rix or ackland?

[TASSIE SAINT]

coming into finals u need 2 ruckmen no doubt, kosi number 1 who get's the 2nd spot rix or ackland? sailnts4flag

 

[toddy]

I would say Rix as i have not seen Ackland play defence and you may need that against some sides with a number of talls, like Adelaide, with the big loss of Goose.

 

[Kildonan]

Brooks again performing well in the Scorpions.
I'd prefer Ackland, but I wouldn't be upset if we tried Brooks in Brisbane.
It may be a bit late, but I fear that he will be lost to the system (delisted) and we still haven't given him a real go.

 

[Fehring]

Not even close. Rix.

 

[crazy_big_al]

ackland has the heart the size of a pea and would not perform inm finals when it is on the line

 

[kosi_23]

Has to be Rix.
Ackland's jumping in the ruck is way off.

 

[mightymagpie1999]

I would have to say Rix but only as long as he doesnt play in defence....The last couple of weeks he has been toweled up down back he is slow when his opponent is on the lead and looks lost in the backline. Not saying hes not a good player but i would prefer to see him in the ruck or forward line not defence

 

[nicko016]

Rix for me. It's been a fairly impressive first 10 games of AFL footy. He wins the most hitouts and is hard and tough. He is also took a couple of good grabs against the WB.