our full strength side

[heavho]

this is my opinion on the side at full strength




B: Greg Broughton, Chris Tarrant, Roger Hayden

HB: Steven Dodd, Luke McPharlin, Paul Duffield

C: Garrick Ibbotson, Ryan Crowley , Nick Suban

HF:Steven Hill, Michael Johnson, Paul Haselby

F: Hayden Ballantyne,Matthew Pavlich,Christopher Mayne

Foll: Aaron Sandilands,Rhys palmer,Byron Schammer

I/C: , Matt DeBoer, Andrew Foster, Zac Clarke,David Mundy

em: Des Headland,Clayton Hinkley,Antoni Grover

could add our first choice in draft next year also

 

[bman]

this is my opinion on the side at full strength




B: Greg Broughton, Chris Tarrant, Roger Hayden

HB: Steven Dodd, Luke McPharlin, Paul Duffield

C: Nick Suban Paul Haselby Stephen Hill

HF:Des Headland, Michael Johnson, Michael Walters

F: Hayden Ballantyne,Matthew Pavlich,Christopher Mayne

Foll: Aaron Sandilands,Rhys palmer, Garrick Ibbotson

I/C: , Matt DeBoer, Ryan Crowley, Zac Clarke,David Mundy

emg: clancee pearce,tim ruffles,byron schammer

 

[Mundy]

The fact that Steven Dodd is still considered top 25 means we are a still along, long way from where we need to be.

 

[heavho]

suban better than walters

 

[Underdog]

The fact that Steven Dodd is still considered top 25 means we are a still along, long way from where we need to be.

and Hinkley just being out of your best 22

 

[Mundy]

and Hinkley just being out of your best 22

Are you being genuine or do you think Hinkley is as poor as me?

 

[Kram]

Hinkley has a lot of work to do.

 

[Brickie29]

At full strength does Mundy deserve to be automatic selection ?

 

[heavho]

At full strength does Mundy deserve to be automatic selection ?

not at all ahaha but cant see him being dropped

 

[Mundy]

At full strength does Mundy deserve to be automatic selection ?

Absolutely. At full strength he wouldnt be required to do the grunt work, he'd be on the outside delivering lace 50m laser passes.

 

[The Night Shift]

What, no Head......

 

[DCFCFAN84]

B: Greg Broughton, Chris Tarrant, Roger Hayden

HB: Antoni Grover, Luke McPharlin, Paul Duffield

C: Garrick Ibbotson, Paul Haselby, Nick Suban

HF: Steven Hill, Matthew Pavlich, Michael Johnson

F: Hayden Ballantyne, Adam Campbell, Christopher Mayne

Foll: Aaron Sandilands, Rhys Palmer, Ryan Crowley

I/C: , Byron Schammer, Matt DeBoer, David Mundy, Des Headland

em: Clayton Hinkley, Steven Dodd, Zac Clarke

Not sure if I forgot anyone but i think that 22 isn't too bad. I think we will pick up a midfielder in the 1st round eg. Trengove, Morabito, Lucas any of those guys would walk in to our 22 straight up imo.

 

[Notorious_29]

this is my opinion on the side at full strength




B: Greg Broughton, Chris Tarrant, Roger Hayden

HB: Steven Dodd, Luke McPharlin, Paul Duffield

C: Garrick Ibbotson, Ryan Crowley , Nick Suban

HF:Steven Hill, Michael Johnson, Paul Haselby

F: Hayden Ballantyne,Matthew Pavlich,Christopher Mayne

Foll: Aaron Sandilands,Rhys palmer,Byron Schammer

I/C: , Matt DeBoer, Anthony Morabito, Zac Clarke, David Mundy

em: Des Headland,Clayton Hinkley, Andrew Foster

could add our first choice in draft next year also

this team is good for me. just swapped foster for morabito.

grover has to go, i think dodd plays some good games and would be a lot better player with a good team around him.

if this team lines up round 1 next year i think we would be very competitive.

