Palmer or Cotchin???

[Spudregus_87]

First week of finals:
Forward line: J.Morton OUT; 'cheap forward' IN (giving me an extra $200k)
then will trade either cotchin or palmer to an elite midfielder, leaving one as my mid emg.

Question is, which one do i keep?

1) Trade Palmer (which will give me an extra 60k), or;
2) Trade cotchin (leaving palmer on the bench)?

Any thoughts much appreciated...

 

[Stanton]

First week of finals:
Forward line: J.Morton OUT; 'cheap forward' IN (giving me an extra $200k)
then will trade either cotchin or palmer to an elite midfielder, leaving one as my mid emg.

Question is, which one do i keep?

1) Trade Palmer (which will give me an extra 60k), or;
2) Trade cotchin (leaving palmer on the bench)?

Any thoughts much appreciated...

I would definitely trade Palmer, has had some soreness, may be rested, also worth more money. Cotchin should continue to play and increase in value. Which cheap forward are you intending on bringing in?

 

[Spudregus_87]

I would definitely trade Palmer, has had some soreness, may be rested, also worth more money. Cotchin should continue to play and increase in value. Which cheap forward are you intending on bringing in?

Good question, not many there. Whoever i bring in will only sit on the bench with lachie hansen (who will probably take the emg role).

Probably Maric from the Dees, as he appears to be the only current option under $100,000 who's played a game.

 

[w00dy]

cotchin will play every game, but doesn't score as well as palmer does...

 

[Stanton]

Good question, not many there. Whoever i bring in will only sit on the bench with lachie hansen (who will probably take the emg role).

Probably Maric from the Dees, as he appears to be the only current option under $100,000 who's played a game.

I am interested as currently i have no playing emergencys, with Josh Kennedy wce and Dowler as my emergencys. Will probably leave it as it is currently and hope kennedy is back and not rested for the rest of the year !

 

[Spudregus_87]

cotchin will play every game, but doesn't score as well as palmer does...

yeah my only concern is palmer's disposal effectiveness (i.e can rack up 30 touches, for only 70=-80 points)...it will depend on $$$ of the elite guys, but i would love to keep palmer as emg in the ideal world

 

[Biggie]

Trade out Palmer for Hodge.

You know you want to.

 

[Spudregus_87]

Trade out Palmer for Hodge.

You know you want to.

thats the way its heading BM, shame i won't be able to challenge u in the finals with my super midfield...

 

[w00dy]

yeah my only concern is palmer's disposal effectiveness (i.e can rack up 30 touches, for only 70=-80 points)...it will depend on $$$ of the elite guys, but i would love to keep palmer as emg in the ideal world

but palmer rarely scores below 70 odd, he isn't that effective but he keeps racking up the stats... cotchin usually scores somewhere between 50-90 because he may not get a lot of the footy some games...

 

[shiny_on_top]

What does evryone think about this??
Goodes > Cooney
Palmer/Cotchin > Scotty Thompson