Robbo's top 50 for 2016

[Wild Bill]

Robbo has put a list of the best 50 players in 2016.

1. Dangerfield
2. Rance
3. Buddy
4. Betts
5. Sloane
6. J Selwood
7. T Lynch Suns
8. Bont
9. Kennedy swans
10. Parker

11. Martin
12. Kennedy WCE
13. Hannebery
14. H Shaw
15. Gawn
16. Pendlebury
17. N Riewoldt
18. C Rioli
19. R Gray
20. Coniglio

21. Shuey
22. Z Merrett
23. D Talia
24. Cripps
25. Rampe
26. Enright
27. J McGovern
28. Shiel
29. S Mitchell
30. Treloar

31. Gaff
32. Neale
33. T Greene
34. D Morris
35. K Simpson
36. J Steven
37. Picken
38. C Ward
39. Dahlhaus
40. S May

41. Priddis
42. Docherty
43. Tarrant
44. Laird
45. Hunter
46. Viney
47. M Boyd
48. Zorko
49. Macrea
50. Z Williams

For me too high: Betts, Shaw, May, Merrett & Picken.

Too low - Gawn, Talia, Rampe & Mitchell.

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Gutted for Jack Watts

 

[Halftimehero]

Robbo has put a list of the best 50 players in 2016.

1. Dangerfield
2. Rance
3. Buddy
4. Betts
5. Sloane
6. J Selwood
7. T Lynch Suns
8. Bont
9. Kennedy swans
10. Parker

11. Martin
12. Kennedy WCE
13. Hannebery
14. H Shaw
15. Gawn
16. Pendlebury
17. N Riewoldt
18. C Rioli
19. R Gray
20. Coniglio

21. Shuey
22. Z Merrett
23. D Talia
24. Cripps
25. Rampe
26. Enright
27. J McGovern
28. Shiel
29. S Mitchell
30. Treloar

31. Gaff
32. Neale
33. T Greene
34. D Morris
35. K Simpson
36. J Steven
37. Picken
38. C Ward
39. Dahlhaus
40. S May

41. Priddis
42. Docherty
43. Tarrant
44. Laird
45. Hunter
46. Viney
47. M Boyd
48. Zorko
49. Macrea
50. Z Williams

For me too high: Betts, Shaw, May, Merrett & Picken.

Too low - Gawn, Talia, Rampe & Mitchell.

What a suprise you have potted the only Bomber in it

 

[Canada]

These list are always good, as long as people don't take them too seriously. It's just one blokes opinion. It isn't right or wrong.
I personally think Treloars season was better than Pendles. That Dochertys season was better than Cripps and that Parker, Hannaberry and Kennedy all had better seasons than Selwood. But that's just me.
People getting hassled over 1 persons opinion is just silly.

 

[discomute]

What on earth is the media's fixation with Rance? There is a very good argument that Tarrant was better than him this year. If you want to name Rance in AA over Tarrant, alright, that's your opinion. But #2?? Are you kidding me?

 

[Canada]

What a suprise you have potted the only Bomber in it

Sensitive much. Hardly potting. Just thinks he's too high. I do as well. Opinions man...chill.

 

[Halftimehero]

Sensitive much. Hardly potting. Just thinks he's too high. I do as well. Opinions man...chill.

You don't know Billy boy then, do you?

 

[Canada]

What on earth is the media's fixation with Rance? There is a very good argument that Tarrant was better than him this year. If you want to name Rance in AA over Tarrant, alright, that's your opinion. But #2?? Are you kidding me?

Best defender in the game and by some margin. Thank god we have him. Without him things would have been triple ugly this year.

 

[Wild Bill]

What a suprise you have potted the only Bomber in it

You honestly think he was better than Sam Mitchell this year? Tipping I won't be the only one to put him in the over rated group.

 

[Upgrayedd]

What on earth is the media's fixation with Rance? There is a very good argument that Tarrant was better than him this year. If you want to name Rance in AA over Tarrant, alright, that's your opinion. But #2?? Are you kidding me?

No there isn't. Please stop

 

[SterlingArcher]

You don't know Billy boy then, do you?

You ****ing whinge about him every time he posts, just put him on ignore.

 

[Canada]

You don't know Billy boy then, do you?

He said Merrett was too high. I agree, I'd have had him 40-50.
He didn't pot him.

 

[Wild Bill]

Sensitive much. Hardly potting. Just thinks he's too high. I do as well. Opinions man...chill.

You don't know half time very well - he sooks over any slight on Essendon.

 

[SterlingArcher]

A pretty good effort overall. Wouldn't have Gaff that high personally and Gawn at 15 is probably low, but pretty good effort.

Scully over Z.Williams for me too at 50.

 

[Halftimehero]

You honestly think he was better than Sam Mitchell this year? Tipping I won't be the only one to put him in the over rated group.

So you think he has him one spot too high then? Hardly worth a mention is it?
Top 10 in the Brownlow and top 20 in the coaches votes hardly makes it a big shock that someone has him the 22nd best player of the year, does it?

 

[Membling]

JPK still underrated in the media even at number 9

 

[Toump Ass]

Am I the only one who thinks Bont gets overrated a wee bit? Or maybe it's because every time he goes near the ball, the commentators aurally ejaculate everywhere and it's having a negative effect on my perception of him.

He's obviously going to be a star of the comp, but I don't think he was top 10 of the league last season.

 

[sydney eagle]

At the risk of being controversial I think that Buddy is much too high. Bontempelli and Sloane , at the very least and probably others, should be above him.

 

[Halftimehero]

You ******* whinge about him every time he posts, just put him on ignore.

No fun in that

 

[Sherrinator]

Not very creative.

 

[Jobe Watson]

The Rance jizzfest continues.

Now I really like him, and reckon he's the best KPD in the league. But he was no where near the 2nd best player in the league this year. He didn't even have as good a season as last year.

Think Robbo has just put him that high so he can make it seem like he's one of those cool guys that has players other than midfielders in his top 10 (would explain why Franklin and Betts were next in line).

 

[Wild Bill]

So you think he has him one spot too high then? Hardly worth a mention is it?
Top 10 in the Brownlow and top 20 in the coaches votes hardly makes it a big shock that someone has him the 22nd best player of the year, does it?

1 spot? I have him a lot higher than that.

Didn't make the AA squad of 40.

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Would swap JPK and Jelwood.

 

[WallyStringhaus]

Am I the only one who thinks Bont gets overrated a wee bit? Or maybe it's because every time he goes near the ball, the commentators aurally ejaculate everywhere and it's having a negative effect on my perception of him.

He's obviously going to be a star of the comp, but I don't think he was top 10 of the league last season.

All Australian, Top 10 in Brownlow, B & F in a premiership team. If he's not top 10 you have ridiculously high standards.

 

[Ambrosia]

Rance, Buddy and Betts are too high.