at the moment the jury is still out on whether he was worth getting. If he is going to be servicable he needs to get out on the ground and set the example for the kids coming through that shows them what it takes to get the most out of yourself to be an AFL player.
Finally, I think the best thing Wallace and co can do now is to forget about ladder position and wins and losses. Remove the expectations from the list as it seems we just wilt under it. They do however seem to thrive when the pressure is off and they are allowed to just go out and play natural footy. So let them have their heads and let them go out and play. If it means we finish down near the arse end of the ladder then so be it. It wont be the first time we've done it and certainly wont be the last, because we simply don't have the cattle to be a genuine contender for a flag let alone the finals. It looks like another rebuild is in the works and it has to be a lot harsher than the one we went through under Wallace early on.
Today I got the chance to sit near the coaches box (thanks UTG) and when we were getting smacked in the 2nd/3rd/4th quarters I spent a bit of time looking up at the brains trust and quite frankly they looked clueless. Didn't seem to have any spark as to how they could stop the way things were going or at least try and wrestle back some sort of control. Wallace had that same expressionless look on his face as he did every other time we have been belted under his tenure. Even the assistants seemed to be lacking any spark.
Perhaps it was them realising that we are a long way off of being a contender for anything. Perhaps they were realising that the odds on them being there next year are getting longer and longer each week.
You see today IMO, it was worse than Round 1, because it came after such a spirited showing against the Cats where all the wrongs that occured then were seemingly addressed and we seemed to be getting things worked out. However, once the pressure was applied by the Dogs today we folded like a house of cards. Same old dumb errors were made time and again, same lack of belief was on show by the same players. When it gets a little too difficult these blokes seem to turn on their survival mode and look after themselves rather than stepping up to lead the side. It simply isn't good enough and should not be accepted by us the fans anymore.
As far as I'm concerned the following players should be told they have 5 weeks to save their careers: Simmonds & Bowden, both seem to be struggling to have the same impact they used to have on games and we can't and shouldn't carry them through the season. If they don't turn it around by then, they should be given the Gaspar speech and told that younger players will be given first crack at their spots. Johnson should be told that already. You've been a decent player for the club but we're going with the kids for the rest of the year.
As for the other players we have above 30 they should only be kept on as long as they are servicable. This means Brown Cousins & Richo. Now this will draw some heat, but in all honesty Richo should retire at the end of the season. Not because he can't compete but because he is not going to be playing when we are a contender for a flag. So instead of him going around another year and ending up as a player who spends most of the season in the stands rather than on the park, I would rather Richo goes out on his terms and at the top of his game. Brown should only be kept on if he can be servicable, in the same way Akermanis is for the Dogs, play a role and every now and then be a match winner for the side. Cousins at the moment the jury is still out on whether he was worth getting. If he is going to be servicable he needs to get out on the ground and set the example for the kids coming through that shows them what it takes to get the most out of yourself to be an AFL player.
Finally, I think the best thing Wallace and co can do now is to forget about ladder position and wins and losses. Remove the expectations from the list as it seems we just wilt under it. They do however seem to thrive when the pressure is off and they are allowed to just go out and play natural footy. So let them have their heads and let them go out and play. If it means we finish down near the arse end of the ladder then so be it. It wont be the first time we've done it and certainly wont be the last, because we simply don't have the cattle to be a genuine contender for a flag let alone the finals. It looks like another rebuild is in the works and it has to be a lot harsher than the one we went through under Wallace early on.












