PSD Targets

[celtic_pride]

Why the hell did we go for Mclaren in the PSD instead of say that young White bloke from Richmond ?
He looks allright.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Why the hell did we go for Mclaren in the PSD instead of say that young White bloke from Richmond ?
He looks allright.

Because we needed a quick fix ruck soloution.

 

[Silvagnis]

Why the hell did we go for Mclaren in the PSD instead of say that young White bloke from Richmond ?
He looks allright.

Because Mojo doesn't run Carlton.

Jimthegreat does.

 

[BlueFeaver]

Dear me, I hope we don't trade Nick Stevens. He may be soft and playing crap footy, but we all know what he can do, and I bet you it's a hell of a lot more than a player picked between 10 and 25. Frankly, I just don't rate the National Draft that highly. A player may have talent, but without a good attitude and good nurturing from the coaching staff, that talent won't amount to anything. But don't take my word for it. Just have a look at all the top 20 drafties in recent years. I bet not 1 draft has had even 10 players turn out better than Nick Stevens.

Michael Gardiner is still my prefered choice in the PSD. - Simply because he is the best player available, and at a prime age. Gardiner may be many things, but a dud he is not. .... And strooth, we could certainly use a decent ruckman.

Dear Funkalicous,
The recruiting policy you hold so dear is what put us in the mire we are in. Drafting others clubs rejects with bad attitudes will only slow down our advancement up the ladder. The National Draft can be a bit hit and miss in the later rounds but with such a deep draft boasting so much talent we would be crazy not to capitalise. Trading Nick is a gamble in it's self but I feel if we don't act this year he will leave on his own accord next year leaving us with nothing. The club needs to approach recruitment with a modern up to date approach, if we don't we will fall further behind our competition. Why has Carlton fallen from grace? It was our own arrogance in not excepting change, Collins was still guilty of this in his regard as I think Smorgan is a little. We need to choose a clear path of direction for the club, this I feel still hasn't been resolved.

Kind Regards
BlueFeaver.

 

[Silvagnis]

Dear me, I hope we don't trade Nick Stevens. He may be soft and playing crap footy, but we all know what he can do, and I bet you it's a hell of a lot more than a player picked between 10 and 25. Frankly, I just don't rate the National Draft that highly. A player may have talent, but without a good attitude and good nurturing from the coaching staff, that talent won't amount to anything. But don't take my word for it. Just have a look at all the top 20 drafties in recent years. I bet not 1 draft has had even 10 players turn out better than Nick Stevens.

I'd trade him for 10 of the top 21 from this draft year.

Stars such as Hodge, Ball, Judd, Bartel, Maguire, Dal Santo, Mitchell, Ablett plus Browne, Reilly, Roberts-Thomson, Hale, Clarke, Sampi, Montagna, Gram, Waite, Swan, Harris, Hyde and Seaby is still a very good draft.

I'd take two of those players in the second round for Stevens if they bust their gut.

This draft is shaping up as another great one according to the good judges.

