Freo Quokkas
Cancelled
I've created a poll for all Big Footy users to have a say on whether they think a Red Card should be implemented and used in AFL and AFLW matches for serious and severe on-field offences.
-
LIVE: St Kilda v Western Bulldogs - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Saints at 51% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Poll: Red Card in AFL - No or Yes?
- Thread starter Freo Quokkas
- Start date
-
- Tags
- report suspension tribunal
- Tagged users None
- Moderator
- #2
yes. not a knee jerk. wondered why since the 80s.
Yes - with with video review to be a part of it. Player infringing to be immediately sent off (and replaced) and not able to be return to the field for a period of 5 minutes. During that 5 minutes the video reviewer to determine whether player can be part of future interchange rotations or not.
I would expect around 1 player per week to be initially sent off but less than 5 across the entire year not be allowed to return to the field of play for the remainder of the game.
Regards
S. Pete
I would expect around 1 player per week to be initially sent off but less than 5 across the entire year not be allowed to return to the field of play for the remainder of the game.
Regards
S. Pete
No.
If we have learnt anything from Score Reviews, VAR in Soccer and the Bunker in NRL it's that adding an additional human element, regardless of how good the technology is, only leads to more controversy and errors in judgement.
The issue surrounds where you set the line for a send off. There is too much grey area for there to be any kind of consistency.
If we have learnt anything from Score Reviews, VAR in Soccer and the Bunker in NRL it's that adding an additional human element, regardless of how good the technology is, only leads to more controversy and errors in judgement.
The issue surrounds where you set the line for a send off. There is too much grey area for there to be any kind of consistency.
StevenwellerHFC
Brownlow Medallist
- Banned
- #6
Never.
Freo Quokkas
Cancelled
- Thread starter
- #7
Please select No or Yes up above at the top and enter it. So far the results are: Yes: 3, to No: 2.
No.
Honestly doesnt serve as a deterrent because the incidents that could possibly result in a red card are incidents where the player is obviously not thinking.
Also, over the years I can only think of 3 or maybe 4 incidents that deserve a red card.
Hall, Bugg, Gaff and Jonas.
But incidents like this are really rare.
Honestly doesnt serve as a deterrent because the incidents that could possibly result in a red card are incidents where the player is obviously not thinking.
Also, over the years I can only think of 3 or maybe 4 incidents that deserve a red card.
Hall, Bugg, Gaff and Jonas.
But incidents like this are really rare.
Tend to agree with that too, but for those 4, why not march them? Or are we afraid that they'll start to use it more (which is a perfectly valid concern)?
Actually, not sure I'd include the Jonas one - it was late, sure, but the ball was there. I'd probably reserve the red for off the ball incidents.
mellowyellow
𝑅𝐹𝒞
Def no!
No, because they will get it wrong 
Definately Yes! The basic logic of a send off rule is impossible to logically argue against. A player should not be allowed to take out an opposition player, leave that team 1 player down and then the offender continues his merry way for the rest of the game. Works well in much older game of Soccer. If someone suggested getting rid of it in Soccer they would be ridiculed.
Jonas was the "maybe" in my post.
I have watched that a few times, very crude hit, he is extremely late and its not like he was going for the ball, just a straight up hit to the back of the head.
But of those 4 incidents, its the one that you could actually debate whether it was a football act or not.
Yeah, guessed Jonas was the maybe - all good. The other 3, no issues at all with a red card. The "football act" test is probably what should be used, and it should come down to there being no subject for debate (in my opinion). I can definitely see how you put Jonas in that group though.
There have been exactly 2 incidents in the past decade where I wouldn't have minded a red card - Barry Hall and Gaff. Only off the ball intentional strikes. No Jonas, no Cameron in contests.
- Jun 6, 2012
- 9,887
- 17,398
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Rampage
Surprised there's no mention of Alistair Lynch. If they just won't stop swinging surely at some point you have to send them off the ground
- Oct 16, 2015
- 24,279
- 30,558
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I vite no purely because the AFL can't get te 50m right.
We've also seen how the tribunal has expanded to ridiculous levels. The red card will end up the same way
We've also seen how the tribunal has expanded to ridiculous levels. The red card will end up the same way
- Banned
- #18
pretty hard to get a bugg/hall/gaff type of strike wrong. A red card isnt going to be applied to dangerous tackle or rough conduct types of things. I worry for anyone who cant see how different those types of things are that they think there will be trouble distinguishing them.
- Banned
- #19
bugg?
No
Can you imagine a red card in Troy Pannells hands when he is umpiring a Doggies game.
Can you imagine a red card in Troy Pannells hands when he is umpiring a Doggies game.
OwnSupply
Debutant
Red and yellow card used in pretty much every league below AFL. Ridiculous AFL didn't implement it decades ago.
- Mar 28, 2018
- 10,491
- 8,454
- AFL Club
- GWS
Yes
But only because I think the umps shouldn't be limited in their authority to control the game if necessary. I would regard it as a reserve power, used rarely if ever, where a player has offended and is at risk if re-offending in game.
But only because I think the umps shouldn't be limited in their authority to control the game if necessary. I would regard it as a reserve power, used rarely if ever, where a player has offended and is at risk if re-offending in game.
- Oct 16, 2015
- 24,279
- 30,558
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Initially no...but then when the tribunal was brought in, did we think players would miss games for things that aren't free kicks
Doss
Ass
- Aug 1, 2011
- 75,214
- 112,305
- AFL Club
- Essendon
No thanks.
- Apr 7, 2017
- 2,235
- 2,476
- AFL Club
- Essendon
In principal I like the idea of penalising poor behaviour and leveling the playing field should that behaviour put a team one man down, but hell no!. The AFL will make a s**t show of it, they need to focus on getting normal umpiring right.
Similar threads
- Poll
