Remove this Banner Ad

Possible trades

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I

irish_setanta

Club Legend
Joined
Sep 6, 2005
Posts
1,554
Reaction score
1
Location
At the airport
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Man U, Celtic, rabbitohs.
These players where in todays paper as possible trades,
Armstrong(melb)
Cole(coll)
Fevola(carl)
Gardiner(wc)
Goddard(saints)
Green(wc)
Hay(hawks)
Heffernan(melb)
Lonie(coll)
McConnell(wc)
Motlop(roos)
Pickett(power)
Richards(ess)
Saddington(swans)
Tivendale(rich)
Watts(st.kilda)
Welsh(ess)
Whitnall(carl)
Woewodin(coll)

How many of these guys will be at new homes next year, and if so what clubs will they be at?
 
Welsh from essendon is not going anywere why people have rumoured he will be traded to richmond for tivendale is stupid. I don't think essendon are that stupid.
 
dav123 said:
Welsh from essendon is not going anywere why people have rumoured he will be traded to richmond for tivendale is stupid. I don't think essendon are that stupid.
Click to expand...

This is what was written in the paper,Andrew Welsh,resigned for two years in late august, but beleived to be up for grabs. Has been linked to the tigers?
Greg Tivendale,fell out of favour in the latter part of the year. The midfielder has been linked to the bombers.

Dont know how much truth there is in it?
 
Why would essendon give up a young gun like welsh for tivendale who is 25-26 and I think one of the worst discision makers in the AFL. Richmond would be laughing if they got this deal done.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

dav123 said:
Why would essendon give up a young gun like welsh for tivendale who is 25-26 and I think one of the worst discision makers in the AFL. Richmond would be laughing if they got this deal done.
Click to expand...
tivendale just needs abit of confidence so im happy wether we keep him or trade him, but as usual sheedy is probably looking at the tivendale of 2 years ago and jsut hopeing he comes bak lol
 
irish_setanta said:
These players where in todays paper as possible trades,
Armstrong(melb)
Cole(coll)
Fevola(carl)
Gardiner(wc)
Goddard(saints)
Green(wc)
Hay(hawks)
Heffernan(melb)
Lonie(coll)
McConnell(wc)
Motlop(roos)
Pickett(power)
Richards(ess)
Saddington(swans)
Tivendale(rich)
Watts(st.kilda)
Welsh(ess)
Whitnall(carl)
Woewodin(coll)

How many of these guys will be at new homes next year, and if so what clubs will they be at?
Click to expand...
Armstrong to port
picket to roos
saddington to dogs
tivendale stays
welsh stays
whitnall to mel
woewodin to dons
watts to saints
motlop to lions
heffernan to dons
cole to either dons or dogs
goddard to blues
gardiner stays
fev stays
green maybe to a melbourne club
hay to roos
richards to a melbourne club
mcconnel to roos
lonie to sydney.
this is where i think these players mite go but it mite just not happen durind trade week
 
dav123 said:
Why would essendon give up a young gun like welsh for tivendale who is 25-26 and I think one of the worst discision makers in the AFL. Richmond would be laughing if they got this deal done.
Click to expand...

Essendon isn't that stupid. Admittedly the only time I saw Tivendale play live was against us, where he was shocking. Terrible decision making, including a selfish play where he chose to run and bounce. Poor Richo was ignored, and Tivendale then handballed to a stationary teammate who was tackled immediately.

His disposal that game was sub-AFL standard, and all the Richmond fans were calling for his head.

No one would give up Welsh for Tivendale.
 
For WC...

McConnell to a Vic club, yet to be determined
Gardiner Staying :(
Wooden may go to Port
Green wants to be traded, could go anywhere
Adkins and McDougall might also be on the move but not definate
 
coasting said:
For WC...

