Toast Qstick, welcome to Collingwood.

[TradeDraft]

Well that what People said is Reporting what has been said on 6pr.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/lynch-to-pies.968532/#post-25357571

 

[jimmy35]

Take it with a grain of salt Dave

 

[jonesy86]

With or without Cloke he'd be perfect for the L.Brown role and Dawes can stay as a KP forward, replaces Tazza in current 22.

 

[TradeDraft]

Take it with a grain of salt Dave

I do because at the Moment it's all Talk and you never know 100% unless Proof Comes Out

 

[Cory]

He'd be very handy.

 

[Optimax]

Would prefer he comes in and plays in front of Dawes then any sort of cloke replacement.

Thinking of next year, hopefully Paine plays more often then not

 

[SpongePie]

Ok so we are getting Lynch, Tippet, Goddard and Fev. Looks alright for next year.

*crosses fingers for Nic Nat, Ablett and Buddy rumors*

 

[76woodenspooners]

Well that what People said is Reporting what has been said on 6pr.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/lynch-to-pies.968532/#post-25357571

Um Dave, are you peddling a rumor here by chance?

 

[Frankie23]

Is the perfect replacement for L.Brown/Cloke, plus gives Paine an extra year or so to develop and Dawes a chance to get out of the ruck.

Will wait for trade month before I get too pumped up over it.

 

[Shade]

Ok so we are getting Lynch, Tippet, Goddard and Fev. Looks alright for next year.

*crosses fingers for Nic Nat, Ablett and Buddy rumors*

I'll start one up if you like seems to be the trend around here

 

[TradeDraft]

Um Dave, are you peddling a rumor here by chance?

I am just Reporting what was said in another Forum

 

[TradeDraft]

Is the perfect replacement for L.Brown/Cloke, plus gives Paine an extra year or so to develop and Dawes a chance to get out of the ruck.

Will wait for trade month before I get too pumped up over it.

Well he is a Free Ageny(UnRistricted?) so there be no Trade

 

[Scodog10]

I am just Reporting what was said in another Forum

Which equates to you peddling a rumor

 

[Frankie23]

Well he is a Free Ageny(UnRistricted?) so there be no Trade

Was referring more to the actual 'trade' period where trades occur/free agents move. But yes, it could be his last contract, if we offer him some good money he could be tempted as it will set him up for life post-footy.

 

[JOELY]

TD, don't peak too early. we want your ten threads a day minimum come trade week.

not giving too much credence to the rumour, but i hope the club is making moves in preparation for cloke possibly leaving, lynch would be a nice stop-gap option we won't have to trade for.

 

[Old Spice]

If Q-Stick came would be able to get rid of Wood, although our ruck stocks are already dangerously thin, so possibly not. But you'd only have to add 50k or so to what Wood is currently getting per year. Still interested in Stefan Martin but Q-Balls would probably be the bridge to Witts-town.

Then we may be able to chase a true champion of Cloke were to leave.

On another topic, be interesting to see if we'd bother with a Danyle Pearce. Only on the cheap.

 

[rose jam]

Is the perfect replacement for Cloke? You guys are on some serious crack.

Cloke stays.

Q stick is inconsistent and does a lot of stupid s***. Don't want him.

 

[Old Spice]

Don't think anyone thinks he's the 'perfect replacement' but would be very handy, in fact necessary. What are the other options?

 

[Maggie5]

No, No and No. Prefer to breed our own.

 

[TradeDraft]

No, No and No. Prefer to breed our own.

So you would leave Dawes in the Ruck?

 

[Shade]

No, No and No. Prefer to breed our own.

What does this even mean ?

Do we have ready made replacements if Cloke leaves?

 

[Pera]

If we did get the Q-Stick though, we would lose our compensation picks for Cloke, unless we lose someone else to free agency. Not sure losing a pick in the 10-15 mark for Quentin Lynch is something the club wants, as much as we do need a ruckman/forward.

 

[TradeDraft]

If we did get the Q-Stick though, we would lose our compensation picks for Cloke, unless we lose someone else to free agency. Not sure losing a pick in the 10-15 mark for Quentin Lynch is something the club wants, as much as we do need a ruckman/forward.

Well Depends on how Hine Rates the Draft and Hine has no Problem Trading our High Draft Picks and Why would we lose it?

 

[Maggie5]

Actually yes I would, Dawes is playing without confidence but I like the 1 per centers that goes un-noticed. I don't think that Lynch is the answer if Cloke leaves. Just my opinion.

 

[TradeDraft]

Actually yes I would, Dawes is playing without confidence but I like the 1 per centers that goes un-noticed. I don't think that Lynch is the answer if Cloke leaves. Just my opinion.

There is no Answer for Cloke though how Cloke is going at the Moment Lynch would be no worse.

Dawes would take Cloke's Spot and Lynch would take Dawes spot and play the Leroy Role