 

[sabre_ac]

On talent and contribution to the side, Mundy is surely in our starting team.

Mundy's never going to be a hard at the ball type player, his tackles will consistently be broken and is highly unlikely to get his own ball.

That said, WHEN we become a top 8 side..Mundy's value will sky rocket, he (like Headland/Kerr) will look like a star with good players around him. The guy is a bottom 8 sides worst nightmare, but a godsend in a team up and running.

Trade him back to Victoria (Other than Demons/Roos) and we will have another trade blunder on the list.

 

[longsuffreosupp]

People who left out Schammer and Headland

On the basis they are 100% fit, they would be in the starting lineup round 1 2010, though this may not be the case come round 22 (some players would really have to step up).

 

[anchor man]

I would have Hayden in my team but never in a back pocket.He is not tight enough to play there.Rover kick too many goals on him.

 

[the probe]

Not bad. I'd have Headland in the forward pocket though...thought he looked dangerous up there earlier this year, would drag a good defender to him.

 

[The Night Shift]

Can we brake Waterhouse out of stasis and bring him in?

 

[Chris25]

b: Hayden - Tarrant - McPharlin
hb: Duffield - Johnson - Broughton
c: Hill - Palmer - Ibbotson
hf: Mayne - Headland - Mundy
f: Ballantyne - Pavlich - Clarke

r: Sandilands - Crowley - Hasleby

i: DeBoer - Suban - Schammer - Pearce

e: Walters - Solomon - Hinkley

The only problem I had was with Johnson. Personally, I prefer him up forward. But the only other option down back was to either play Grover/Dodd or to rely on Pearce/Broughton to play above their height. Neither of which I really wanted to do. So Johnson found his way back to CHB, with Clarke/Sandilands taking his spot up forward.

 

[silverscope]

I liked some of your team Chris25 but just made a couple of changes.

Firstly with Johnson IN i don't think Clarke will get much of a run next year, but hey i might be wrong. But IMO Johnson is our second ruck/foward.

Solomon in the backline with Headland on the bench. Taz FB and McP CHF. Suban on the HBF.

I'd have Mundy on the wing where he can use his foot skills in the open space (which he loves) to good use and play Hill of the HFF.



B: R.Hayden - C.Tarrant - G.Broughton
HB: P.Duffield - L.McPharlin - N.Suban
C: D.Mundy - R.Palmer - G.Ibbotson
HF: C.Mayne - M.Johnson - S.Hill
F: H.Ballantyne - M.Pavlich - D.Solomon

R: A.Sandilands - R.Crowley - P.Hasleby

I: M.DeBoer - D.Headland - B.Schammer - C.Pearce

E: M.Walters - Z.Clarke - S.Thornton - J. van Berlo - A.Foster - C.Hinkley - L.Pratt

 

[legitimatic]

I liked some of your team Chris25 but just made a couple of changes.

Firstly with Johnson IN i don't think Clarke will get much of a run next year, but hey i might be wrong. But IMO Johnson is our second ruck/foward.

Solomon in the backline with Headland on the bench. Taz FB and McP CHF. Suban on the HBF.

I'd have Mundy on the wing where he can use his foot skills in the open space (which he loves) to good use and play Hill of the HFF.



B: R.Hayden - C.Tarrant - G.Broughton
HB: M.Duffield - L.McPharlin - N.Suban
C: D.Mundy - R.Palmer - G.Ibbotson
HF: C.Mayne - M.Johnson - S.Hill
F: H.Ballantyne - M.Pavlich - D.Solomon

R: A.Sandilands - R.Crowley - P.Hasleby

I: M.DeBoer - D.Headland - B.Schammer - C.Pearce

E: M.Walters - Z.Clarke - S.Thornton - J. van Berlo - A.Foster - C.Hinkley - L.Pratt

I agree with everything except this