Preview R10: Changes v Pies, 2024

[Crow till I die]

Curtin has to look like a complete footballer over five quarters of football over two weeks apparently meanwhile we play McHenry and Murphy who deliver mistake after mistake every ******* week.....

I wonder what nicks would say if challenged that why do you drop Curtin etc for making some mistakes, refuse to pick dowling, taylor etc but accept error after error from mchenry and murphy. Don't gaslight us as we watch the same game you do and are keenly aware of their shortcomings.

I'd love to hear the reply

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

You just know that McHenry will get a two-year extension.

"We really appreciate what he brings to the side. Without him, we don't have the full puzzle as he fills a shape that no other player can replicate."

 

[Scorpus]

You don’t leave players out that ooze leadership

The only person oozing anything is Nicks at the thought of bringing in Murphy

 

[FR0GGY]

I wonder what nicks would say if challenged that why do you drop Curtin etc for making some mistakes, refuse to pick dowling, taylor etc but accept error after error from mchenry and murphy. Don't gaslight us as we watch the same game you do and are keenly aware of their shortcomings.

I'd love to hear the reply

It’s just a hobby for us.

 

[BACCS]

Well I was right on Hamill & Murphy.

Just unfortunately wrong with McHenry surviving for Schoenberg.

Rightly should be melts with these changes.

Disgusting changes, genuinely spew worthy

 

[Smart Fella]

You don’t leave players out that ooze leadership

Agree, I remember the three games Murphy played earlier in the year where he, and the Crows dominated!

On motorola edge 30 pro using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Disgusting changes, genuinely spew worthy

The only change I wanted the club to make (Schoenberg) of the 3 I thought they would make, they didn't make.

 

[dogs105]

I did not watch SANFL last week - was Hamill good? He was very ordinary against Port 2 weeks ago.

 

[WheresGroomgone]

Agh Nicksy you champion you got the team back together….

Murphy, McHenry, Scholl, Smith…

even Jonesy gets a crack

and the big man Rob in incredible form!

Those poor magpies.

 

[MarcusP2]

A return!

 

[MRB37]

Agh Nicksy you champion you got the team back together….

Murphy, McHenry, Scholl, Smith…

even Jonesy gets a crack

and the big man Rob in incredible form!

Those poor magpies.

You'd of thought we'd won a premiership with that lot given how many chances they get.

 

[BACCS]

How on earth has Schoenberg not even made the emergencies? Why do we need two talls?

 

[BACCS]

You'd of thought we'd won a premiership with that lot given how many chances they get.

Sholl is in a good patch of form, only one of the 4 that deserved their spot though

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I want to know what WaynesWorld19 thinks

Not enamoured by the changes ....I understand COLL are going with a medium size fwd line, but our depth is being exposed

We shouldn't have Ned & Murphy in the same team .....but there's no-one really to bring in

Hamill, Meh! ....Oscar Ryan must be close

Given the damning video of Crouch on Footy Classified .....he must be on the edge of being the sub .....it's that lack of two-way running that's always been the negative on Crouch
Time to move on from Crouch !

 

[FR0GGY]

How on earth has Schoenberg not even made the emergencies? Why do we need two talls?

Kept out for the sanfl

 

[NSolis]

As opposed to every other player that has great games each week.. I mean that's why we're 3-5 right?

Seasons cooked. Anyone who agrees with Curtin out is also cooked

Curtin out makes a fair amount of sense. I was hoping he'd be retained but it's not surprising he was dropped. Was absolutely dreadful against Brisbane and Collingwood don't have many tall forwards so going with a shorter backline makes sense.

Some of the other retained players are difficult to understand, however.

 

[Geoffa32]

Schoenberg was better than Murphy last week.

Much prefer him over Murphy as that stoppage mid role

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Samcro24]

Mat Nicks
Matthew Nicks
Mathew Nicks
Matt Nicks
Mat Nix
Mathew Nix
Matthew Nix
Matt Nix
Mat Knicks
Matthew Knicks
Mathew Knicks
Matt Knicks

Lynda Loads is his alias account.

Full apologist mode engaged tonight.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Not enamoured by the changes ....I understand COLL are going with a medium size fwd line, but our depth is being exposed

We shouldn't have Ned & Murphy in the same team .....but there's no-one really to bring in

Hamill, Meh! ....Oscar Ryan must be close

Given the damning video of Crouch on Footy Classified .....he must be on the edge of being the sub .....it's that lack of two-way running that's always been the negative on Crouch
Time to move on from Crouch !

No one?

Schoenberg for starters has been in better sanfl form than Murphy.

How do you logically explain this?

 

[Eagleboy2011]

I thought Borlase would be an auto replacement for Worrall. We can't go in with Murthy and Ned. The club has gone mad.

 

[dogs105]

How on earth has Schoenberg not even made the emergencies? Why do we need two talls?

Well we dropped 2 from the team, and replaced them with a half bank flanker and a high half forward....

Perhaps it still counts as a balanced team if you fill up the Emergencies?

 

[MarcusP2]

There is literally no reason to select Murphy that doesn't apply even more so to other players not selected.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

No one?

Schoenberg for starters has been in better sanfl form than Murphy.

How do you logically explain this?

Murphy or Hamill are not playing midfield .....nor is Shoenberg a pressure forward .....he's a running mid / wing possibly

 

[WheresGroomgone]

Not enamoured by the changes ....I understand COLL are going with a medium size fwd line, but our depth is being exposed

We shouldn't have Ned & Murphy in the same team .....but there's no-one really to bring in

Hamill, Meh! ....Oscar Ryan must be close

Given the damning video of Crouch on Footy Classified .....he must be on the edge of being the sub .....it's that lack of two-way running that's always been the negative on Crouch
Time to move on from Crouch !

No one to bring in?

Curtin could have stayed.
Dowling has been very good and kicks goals
Schoenberg has been very good.
Taylor has been good and deserves some taste.

 

[Shuestar13]

I shouldn’t dare ask, but as I’ve liked a few of the AFC’s posts on FB, they appear in my feed. Is Lynda Loades, Lindy? The famous one (Full Lindy) Her posts are.. um interesting