Possible Trade for 4th Pick

[Lenny*]

Would this work?

Richmonds 4th Pick + Ottens
or chaffey
or tivendale
or Fiora
For
Hawks 2nd Pick

Richmonds biggest need is definately our midfeild. If mr wallace and mr miller are serious they would look closely at getting another pick inside the top 3. This could give us 2 superstar midfeilders in future years to get the ball down to richo and browny. I have heard rumours of Brett Deledio and Ryan Griffen could be top 2 picks, it's also said that they both have amazing skills. (which is where tigers lose so many of our games)

This trade would also let hawthorne keep a top 5 pick and give them a player who might just flourish under a new enviroment EG; Ottens

If Hawthorne do not want to do this trade, tigers should look at trading the same players ( 4th pick and a player) for western bulldogs 3rd pick, Tambling is said to go at the 3rd pick and he could be a great midfeilder (wells like) in the future. I know that tambling may slip down to our 4th pick anyway, but i think that we should make sure that we get at least 2 top quality midfielders out of this draft. This trade must be on TW and GM agenda.

 

[jezza]

Can't trade priority picks so 1, 2 and 3 are out of bounds. Best we can do is a trade for picks 5 onwards.

I think we'll see trades happen to get us mid-1st round picks, anything higher will take too much to obtain, the players that could be traded are worth more to us here.

 

[Lenny*]

Can't trade priority picks so 1, 2 and 3 are out of bounds. Best we can do is a trade for picks 5 onwards.

I think we'll see trades happen to get us mid-1st round picks, anything higher will take too much to obtain, the players that could be traded are worth more to us here.

Well ottens must be traded then, im sure adelaide would want a player of his capabilities. That shoudl get us the 8th pick, and that should be used on a midfeilder.

The best we can hope for now is that tambling could fall down to our 4th pick, which i think would be highly unlikely after the draft camp, where he will liekly excel

 

[jezza]

I disagree, Ottens has a lot of improvement and years ahead of him, under the right coach he will be a big star. Our ruck ranks are too thin, it would leave only Stafford (injury prone) and Hall (only good to fill in around the ground). We have picks 1 and 4, we will get 2 of the big name kids, plus something decent with pick 20. There are a lot of players who would be on the trade list who combined might be able to get us another first rounder (say Fiora + 1 other) but we Ottens should be kept.

 

[Lenny*]

I disagree, Ottens has a lot of improvement and years ahead of him, under the right coach he will be a big star. Our ruck ranks are too thin, it would leave only Stafford (injury prone) and Hall (only good to fill in around the ground). We have picks 1 and 4, we will get 2 of the big name kids, plus something decent with pick 20. There are a lot of players who would be on the trade list who combined might be able to get us another first rounder (say Fiora + 1 other) but we Ottens should be kept.

Yeah, ottens will probably flourish under TW. But if adelaide came up with a trade that looked very nice (must include 8th pick) i think TW would get rid of ottens.

Hall must be traded, totally shyzen Houzen

 

[jezza]

I agree that Wallace will listen to any trade offer, the more high draft picks the better as he knows he got plenty of time on his contract to build a team around this year's and last year's draft picks (as 3 of last years went a year early so will actually fit in with this lot coming in).

 

[Lenny*]

Well 1st pick 4th pick and 8th pick sound very nice to me...
In the pastyears for picks 4th and 8th have been
'99
1st pick
4th pick
8th pick Joel Corey
'00
1st pick Nick Riewoldt
4th pick
8th pick
'01
1st pick Luke Hodge
4th pick Graham Polak
8th pick James Bartel
'02
1st pick BRENDON GODDARD
4th pick TIMOTHY WALSH
8th pick LUKE BRENNAN

PLZ add to list

 

[Darth_Tiger]

You two having a nice conversation? pick 4 and ottens for pick 2 would be pure idiocy. might as well give ottens away for free. pick 4 is on a par with 2 in fact only time will tell which will be the better pick. we might trade for one more 1st round pick but wallace has stated he is aiming for finals next year. it is not going to be the all out sale you are expecting.

 

[jezza]

03
1. Cooney
4. Ray
8. ???

