Our Worst 5 you decide

[Da Shag On Fire]

Who cant you stand wearing the navey blue?

 

[bibi01]

these are my bottom 6 players

prendergast
bannister
davies
longmuir
chambers
livingston

 

[Stig O'Hara]

these are my bottom 6 players

prendergast
bannister
davies
longmuir
chambers
livingston

Under the pump i agree,
You can add Wiggins, Livingston and Sporn.

All of the above mentioned would be in a make or break situation this year,
have had time and chances and must perform.

After seeing so many careers go into oblivion after the draft/psd,
these guys must realise if this year goes skewiff,
that's the end of the line.

Hopefully if 3 of this lot step up, will add depth.

 

[av76]

Under the pump i agree,
You can add Wiggins, Livingston and Sporn.

All of the above mentioned would be in a make or break situation this year,
have had time and chances and must perform.

After seeing so many careers go into oblivion after the draft/psd,
these guys must realise if this year goes skewiff,
that's the end of the line.

Hopefully if 3 of this lot step up, will add depth.

Prenderghast
Longmuir
Chambers
Wiggins
Bannister

Sporn, Davies and Livo are living on the edge but if they stay fit could survive. Sporn has shown that when fit and confident can be handy. Davies had talent. Livo could still develop into a good, large negating defender. Teague is also on the fringe now too. I think the other five have shown their best and have no improvement left in them. Wiggins is probably the most useful as a tough body tagger/defender.

 

[Kooley]

and chuck in teague.

 

[Blues_Man]

Prenderghast
Longmuir
Chambers
Wiggins
Bannister

Sporn, Davies and Livo are living on the edge but if they stay fit could survive. Sporn has shown that when fit and confident can be handy. Davies had talent. Livo could still develop into a good, large negating defender. Teague is also on the fringe now too. I think the other five have shown their best and have no improvement left in them. Wiggins is probably the most useful as a tough body tagger/defender.

I honestly believe Davies has the potential to be a top line player...lets hope he steps up this year and doesn't waste his chance ...Sporn and Livingstone have been very very ordinary

 

[Da Shag On Fire]

these are my bottom 6 players

prendergast
bannister
davies
longmuir
chambers
livingston

SPOT ON

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

While they are wearing the monogram, I love them all.

 

[WTTF]

1. Prendergast
2. Longmuir
3. Davies
4. Chambers
5. DeLuca
6. Bannister
7. Wiggins
8. Sporn
9. Whitnall

 

[SurreyBlue]

While they are wearing the monogram, I love them all.

Thank Christ some-one said it.

 

[OZBomb]

They've all got redeeming qualities.

The only Carlton player I ever hated was Justin Murphy.

 

[purplepavlich_29]

1. Prendergast
2. Longmuir
3. Davies
4. Chambers
5. DeLuca
6. Bannister
7. Wiggins
8. Sporn
9. Whitnall

You have got to be joking. Whitnall is an outstanding talent, a player with a fantastic football brain. Top three or four in Carlton's best!

Davies is mecurial, and yes inconsistant. But will produce the goods.

I wonder if you like or have any hope for the players of your club.

 

[SurreyBlue]

You have got to be joking. Whitnall is an outstanding talent, a player with a fantastic football brain. Top three or four in Carlton's best!

Davies is mecurial, and yes inconsistant. But will produce the goods.

I wonder if you like or have any hope for the players of your club.

I thought I would never see the day that a opposition supporter would value a Carlton player more than some Carlton supporters, but there it is folks. We have officially slumped to our lowest.

 

[mojo31]

1. Prendergast
2. Longmuir
3. Davies
4. Chambers
5. DeLuca
6. Bannister
7. Wiggins
8. Sporn
9. Whitnall

If Lance is in our bottom 9 players then we should be premiership favourites.

 

[WTTF]

You have got to be joking. Whitnall is an outstanding talent, a player with a fantastic football brain. Top three or four in Carlton's best!

Davies is mecurial, and yes inconsistant. But will produce the goods.

I wonder if you like or have any hope for the players of your club.

Looks like I've landed a big one here..............

That should be the first and only time Davies and mercurial are used in the same sentence. Hard at the ball, yep but far from skillful.

 

[WTTF]

If Lance is in our bottom 9 players then we should be premiership favourites.

C'mon Mojo, that's disappointing that you responded to that.

You must have the CBF's with work like me today?

 

[gandaal]

1. Prendergast
2. Bannister

That is all I'm willing to write off at this point.

 

[Muji]

Who would get delisted next year with all these names popping up?
I'd say:
Bannister
Prendergast
Wiggins
Deluca
Longmuir and Chambers (worst trades we've ever done)

These guys in any order and I think a couple more on the fringe like Davies, Sporn and Teague but they should be alright.

 

[aic-poppy]

Chambers! Soft C**t!!! Houlihan also. Too soft to be wearing the jumper.

 

[deluxeman]

Who would get delisted next year with all these names popping up?
I'd say:
Bannister
Prendergast
Wiggins
Deluca
Longmuir and Chambers (worst trades we've ever done)

These guys in any order and I think a couple more on the fringe like Davies, Sporn and Teague but they should be alright.

Teague and Deluca are safe as they are on 2 yr contracts.

Livingston is in trouble and I suspect that possibly Bryan could be delisted if CArlton decide to promote Batson to the primary list.

 

[Muji]

Is batson any good? or are we going for a Sellar or a Leunberger type next season?

 

[stokesy]

1. Prendergast
2. Chambers

Every other player on the list is better then the two I have mentioned and therefore, they don't warrant a mention.

 

[Chemical]

Huge fan of Bannister. Believe he could be a runnning backman for us next year.

 

[Jeremias]

1. Prendergast
2. Livingston
3. Bannister
4. Wiggins
5. Davies-but i think he will eventually come good

the top 4 are montys at this stage to be delisted at the end of 2006

 

[audas]

Danaher and Ratten have both recently given Davies big raps.he is good player and some people around here have biased views he will be staying. Watch him without prejuduce.

Bryan is getting bigger and better and am surprised to see his name up here.

For a bloke who looks like Hoolahan acts Teague is 110%. Dosent have the nouse but sooooo willing. Id give him plenty of room.

Wiggins ws starting to look a lot better last towards the end of the season. Go back and watch him when we are winning he is very noticable. (Admittedly that isnt a big wrap)