POTY Round 13 (vs. Adelaide)

[Hooley McBoob]

Please number your votes from 5 to 1, with 5 being being best on ground for the Swans.

Young POTY: Jack, White, Smith, Brabazon, Bird, Thornton, Grundy, Veszpremi, Barlow.

 

[Dangas]

Why do we have two threads?

 

[Hooley McBoob]

Because I got excited and started one 1 minute before Grim

 

[Dangas]

Because I got excited and started one 1 minute before Grim

Well who's ever stays, heres my vote:


5. Mattner
4. Kirky
3. Goodes
2. Hall
1. Shaw

Unlucky: LRT, B1, RoK, Teddy

YPOTY: Brabazon
Unlucky: Jack

 

[grimlock]

Has Grundy been eligible for the YPOTY? I've left him out all this time...
Need a ruling CAS.

 

[MF]

Very hard game to give votes on, there's barely anything separating our top 8 or 9 players but Kirk gets full points for being the only one to put in a 4 quarter effort.

5. Kirk
4. Hall
3. Goodes
2. Shaw
1. Mattner

Unlucky... LRT, Jude, ROK, Jolly

YPOTY: Bird

 

[EatBig Australia]

5. Kirk
4. Mattner
3. Shaw
2. Hall
1. Goodes

YPOTY = Brabazon.

 

[grimlock]

5. Mattner
4. ROK
3. Shaw
2. Hall
1. Jack

YPOTY - Jack. Unlucky Braba, I liked his endeavour.

 

[SOPH_CROSS]

5. HALL (didnt think the report was worth it shame it was on his 250th)
4. KIRK
3. ROK
2. GOODES
1. SMITH

U23. Ryan Brabazon

 

[CAS79]

Has Grundy been eligible for the YPOTY? I've left him out all this time...
Need a ruling CAS.

No, need to be U 23 on GF day.

And if your 23 on the wednesday the week after and win the award and there is a draw it's taken off you.... just kidding.

 

[Swans120]

5. Mattner
4. ROK
3. Hall
2. Kirk
1. Shaw

YPOTY: Jack (just beat out Bird, though Braba and Smith were both quite good too)

 

[CAS79]

5: M.Mattner
4: A.Goodes
3: B.Kirk
2: B.Hall
1: R.Shaw

Apolgies: P.Bevan, despite Porps stat book I think Bevo did a decent job.

YPOTY: Brabazon.

 

[MF]

5: M.Mattner
4: A.Goodes
3: B.Kirk
2: B.Hall
1: R.Shaw

Apolgies: P.Bevan, despite Porps stat book I think Bevo did a decent job.

YPOTY: Brabazon.

I don't know that Bevan would have been close to votes for mine but you do have to feel sorry for the guy... He plays on some absolute game-breakers and often does a great job most of the day only to have them tear the game apart in small bursts.

 

[BarneyBent]

5. ROK
4. Goodes
3. Kirk
2. Mattner
1. Shaw

YPOTY: Jack

 

[Hooley McBoob]

5. Kirk
4. ROK
3. Goodes
2. Brabazon
1. Hall

YPOTY: Brabazon.

 

[balldman]

5.Kirk
4.Mattner
3.Hall
2.ROK
1.Goodes

YPOTY: Brabazon.

 

[SM]

5. Kirk
4. Mattner
3. Shaw
2. Jack
1. ROK

YPOTY: Brabazon

 

[kira]

5. M Mattner - go out on a limb and say it was his best game ever for the swans

4. B Kirk

3. A Goodes

2. B Hall - he punched his way down my votes

1. R Shaw

YPOTY: K Jack - complete 180 from his start to the season. Unlikely not be in my regular POTY votes

 

[vonn]

5 Bolton for never giving up.
4 ROK for reliability.
3 Mattner ditto
2 Kirk for another solid game.
1 Goodes

Ypoty BRABOY.

 

[set shots]

5. Mattner
4. ROK
3. Hall
2. Kirk
1. Goodes

YPOTY: Jack again, didn't start the year to flash but has been one of the most consistant players lately.

 

[Skystyler]

5 Kirk
4 ROK
3 Bolton, J
2 Mattner
1 Goodes

ypoty - I'll give it to Brabazon coz he kicked his 1st career goal and didn't suck.

 

[Bonz]

5. Mattner (He was awesome....Didn't expect that way to play yourself into form)
4. Goodes (Hopefully the umps give him some votes)
3. Kirk (Desearves votes week in week out)
2. ROK (The move to the modfield has been fantastic)
1. Hall (Had to lose it *sigh* But was in great form before that)

YPOTY Brabazon

 

[bedford]

5 Mattner
4 Goodes
3 Shaw
2 ROK
1 Jack and ypoty

 

[grimlock]

2 rounds updated!

Round Results
Two ties this time round

Martin Mattner, Brett Kirk 91 - 4.5 votes each
Ryan O'Keefe, Adam Goodes 55 - 2.5 votes each
Barry Hall 27 - 1 vote

Rhyce Shaw 18
Jude Bolton 8
Kieren Jack 4
Ryan Brabazon 2
Nick Smith 1

Overall leaderboard
The ROK, Kirk and Goodes show continues with the three now heading the leaderboard after polling well in this game.

Goodes 30.5
R.O'Keefe 23.5
Kirk 22.5
J.Bolton 22
C.Bolton 18

Shaw 13
McVeigh, Jolly 12
Hall, Richards, Roberts-Thomson 8
Mattner 7.5
Bird 7
Buchanan, Crouch, Grundy 1

 

[vonn]

Goodes MUST poll well with umpies if he polls this well with us.