 

[sante]

You two having a nice conversation? pick 4 and ottens for pick 2 would be pure idiocy. might as well give ottens away for free. pick 4 is on a par with 2 in fact only time will tell which will be the better pick. we might trade for one more 1st round pick but wallace has stated he is aiming for finals next year. it is not going to be the all out sale you are expecting.

iagree Ottens and the 4th round pick for a second pick is ridiculous, Ottens is worth more than a 1st round pick himself

 

[sante]

03
1. Cooney
4. Ray
8. ???

Tenace or someone like him...maybe Bradley

 

[jezza]

You two having a nice conversation?

Well it's been quiet round these parts, I've been trying to stir up trouble on the Hawks board about only giving their coach 2 years but nobody will bite, I take that as a sign everything I say is right

 

[sante]

Well it's been quiet round these parts, I've been trying to stir up trouble on the Hawks board about only giving their coach 2 years but nobody will bite, I take that as a sign everything I say is right

go to the Collingwood Board they hate it or the Doggies and say thanx for Browny and TW and for not taking Bowden in the trades for Browny!!

 

[jezza]

go to the Collingwood Board they hate it or the Doggies and say thanx for Browny and TW and for not taking Bowden in the trades for Browny!!

every week on white line fever there would be a feral doggies support ringing up trying to put down Brown because he left them. Sad sad sad. As for the collingwood board, well, I don't speak fluent bogan, might need a translator.

 

[DirtyDogTiger]

Can't trade priority picks so 1, 2 and 3 are out of bounds. Best we can do is a trade for picks 5 onwards.

I think we'll see trades happen to get us mid-1st round picks, anything higher will take too much to obtain, the players that could be traded are worth more to us here.

So they've changed the rules since 2001 when Freo traded their priority pick 1 to Haw for Croad and mcpharlin ,,,...and the hawks chose Hodge ?

 

[Nightwolf]

I doubt very much the Hawks will give up any of their early picks. We are going youth is what Clarkson said yesterday, plus ottens? We've got Spida for a few more years, simular player, no thanks!

 

[Punt_Road_Roar]

move along nothing to see here ...................

 

[Rookie]

go to the Collingwood Board they hate it or the Doggies and say thanx for Browny and TW and for not taking Bowden in the trades for Browny!!

He's all yours. We're not complaining.

As for Bowden, we don't want him. Keep him too.

 

[gustiger12]

Would this work?

Richmonds 4th Pick + Ottens

If we traded Otto who would we have to ruck. We would need to trade for another Ruckman. Staff is getting on and could not carry the load on his own, Ray Hall is not a ruckman.

The only way I would trade Otto now is if he desperately wants to go back to Crow Eater Land, but that would mean we would have to look at a trade to get another ready made ruckman somewhere.

 

[Lenny*]

would hawks accept pick 4 and tivendale for pick 2.

Having pick 1 and 2 nearly asures tigers of having 2 quality midfeilders in the future. Pick 4 might force us to draft someone like franklin or Roughead who i fear, will not be superstars.

 

[HighFlyer]

Dirty Dog its possible to trade for priority picks you need to get special AFL permission.

 

[Wrenny]

Ummm first pick has got to be deledio no matter what. Then we need a kp at 4 which will be one of franklin or deledio.

But one guy i really rate is jordan lewis. If only he had more strings to his bow he could be top 4. But we need him in our midfield he is tough and has great skills and good size. Unfortunatly though he will be picked around pick 7-10 so if we can manage to do a trade like fiora or rodan or someone plus something it will be beneficial.

Youth aside if i will leave rodan and fiora out of this and just have a look at the team in a few years with youth injected.

B: Jackson Moore Hartigan
HB: Bowden Hall Johnson
C: Hyde Coughlan Pettifer
HF: Brown Roughhead Schultz
FF: Pettifer Richo Krakouer
Foll: Ottens Deledio Lewis
Int: Newman Stafford Tivendale Fleming
Emg: Raines Gilmour Archibald

 

[jezza]

Ummm first pick has got to be deledio no matter what. Then we need a kp at 4 which will be one of franklin or deledio.

Franklin or Roughead you mean?

 

[Heisenberg_]

You also have pettifer on the wing and the foward pocket

 

[jezza]

You also have pettifer on the wing and the foward pocket

Maybe he has a brother?