Poached Cats: those gained and those lost

[Thundercracker]

I don't think Steven King's move to St Kilda really hurt our club as bad as losing Mumford. King was at the end of his career and spent most of 2007 in the seconds. He only got brought back in for the AFL Grand Final after his performance in the VFL Grand Final, and Blake was still an unknown quantity.

I think we should blame Blake for the loss of Mumford rather than Mumford chasing the cash up in Sydney. Mummy was a big loss, since we had to depend on Blake a lot in 2010 and 2011 due to Otto's injuries.

 

[Goggin Our Best]

Ditto David Haynes.

Ditto Andrew McNish Ditto Brett Spinks Ditto Mitchell White Ditto Geoff "Joffa Boy" Miles

Jeez we got some shiit from the Eagles over the years

 

[card20]

Gary Sidebottom - In (from St.Kilda) Out (to Fitzroy)
Carl Stienfort (?) - Out (to Collingwood)
? 'Henry' Higgins - out (to Fitzroy)
Michael Woolnough - out (to Collingwood)

Kevin Higgins I could be wrong but i think his son plays for the Bulldogs?

 

[Pavlovs Cat]

Didnt we get Ken Hinkley from Fitzroy? A more than handy in there.

 

[James1970]

A somewhat handy in from the Eagles -

1999 - B. Cook

 

[steady2]

Fred you might also remember Phil Stevens going to St Kilda. He taught at my primary school for a short time.

Ah, Phil Stevens, I got his autograph, along with Gordon Reid and Bill Ryan in Woomelang, April 1971.

 

[FredLeDeux]

My feeling is that our "ins" played many, many more quality games for us than did our "outs" after they left us.

 

[Moggy]

I love it when the old boys start reminiscing in these threads. :thumbsup;

 

[Hot Tin Roof]

​

 

[copythatover]

COLBERT was not a Judus ,he left because he was made captain at a young age and a lot of older senior players got jealous and thought they should of been captain and kept disrespecting him and started treating him like sh*t .

 

[copythatover]

Michael Mansfield was one of the main culprits and is why he was traded cause he cost us Colbert....so if anyone was a Judus it was Mansfield and the rest of blokes that made Colbert want to leave .

 

[Vdubs]

Ah, Phil Stevens, I got his autograph, along with Gordon Reid and Bill Ryan in Woomelang, April 1971.

girls loved him, thick blond hair, huge muscly thighs, #4 iirc, newc type moustache

 

[copythatover]

Should of picked up Dean Rice when Saints let him go ( His uncle Colin captained Geelong ) he had bad knees but loved the way he played when on the ground .

 

[copythatover]

A somewhat handy in from the Eagles -

1999 - B. Cook

Biggest in by far ,we mite not have footy team if it wasn't for him

 

[RedmanWasHere]

Can we include no gamers?

If so, Brent Cowell, Andrew Carrazzo and Marcus Drum.

 

[corio bay]

Can we include no gamers?

If so, Brent Cowell, Andrew Carrazzo and Marcus Drum.

moloney

 

[RedmanWasHere]

moloney

Moloney played probably 20 games for the Cats.