1	Luke Hodge	Hawthorn	Geelong U18	U18 VCFL
2	Luke Ball	St Kilda	Sandringham U18	U18 VMFL
3	Chris Judd	WC Eagles	Sandringham U18	U18 VMFL
4	Graham Polak	Fremantle	East Fremantle 	WAFL
5	Xavier Clarke	St Kilda	St Marys 	NT
6	Ashley Sampi	WC Eagles	South Fremantle 	WAFL
7	David Hale	Kangaroos	Broadbeach 	Qld
8	James Bartel	Geelong	Geelong U18	U18 VCFL
9	Luke Molan	Melbourne	Geelong U18	U18 VCFL
10	Sam Power	W Bulldogs	Oakleigh U18	U18 VMFL
11	Richard Cole	Collingwood	Eastern U18	U18 VMFL
12	Brent Reilly	Adelaide	Calder U18	U18 VMFL
13	Nick Del Santo	St Kilda	Bendigo U18	U18 VCFL
14	Ashley Watson	Kangaroos	Bendigo U18	U18 VCFL
15	Barry Brooks	Port Adelaide	Tasmania U18	U18 Tas
16	Rick Ladson	Hawthorn	Bendigo U18	U18 VCFL
17	James Kelly	Geelong	Calder U18	U18 VMFL
18	Shane Harvey	Essendon	Northern U18	U18 VMFL
19	Jason Gram	Brisbane	Gippsland U18	U18 VCFL
20	Daniel Elstone	Hawthorn	Bendigo U18	U18 VCFL
21	Matt Maguire	St Kilda	Geelong U18	U18 VCFL
22	Mark Seaby	WC Eagles	West Perth 	WAFL
23	Charlie Gardiner	Geelong	Sandringham U18	U18 VMFL
24	Steve Johnson	Geelong	Murray U18	U18 VCFL
25	Steven Armstrong	Melbourne	Perth 	WAFL
26	Aaron Rogers	Melbourne	NSW-ACT U18	U18 NSW-ACT
27	Tom Davidson	Collingwood	Geelong U18	U18 VCFL
28	Mark Powell	Sydney	Murray U18	U18 VCFL
29	Lewis Roberts-Thomson	Sydney	NSW-ACT U18	U18 NSW-ACT
30	Rod Crowe	Kangaroos	Sandringham U18	U18 VMFL
31	Joel Reynolds	Essendon	Geelong U18	U18 VCFL
32	Campbell Brown	Hawthorn	Oakleigh U18	U18 VMFL
33	David Rodan	Richmond	Calder U18	U18 VMFL
34	Simon OÕKeefe	Essendon	Murray U18	U18 VCFL
35	Jarrad Wright	Brisbane	Woodville-West Torrens 	SANFL
36	Sam Mitchell	Hawthorn	Box Hill Hawks	VFA
37	Leigh Montagna	St Kilda	Northern U18	U18 VMFL
38	Ashley Hansen	WC Eagles	Oakleigh U18	U18 VMFL
39	Justin Davies	Carlton	Murray U18	U18 VCFL
40	Gary Ablett junior	Geelong	Geelong U18	U18 VCFL
41	Henry Playfair	Geelong	NSW-ACT U18	U18 NSW-ACT
42	Kieran McGuinness	W Bulldogs	Eastern U18	U18 VMFL
43	Mark McGough	Collingwood	Murray U18	U18 VCFL
44	Ben Finnin	Adelaide	Northern U18	U18 VMFL
45	Nathan Clarke	Brisbane	Brisbane 	AFL
46	Jarrad Waite	Carlton	Murray U18	U18 VCFL
47	Andrew Welsh	Essendon	Calder U18	U18 VMFL
48	Simon Cox	Hawthorn	W Bulldogs	AFL
49	Josh Houlihan	St Kilda	Murray U18	U18 VCFL
50	Paul Salmon	Essendon	Hawthorn 	AFL
51	Not utilised 	Brisbane	n/a	n/a
52	Andrew Browne	Fremantle	Claremont 	WAFL
53	Daniel Hunt	Sydney	South Fremantle 	WAFL
54	Ben Robbins	Kangaroos	Brisbane 	AFL
55	Brad Miller	Melbourne	Mt Gravatt 	Qld
56	Paul Medhurst	Fremantle	Claremont 	WAFL
57	Brent Colbert	W Bulldogs	Northern U18	U18 VMFL
58	Dane Swan	Collingwood	Calder U18	U18 VMFL
59	Jacob Schuback	Adelaide	Gippsland U18	U18 VCFL
60	Adam Schneider	Sydney	NSW-ACT U18	U18 NSW-ACT
61	Mick Martyn	Kangaroos	Kangaroos	AFL
62	Damon White	Port Adelaide	Perth 	WAFL
63	Adam L. Houlihan	Richmond	Geelong 	AFL
64	Daniel McAlister	Essendon	Essendon	AFL
65	Not utilised 	Brisbane	n/a	n/a
66	Not utilised 	Fremantle	n/a	n/a
67	Not utilised 	St Kilda	n/a	n/a
68	Chris Hyde	Richmond	Richmond	AFL
69	Matthew McCarthy	Geelong	Old Xaverians	VAFA
70	Not utilised 	Melbourne	n/a	n/a
71	Brian Harris	W Bulldogs	Woodville-West Torrens 	SANFL
72	Tristen Walker	Collingwood	Claremont 	WAFL
73	Not utilised 	Adelaide	n/a	n/a
74	Ricky Mott	Sydney	South Fremantle 	WAFL
75	Sam Cranage	Carlton	Carlton	AFL
76	Jared Poulton	Port Adelaide	Port Adelaide 	AFL
77	Martin McGrath	Richmond	South Fremantle 	WAFL
78	Not utilised 	Essendon	n/a	n/a
79	Not utilised 	St Kilda	n/a	n/a
80	Hugh Foott	Kangaroos	Bendigo U18	U18 VCFL
81	David Johnson	Geelong	Essendon Reserves	AFL RES
82	Not utilised 	Melbourne	n/a	n/a
83	Aaron James	W Bulldogs	Richmond

 

[4blues]

Sorry about my ignorance but if we end the season like this what picks will we have in the National Draft?

If we finish last we get pick 1, 17, 19pp,35,51