Poll for my last trade...

[favourites]

Pretty Simple Ive got $365K to spend on a midfielder. I've narrowed it down to three.

1. HAYES, Lenny (STK) GOT WCE and RICH
$357,200

2.SWAN, Dane (COL) GOT SYD and ADEL
$343,000

3.WEST, Scott (WBD) GOT HAW and KANG
$336,800

Please respond in poll or 3.2.1 in reply.

 

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

3. Lenny .. Congrats Lenny

2. West

1. Swan

 

[Zapp]

1st - West
2nd - Swan
3rd - Hayes

Swan and West fairly interchangeable - Swan great for R22 GF if you make it.

 

[Mattlowry]

Swan has the Swans and the Crows. Definately wouldn't go for him. He hasn't been in amazing form lately either.

West and Hayes more interesting. Would go for West though, easier opposition. Reliable.

 

[Bond.ShaneBond]

You'd be mad not to go lenny... check him against wce- last 7 have been 94+
check him against richmond- last 3 have been 95+
he da man!

 

[Zapp]

A few weeks back there was a thread about opposition 100+ scores against the Crows being the highest of any team... given their defensive style, opposition mids have to hold the ball and share it around a bit more. So this counts in favour of Swan IMO, BUT this week for him sucks...

Hayes won't go poor at least, West your best bet.

 

[Beau_Waters for PM]

3.Hayes/West - I can't even decide. Although I voted Hayes.


-1. Swan

Nice stats there Bond, Hayes should have 2 great games. But did you check out West?

West vs Hawthorn:
Last 4: av 111
Last 20: av 89.1

West vs roos:
Last 21: av 79 - nothing special
Last 4: av 80 - not that great, but he's in good form atm

 

[abcxyz]

West vs roos:
Last 21: av 79 - nothing special
Last 4: av 80 - not that great, but he's in good form atm

I dont know the answer but does that mean that West always gets Rawlings and doesn't deal with his close tag well??????

Something else to consider.

 

[Bond.ShaneBond]

3.Hayes/West - I can't even decide. Although I voted Hayes.


-1. Swan

Nice stats there Bond, Hayes should have 2 great games. But did you check out West?

West vs Hawthorn:
Last 4: av 111
Last 20: av 89.1

West vs roos:
Last 21: av 79 - nothing special
Last 4: av 80 - not that great, but he's in good form atm

That's what put me off voting for him, plus swan against the swans... and i love lenny

 

[1eyedPie]

this is very tough choices,

i tossing up between hayes and west myself,

i think i will go hayes though.....

 

[favourites]

I changed, I had to trade Bartel for Kornes and Kerr for Scotland. Shattered means i have to keep Harris. Ah well that DT for ya. Glad i waited til the last minute for the trades!!