McConnell to a Vic club, yet to be determined
Gardiner Staying :(
Wooden may go to Port
Green wants to be traded, could go anywhere
Adkins and McDougall might also be on the move but not definate
Click to expand...
i wouldnt mind McConnell or McDougall at the tigers next year
 

Remove this Banner Ad

giantroo said:
Armstrong to port
picket to roos
saddington to dogs
tivendale stays
welsh stays
whitnall to mel
woewodin to dons
watts to saints
motlop to lions
heffernan to dons
cole to either dons or dogs
goddard to blues
gardiner stays
fev stays
green maybe to a melbourne club
hay to roos
richards to a melbourne club
mcconnel to roos
lonie to sydney.
this is where i think these players mite go but it mite just not happen durind trade week
Click to expand...


Think you might be close with a few there.
 
In a similar vein to that other thread:
Armstrong - Melbourne to Port
Cole - Collingwood to Essendon
Fevola - Staying at Carlton
Gardiner - Staying at West Coast
Goddard - Staying at St Kilda
Green - West Coast to ?
Hay - Hawthorn to North Melbourne
Heffernan - Melbourne to Essendon
Lonie - Collingwood to Western Bulldogs
McConnell - West Coast to ?
Motlop - North Melbourne to Port Adelaide
Pickett - Port Adelaide to North Melbourne
Richards - Essendon to ?
Saddington - Sydney to Western Bulldogs
Tivendale - Richmond to ?
Watts - Adelaide to St.Kilda
Welsh - Staying at Essendon
Whitnall - Carlton to Melbourne
Woewodin - Collingwood to Melbourne

If Lance goes Fev won't, and the same in reverse. If Fev goes then I'd be guessing that Goddard will go to Carlton for him.

A few of those will go Pre-Season draft (Woewodin, Cole), and some of the ones with ?'s could be used in 3 ways to get deals done.
 
Tigerbob said:
I have a feeling it will be McConnell and Adkins at Tigerland next year ;)
Click to expand...

Ohh, I hope so :)
 
These were only the ones in the paper today(sunday herald sun), im sure there will be a few out of left field that we didnt expect.
 
Goddard>>> Carlton
Fevola >>> St.Kilda
-------------------------------
Hay>>> Fremantle
Fremantle>>> Dunn
-------------------
Cole>>> Essendon
Richards + 2nd pick>> Collingwood
---------------------
Watts>>> St.Kilda
Pfitzner + 3rd round>> Adelaide
-----------------------
 
Snickers said:
Goddard>>> Carlton
Fevola >>> St.Kilda
-------------------------------
Hay>>> Fremantle
Fremantle>>> Dunn
-------------------
Cole>>> Essendon
Richards + 2nd pick>> Collingwood
---------------------
Watts>>> St.Kilda
Pfitzner + 3rd round>> Adelaide
-----------------------
Click to expand...

fevola wont be leaving and goddard wont be coming to carlton ...
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

For ********s sake Saints fans, Goddard is not of equal worth to Fev. Just because he was a no1 draft pick doesn't mean that has the same value at 50+ goal kicker
 
dav123 said:
Welsh from essendon is not going anywere why people have rumoured he will be traded to richmond for tivendale is stupid. I don't think essendon are that stupid.
Click to expand...

Richards or Bullen for Tivendale would be a reasonable trade..Would prefer to trade Bullen though, maybe trade both and throw in Rodan.
 
Fevola will play all his footy at Carlton, and show his Loyaltie at one club eg, david Neitz who played all his footy with Melbounre, also Matthew Lloyd,james hird etc
 
Andyt30 said:
Fevola will play all his footy at Carlton, and show his Loyaltie at one club eg, david Neitz who played all his footy with Melbounre, also Matthew Lloyd,james hird etc
Click to expand...

Unfortunately i dont think that brendon will have a big say in wether he plays for carlton or not, he lost alot of supporters with some of his on field actions this year, personally i think we should keep him, but by this time next week im sure we will know more?
 
irish_setanta said:
Unfortunately i dont think that brendon will have a big say in wether he plays for carlton or not, he lost alot of supporters with some of his on field actions this year, personally i think we should keep him, but by this time next week im sure we will know more?
Click to expand...

He has a big say. He can't be traded if he doesn't want to be traded.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom