Phantom B&F

[Demon37]

I posted this on Demonology... without a reply.

1. Clint Bizzell
Played every game, and contributed in every single one. Possibly our best ever recruit.

2. James McDonald
A real surprise packet this season I must say. Averaged 21 disposals a game, and was our most consistent player along with Bizzell.

3. Russell Robertson
Started brilliantly. Would have been leading the count at the break, but his form dipped slightly. Still a solid season.

4. Adem Yze
There is always one surprise on B&F, and I reckon Yze's high finish will be the talking point this year. Was down on his usual brilliant self, but averaged over 20 disposals a game and was very good after the break.

5. Chris Heffernan
Very solid recruit. Didn't get as many disposals as some midfielders, but was very consistent and should poll well. A real find.

6. David Neitz
65 goals from the big skipper. Won't poll all that well because he did go missing in a few matches.

7. Cameron Bruce
Not quite as good as 2002, but better than some think. Should, and will finish Top 10.

8. Simon Godfrey
I'm unsure where he will finish. Did some good tagging jobs, but has poor skills and doesn't get much of the ball.

9. Travis Johnstone
A bit of a surprise selction, but Travis will poll in quite a few matches.

10. Brad Miller
Will poll well. Danners loves him!

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Pretty good effort there mate!

And you didn't get a reply on Demonology as the post was too intellectual for their like!

 

[CowboyFromHell]

And I forgot to add that if Bizzell doesn't win, it's a travesty.

 

[Demon37]

Originally posted by CowboyFromHell
And I forgot to add that if Bizzell doesn't win, it's a travesty.

I have a slight feeling Junior will win it. He has always been one of ND's favourites (8th last year despite a terrible year), and was actually one of our best players this year. 1st placing in the Flame POTY shows this!

 

[Deestroy]

Looks pretty good. I would bump TJ and Miller out of my top 10, but not sure who would come in

 

[Supermercado]

Nathan Brown would have to crack the top 10. Sure he turns over the ball half the time but he was still good enough to finish 10th.

Incidentally did anyone else crack it when he got the 3 Brownlow votes against Port Adelaide? It just shows how stupid the umpires are when they give BOG to somebody who had 30 possessions and 25 of them ended up as clangers.

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Here's how I think it will finish

1. Clint Bizzell
2. James McDonald
3. Russell Robertson
4. David Nietz
5. Simon Godfrey
6. Cameron Bruce
7. Chris Heffernan
8. Adem Yze
9. Matthew Whelan
10. Daniel Ward


If I was awarding it would be

1. Clint Bizzell
2. James McDonald
3. Simon Godfrey
4. Matthew Whelan
5. David Nietz
6. Cameron Bruce
7. Russell Robertson
8. Darren Jolly
9. Adem Yze
10. Daniel Ward

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Originally posted by Supermercado
Nathan Brown would have to crack the top 10. Sure he turns over the ball half the time but he was still good enough to finish 10th.

Incidentally did anyone else crack it when he got the 3 Brownlow votes against Port Adelaide? It just shows how stupid the umpires are when they give BOG to somebody who had 30 possessions and 25 of them ended up as clangers.

Brown was great for us that night. I had him as our second best just behind McDonald.

 

[BT]

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
Here's how I think it will finish

1. Clint Bizzell
2. James McDonald
3. Russell Robertson
4. David Nietz
5. Simon Godfrey
6. Cameron Bruce
7. Chris Heffernan
8. Adem Yze
9. Matthew Whelan
10. Daniel Ward


If I was awarding it would be

1. Clint Bizzell
2. James McDonald
3. Simon Godfrey
4. Matthew Whelan
5. David Nietz
6. Cameron Bruce
7. Russell Robertson
8. Darren Jolly
9. Adem Yze
10. Daniel Ward

The Flame knows best

My top 5

1 Macca
2 Biz
3 Robertson
4 Brown
5 Godfrey

Actuall top 5

1 Biz
2 Macca
3 Robbo
4 Neeta
5 Yze

 

[Patrick Bateman]

Robertson will win from McDonald and Neitz with Bizzell fourth.

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
Here's how I think it will finish

1. Clint Bizzell
2. James McDonald
3. Russell Robertson
4. David Nietz
5. Simon Godfrey
6. Cameron Bruce
7. Chris Heffernan
8. Adem Yze
9. Matthew Whelan
10. Daniel Ward

5/5 from the top 5 but in the wrong order.

Anybody know who finished 6-10th?

Robbo winning was a suprise. His trade value will be HUGE now.

 

[BT]

Originally posted by Demon37
I posted this on Demonology... without a reply.

1. Clint Bizzell
Played every game, and contributed in every single one. Possibly our best ever recruit.

2. James McDonald
A real surprise packet this season I must say. Averaged 21 disposals a game, and was our most consistent player along with Bizzell.

3. Russell Robertson
Started brilliantly. Would have been leading the count at the break, but his form dipped slightly. Still a solid season.

4. Adem Yze
There is always one surprise on B&F, and I reckon Yze's high finish will be the talking point this year. Was down on his usual brilliant self, but averaged over 20 disposals a game and was very good after the break.

5. Chris Heffernan
Very solid recruit. Didn't get as many disposals as some midfielders, but was very consistent and should poll well. A real find.

6. David Neitz
65 goals from the big skipper. Won't poll all that well because he did go missing in a few matches.

7. Cameron Bruce
Not quite as good as 2002, but better than some think. Should, and will finish Top 10.

8. Simon Godfrey
I'm unsure where he will finish. Did some good tagging jobs, but has poor skills and doesn't get much of the ball.

9. Travis Johnstone
A bit of a surprise selction, but Travis will poll in quite a few matches.

10. Brad Miller
Will poll well. Danners loves him!

Good effort there mate!

1. Russell Robertson 267

2. James McDonald 240

3. David Neitz 198

4. Clint Bizzell 166

5. Simon Godfrey 165

6. Cameron Bruce 159

7. Brad Green 145

8. Matthew Whelan 141

9. Nathan Brown 139

10. Adem Yze 131

Reckon that top 6 is fair enough.

Green???? Trade value booster!!!

Whelan wouldn't have made my top 10.

Heffernan was never going to be top 5, maybe a tad stiff to miss the top 10.

 

[BT]

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20


Robbo winning was a suprise. His trade value will be HUGE now.

LOL