possible trades

[tabking]

Polak to Richmond for pick 24
Tivendale, pick 40 for Cupido, pick 23

 

[sinepari]

Interesting.

Judd to Richmond for pick 78?

 

[coffee man]

We'd better jump in first before some-one else nabs it so can we have your pick 56?

These players will be available for it: Fevola, Walker, Whitnall or Thornton

 

[viccles]

Polak for 24 I doubt it

 

[waspy]

Last edited by tabking : Today at 15:40. Reason: mistake

That whole post is still a mistake....you surely can't be serious.

 

[tabking]

what is your argument with it, and what do u think would be fair if these players came up

 

[sinepari]

No matter what you say about Polak, he is still worth a top 10 easy.

Probably top 6.

 

[waspy]

Cupido is of greater value than Tivendale, has far more potential and Tivendale won't provide Essendon anything much at all. At least Cupido is capable of being a very handy player, no doubt that is why you are proposing the trade. And a pick upgrade aswell? Forget it. Polak for pick 24 sounds slightly more realistic but it's still an unlikely trade, why would Freo trade one of the most promising KPP's in the league for a 2nd round pick? They will surely get a Round 1 pick for him if he is traded because plenty of clubs are interested.

 

[theorangeapple]

Winderlich to the roos.

Watch it happen.

 

[tabking]

I think everyone on this forum has under-rated Tivendale, he had a terrible season but does have plenty to offer, I am surprised he has coped as much as he has on here, there are worse players on the market

 

[waspy]

Winderlich to the roos.

Watch it happen.

That rumour has been going around for a while, I'd like to keep Winderlich but if North offer a good pick I wouldn't be surprised if we accepted.

 

[sinepari]

I've heard that too. I wonder what the Roos would give up.

 

[waspy]

I think everyone on this forum has under-rated Tivendale, he had a terrible season but does have plenty to offer, I am surprised he has coped as much as he has on here, there are worse players on the market

Sure, at his best he's a handy player and we might well pick him up via trade...but I don't want to see us trade cupido and a 2nd round pick for Tivendale and a crap pick. That seems like a pretty stupid trade to me.

 

[dave_27]

tiger supporters are **** heads.

were you the same dip sh*t who said welsh for tivendale?

 

[Murray]

I think everyone on this forum has under-rated Tivendale, he had a terrible season but does have plenty to offer, I am surprised he has coped as much as he has on here, there are worse players on the market

Then why are YOU (not Richmond) trying to get rid of him?

 

[theorangeapple]

That rumour has been going around for a while, I'd like to keep Winderlich but if North offer a good pick I wouldn't be surprised if we accepted.

Ive heard that he could be part of a 3 way, with a bigger fish to fry. Winderlich is only a portion. I dont envisage a straight swap.

 

[waspy]

Ive heard that he could be part of a 3 way, with a bigger fish to fry. Winderlich is only a portion. I dont envisage a straight swap.

who is the third club?

 

[Ryan O'Keefe]

Lance Whitnall to Hawthorn For Pick 6 and Nathan Lonie

 

[Swifty_446]

Staying with the standard of this thread, I propose:

T. Knobel to Hawthorn for pick 6 and L. Hodge.

 

[Portia]

T. Thurstans to Collingwood for pick 5

 

[jimmy35]

T. Thurstans to Collingwood for pick 5

Throw in Choco and its done.

 

[Murray]

Pick 69 plus Andrew Williams to WCE for Judd

Beat that!!!

 

[Portia]

Throw in Choco and its done.

Do we get Malthouse?

 

[jimmy35]

Do we get Malthouse?

Sure. X 2 (Package deal)