players to get rid of

[bgs05]

with are younger players looking quite solid i think its we should get rid of some of the players that make we yell at the tv for the past maybe two seasons.
i would trade cole, lokan, walker and maybe maxwell.
who do u think should go?

 

[Magpies2005]

with are younger players looking quite solid i think its we should get rid of some of the players that make we yell at the tv for the past maybe two seasons.
i would trade cole, lokan, walker and maybe maxwell.
who do u think should go?

my god its only round 12 hahaha why dont u wait till the end of the year, u should support the players that r playing in the black and white not bagging the crap out of them and starting the big "GET RID OF THEM" at round 12.

considering that Cole has been injured and maxwell has been solid for us the last month or so down back and his had some tough players to play on.

i think its stupid how the so called SUPPORTERS on here bag the crap out of players wearing the black and white at round 12 when u should be getting behind them!!!!

so bgs05 have u got a membership? do u go every week to support the team win or lose?

 

[DidaksLeftFoot]

Maxwell??? There is no way we would trade 'Jimmy Junior'. A very flexible defender who, like our acting captain, can match up on both tall and short opposition forwards.

Walker, Lokan... gawn. Walker has been pooed upon by C3 taking the vacant CHF spot and C2 rucking OK. There are no spots in the backline either... so I guess it's see ya Tex.

Lokan had a great first year... but was probably, like most players, scarred from the GF loss.

Cole is a difficult one because he can be so punishing with his run from defence, but finds himself caught often and his disposal can be dreadful.

 

[hilly69]

Maxwell are you joking he has been really good and is no doubt the biggest backline player of the future

 

[NICK THE PIE MAN]

Trade Cole.

 

[hotpie]

Trade Cole.

normally i'd disagree with you but he is one of the few players on our list we'd get something decent for (apart from those we'd rather keep).

depending on what we could get for him, maybe he's worth trading.

 

[ryan2000]

Trade Cole.

I actually like Cole. What would you want for him? And, more to the point, why aren't you happy with him?

Has he been tried in the midfield at all?

 

[hotpie]

my point's proven already. Unfortunately nobody at Carlton is worthy of even Andrew Williams.

 

[ryan2000]

my point's proven already. Unfortunately nobody at Carlton is worthy of even Andrew Williams.

What about picks? 2nd round?

 

[Jabso]

Cole is my favorite player but I agree he would be the best player to trade. However he has huge potential and should be tried in the midfield/wing, while he can be a very good accountable back pocket he can be a great winger/midfielder.
2nd round is not enough in an average draft. How about somehow getting our hands on Thornton? It's not like your backline can get any worse And to ease the pain we'll hand over big Tex Walker.

 

[RuZZa#28]

get rid off cole,williams,morrison,rowe,lokan

 

[sebastien]

get rid off cole,williams,morrison,rowe,lokan

you must be joking

 

[goalpie]

I think thers is spots for tall defenders. Wakelin 31 will be the first tall to go. Thats the thing about list management, you have to see into the future otherwise we will end up like Carlton. Presti and Clement are not spring chickens either. Balanced recruiting in the future is going to be very interesting and important. Lets hope they get it right.

 

[hotpie]

What about picks? 2nd round?

2nd Round for Richie Cole would be worth considering, especially a Carlton 2nd Round which would still be top 20.

 

[bgs05]

clement will stay at collingwood until he retires, and wakelin is one of the best backline players in the league. i wouldnt get rid of rowe i think hes an up an comer player. i dont think we should trade this players but in the draft get some strong backmen for the future aswell with the trades i said before.

 

[bgs05]

oh and presti he would have to stay. i love him.

 

[Bennycoff]

Maxwell is good must keep him.
Rowe has the potential to be a handy winger.

Williams aint worth much anymore maybe a late draft pick.
Lokan was alright now his a dud, same as williams.
Walker had wraps but wont ever make it in ur side, and dont think his that good. might goto a young side.
Cole is injured right? u could get maybe a 2nd rd pick for him, but prob keep him 4 another yr yet.

Now jason cloke he is goin to be traded am i right? he doesnt get a game,so surely he wont remain on the list. he might want a clean start?

 

[silverphoenix]

Lonie will never play in the black and white again after 2days performance

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Cam Cloke - after today's effort!
Williams
Lokan
Walker

 

[Bennycoff]

is it one cloke finished?
one unsure
one who'll be a star?

 

[hotpie]

Lonie

 

[eddiesmith]

DOnt bother trading, just delist them, they aint worth nothing

Cole- No he is not injured, he is just to ******** to get a game
Walker- Hack, has been surpassed in the forward line and has no ********ing idea in the backline
Williams
Lokan
Fraser- Why bother keeping a soft ******** like him?

That will be all for now

But seriously, lay off Lonie and Morrison, they arent as bad as most make out, same with Woey, but the same players always get blamed for losses and the same players escape blame and often get praised for ******** games

 

[magpies42]

id keep lonie, i just think he will come good!
but get rid of morrison, woewodin, rowe, j cloke, williams.
and obree if we can find a suitable substitue!
i think teh problem is in teh fact we cant find suitabel substitutes for these guys, so we are better of keeping em. Unless we can steal a quality player in return fact is we wont get much better wth draft picks we get or the delisted duds goign around!

And im not syaing there havent been many quality midfielders or players swapping clubs, but we just dont seem to able to get them! for example, stevens, k.johnson, moloney, ottens, gehrig are all good players that we havent managed to secure! hopefully next trade period we will secure a few goodies! i ahve a feeling tenace will be coming our way as will power, but yeah we are long way off tlaking about trades

 

[Magpies2005]

DOnt bother trading, just delist them, they aint worth nothing

Cole- No he is not injured, he is just to ******** to get a game
Fraser- Why bother keeping a soft ******** like him?

ur a collingwood supporter shame shame shame
get rid of fraser? i think u need ur head cleaned out or something his just came back after having no preseason coz of injury and injuries all season.

he will come good and yeah doesnt really matter his signed up for a few more years

 

[trizzles]

Cole - No he is not injured, he is just to ******** to get a game

Think this talk about Coley is utter rubbish. He is only 21 and has over 50 games under his belt.
He has always had his critics, but never to such an extent. I hope that he returns to the side in the near future and makes a real impact.
You blokes better not come back, telling us how good you thought he was and that you love his attitude to get back and play good football after being on the outer.
Talk at this stage of the year, especially about a younger player who has significant improvement in him is a disgrace to supporters of any club.