MVP POTY Tally Thread

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Daisy pushing up the rankings pretty quickly i imagine.

 

[ferrisb]

I'm giving Mebby a helping hand with this for a bit.

Round 7 vs Collingwood
Gibbs 5
Simpson 4
Docherty 3
Cripps 2
Casboult 1

Best New Blue
Byrne

 

[thylacine60]

Not sure what all these player ratings have to do with Post Of The Year. Give it to ferrisb now for the Gorringe\Lemons gag and be done with it.

 

[ferrisb]

Round 7 POTY voting stats

Most popular selections

Gibbs was given votes by 97% of posters (73 out of 75).
Simpson (93%), Docherty (93%) and Casboult (92%) the other high consensus picks.

Best on Ground

Gibbs most popular 5 vote winner, with 36 BOG
Simpson (20), Docherty (9), Cripps (5), Casboult (4) and Curnow (1) the others.

BNB

Byrne was picked by 57 out of 66 BNB votes (86%)

 

[ferrisb]

Round 8 vs Port Adelaide
Docherty 5
Gibbs 4
Kreuzer 3
Cripps 2
Simpson 1

Best New Blue
Sumner

 

[ferrisb]

Round 8 POTY voting stats

Most popular selections

Docherty & Gibbs led the pack, each picked by 96% of posters
Kreuzer (90%), Cripps (75%), Simpson (54%) and Rowe (36%) next

Best on Ground

Docherty most popular 5 vote winner, with 35 BOG
Gibbs not far behind on 28
Kreuzer (4), Cripps (1) & Simpson (1) the only other selections

BNB

Sumner had almost half the votes, followed by Byrne. Plowman was a solid 3rd (despite not being eligible?)

Other

Docherty finished on a total 298 votes. Gibbs fell short by a bee's #31, with 295 votes!*
They were voted for the same amount of times
Doc picked 7 times more as BOG, but Bryce had more selection at 4 OR 5
So Gibbs was consensus as top 2 whereas, Doc polarised - picked more as 5 but also more often lower down the chain


* I recounted to make sure. The result may or may not be appealed to the Florida Supreme Court

 

[ferrisb]

Leaderboard after Round 8

If you don't want to see the score, look away now....



Best New Blue

Weitering 3
Byrne 3
Sumner 2

 

[ferrisb]

Leaderboard stats

• Doc and Cripps the most consistent, each polling in 6 of 8 matches
• And when they poll, they poll well
• Gibbs, E Curnow, Simpson and Wright (!) are next most consistent on 4
• Thomas and Murphy the least consistent (each have 2 BOGs, otherwise haven't polled)
• 3 of the 'Menzel 5' are on the board
• BNB - I suggested to MEB after round 3 that we should engrave Weitering's name on the trophy. Looks like he could have a battle on his hands...

 

[ferrisb]

ps - Props to MEB_ for her efforts so far, too.

Tallying votes is a pain in the @rse!

 

[GordonBlue]

Docherty another GOG. Byrne another BNB

 

[P_Crippy]

The BF Blues Lab with MEB_ and FerrisB

 

[ferrisb]

Round 9 vs North Melb
Docherty 5
Byrne 4
Gibbs 3
Kerridge 2
Cripps 1

Best New Blue
Byrne

 

[ferrisb]

Round 9 POTY voting stats

Most popular selections

• Docherty & Byrne were both unanimous selections
• Gibbs a clear third (86%), followed by Cripps (51%), Kerridge (49%), Sumner (43%) and Plowman (38%)

Best on Ground

• Docherty (26) or Byrne (10) took out every single BOG choice, except.....
• One poster gave Kerridge the 5 votes

BNB

• Byrne had 100% of the BNB votes!*

Other

• Doc was awarded 4 or 5 votes by 36 out of 37 posters. Everyone has the right to call the game as they see it, but this poster should be ashamed!
• Doc averaged 4.68 votes per poster, an astonishing effort and much more unanimous than other weeks I have calculated. I have a feeling this will be surpassed (could we see a perfect result?) by a certain man bun in Round 10...
• Cripps was picked by more posters than Kerridge, but Kerridge finished higher in the tally
• Sumner finished just two votes (34 vs 36) off a place in the final vote tally

* One poster picked Plowman as BNB, depsite a) Plowman being ineligible and b) said poster awarding Byrne 4 votes (behind Doc).......love the creativity!

 

[ferrisb]

Leaderboard after Round 9



Best New Blue

Byrne 4
Weitering 3
Sumner 2

 

[ferrisb]

Leaderboard stats after Round 9

• Doc pulling away a clear lead
• Doc and Cripps leading the way in consistency, finishing in the votes in 7 games each
• Cripps missed a match (Doc has played all), so Cripps has finished in the votes every match he has played this year, bar one!
• Despite polling in 2 less matches, Gibbs leads Cripps on the overall count. When Gibbs plays well, he plays really well. Spoiler alert: round 10....
• Kerridge and Byrne each polled their second match each, moving up the board
• Byrne moves into the outright lead for BNB
• Byrne's round 9 match was only the 2nd time a BNB player has earned more than 1 vote in a match (Weiters was BOG in round 3)
• If Byrne was four weeks younger, he'd be eligible for (and a shot at) the rising star award!!!