re do the 2006 draft

[geelong_crazy26]

been in the system six years now, all fully developed now being mostly 24, time to properly rank how they have turned out

1. Tom Hawkins
2. Joel Selwood
3. Josh kennedy
4. Jack Riewoldt
5. Ben reid
6. James frawley
7. Bryce gibbs
8. Travis boak
9. Kurt tippett
10. Tod goldstein
11. Erick mckenzie
12. Nathan brown
13. Lindsay thomas
14. Lachlan Hansen
15. Shaun hampson
16. Aaron edwards

 

[Groupie_]

Looool not sure if serious?

To date the top 4 is:

1. Joel Selwood
2. Jack Riewoldt
3. Hawkins
4. Kennedy

Kennedy could be 3rd but I gave you the benefit of the doubt.

Jack's career so far has been better than Hawkin's or Kennedy's.

Joel Selwood is a clear first.

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Looool not sure if serious?

To date the top 4 is:

1. Joel Selwood
2. Jack Riewoldt
3. Hawkins
4. Kennedy

Kennedy could be 3rd but I gave you the benefit of the doubt.

Jack's career so far has been better than Hawkin's or Kennedy's.

Joel Selwood is a clear first.

Frawley?

 

[Groupie_]

Frawley?

I was just redoing his top 4..

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

1. Joel Selwood
2. Josh kennedy
3. Jack Riewoldt
4. James frawley
5. Ben reid
6. Tom Hawkins

The standouts. Jack's been pretty much even with Tomahawk this year. Unlike Tomahawk though he has anothter 62 goal season and a 78 goal season under his belt. Given their even form you'd be stupid to take Hawkin's first 6 years over Jack's.

Jack's shown a much higher peak so far.

 

[Daz]

Selwood (7)
J.Riewoldt (13)
Hawkins (FS)
Kennedy (FS)
Jacobs (r)
Frawley (12)
Leuenberger (4)
Goldstein (37)
Reid (8)
Tippett (32)
Gibbs (1)
Boak (5)
Gray (55)
Lonergan (r)
Adams (r)
Thomas (53)
Suckling (r)
Schofield (50)
N.Brown (10)
MacKenzie (29)
Wellingham (r)
Armitage (9)
Harbrow (r)


Unbelievably good draft for talls.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Looool not sure if serious?

To date the top 4 is:

1. Joel Selwood
2. Jack Riewoldt
3. Hawkins
4. Kennedy

Kennedy could be 3rd but I gave you the benefit of the doubt.

Jack's career so far has been better than Hawkin's or Kennedy's.

Joel Selwood is a clear first.

i disagree on riewoldt, i agree that over the six year period he has been better, but it took hawkins a lot longer to develop and find his feet, hawkins has now developed into arguably the premier key forward of the competition alongside franklin, so yes i agree with you that over the stretch riewoldt has accomplished more, but right now hawkins is clearly a better player and just about every club would pick him ahead of riewoldt and i think also selwood

 

[Crow_Sting]

1. Joel Selwood

Daylight

Hawkins/Riewoldt take your pick

Kennedy

 

[geelong_crazy26]

1. Joel Selwood
2. Josh kennedy
3. Jack Riewoldt
4. James frawley
5. Ben reid
6. Tom Hawkins

The standouts. Jack's been pretty much even with Tomahawk this year. Unlike Tomahawk though he has anothter 62 goal season and a 78 goal season under his belt. Given their even form you'd be stupid to take Hawkin's first 6 years over Jack's.

Jack's shown a much higher peak so far.

Fair call and opinion which your entitled to, i was hoping to see differing opinios and debate

just my personal opinion that hawkins has now developed into the premier forward in the game along side franklin, no doubt his six years in the competition arent as glorified as riewoldts, but i believe hawkins has developed into the superior player, the monster prescense he has in the forward fifty and contested ability is something we havent seen since tony lockett, a number of commentators have mentioned this, i rate him above selwood now also

but if your going by your criteria of performance over a six year period then riewoldt and several others are ahead including tippett and reid

 

[Mister_A]

1. Joel Selwood
2. Ben Reid
3. Sam Jacobs
4. Bryce Gibbs
5. Tom Hawkins
6. Jack Riewoldt
7. Josh Kennedy
8. James Frawley
9. Kurt Tippett
10. Robbie Gray

etc..

just my personal opinion that hawkins has now developed into the premier forward in the game along side franklin

Franklin>Pavlich>Cloke>Petrie>Hawkins>Reiwoldt(either/both)>Others

 

[Ambrosia]

Not a fan of having father son and NSW scholarship players in redo threads. If it's rank the players from the draft then they should be included but it's not really a draft redo with them being moved around.

 

[Tulip]

Joel Selwood
Jack Riewoldt
Tom Hawkins
James Frawley
Ben Reid
Josh Kennedy
Kurt Tippett
Sam Jacobs
Matt Leuenberger
Bryce Gibbs
Todd Goldstein

Amazing draft for talls, especially with the second and third picks being probably the worst performed big men.

The difference between 1 and 11 is negligible.