Raines Or Birchall??

[alekstah]

im trading off either raines or birchall for mcphee and i need to know which one will be more consistant and valuable through out the season? both of them did reasonably well last season and showed signs of great potential. who will do better this weekend do you think?

 

[Cynic]

Raines tends to be accountable.

Birchall tends to be unaccountable.

 

[Cartman121]

you better be kidding me, keep birchall for sure, i couldnt believe the poll Birchall has had one bad game and one super game give him a fair go, he is a gr8 player for dream team and is a great prospect for future, raines has never put up good DT scores and i cant see why so many people have jumped on his bandwagon,

RAINES DEFINTELY

 

[Jonathan]

keep BIRCHALL!!!!
trade raines

 

[the-X-factor]

The question was... "who will do better this weekend do you think?"
Most people have responded Birchall. Yes, he had a poor game on the weekend, but he wont score lower than that. Oh, and he scored 100 plus against the Kangaroos and Geelong (who Hawthorn play the next two weeks) last year

 

[Ahwooga]

Raines = DT dud, Birchall = DT star

 

[magpies03]

Birchall Average = 71

Raines Average= 47.50


.....Ill leave it at that

 

[lion_gooner]

both play for teams who are known to flood heavily especially richmond so you would kind of expect raines to get more points