Rate Our Key Position Players

[Cotcho]

Jack = Great
Vickery = OK
Chaplin = Good
Rance = Ok
Bachelor = Is he even a KPP?
Grimes = Potentially great but needs solid around him
Mcguane Edwards = Depth
Griffiths, Astbury, Mcbean, Elton = Nothing yet

Hmmmm a bit light on I woulda thought.

 

[wart101]

i dont think we can keep both Astbury and Griffo but it might be viable to hold onto one and see if we can develop him, i would like to see chocco's opinion of griffo!

 

[CoggaRules]

i dont think we can keep both Astbury and Griffo but it might be viable to hold onto one and see if we can develop him, i would like to see chocco's opinion of griffo!

Going to call it with these two and its time to put a line through their names and find something better to work with. Their constitution is just not up to the standard required in AFL footy. Enough of the spoon fed shit we are getting used to here.

 

[wart101]

Going to call it with these two and its time to put a line through their names and find something better to work with. Their constitution is just not up to the standard required in AFL footy. Enough of the spoon fed shit we are getting used to here.

yeah i feel the same way, just make room for talent IMO, i guess i get a little hung up on but what if!!!!!

 

[theflea]

as an up and coming player in junior he was bloody awsome, massive kick KPF, he hasn't been given a good chance to blossom as a forward which is frustrating since that is what he does best, being groomed a backman has sent him backwards in development IMO he is just a natural forward, could Richardson play as a backman? NO!

A: he performed as a fwd.

B: he was second in the brownlow out of position.

Just saying.

 

[DustinsGuns]

A - Riewoldt
B - Chaplin, Rance, Maric
C - Vickery, Grimes
D - McGuane, Astbury, Elton, McBean, Stephenson
F - Griffiths, Derickx

Grading:
A - would get a game in every teams best 22
B - would get a game in most teams, other then maybe the top 4.
C - Would get a game in bottom 8 teams, fringe at best in top 8 teams
D - Would only get a game in developing teams
F - Wouldn't get a game in EFL divy 4

 

[Squibbs]

A - Riewoldt
B - Chaplin, Rance, Maric
C - Vickery, Grimes
D - McGuane, Astbury, Elton, McBean, Stephenson
F - Griffiths, Derickx

Grading:
A - would get a game in every teams best 22
B - would get a game in most teams, other then maybe the top 4.
C - Would get a game in bottom 8 teams, fringe at best in top 8 teams
D - Would only get a game in developing teams
F - Wouldn't get a game in EFL divy 4

G - Robin Nahas

Grading:
G - wouldn't get a game in Auskick.

 

[Tony Harrison]

G - Robin Nahas

Grading:
G - wouldn't get a game in Auskick.

So you're saying Auskick team > Coburg?