Rookie list for Polak?

[dominguez]

Polak ain't no dumbarse, I guess you're saying that cause he was hit by a tram. Pretty bad form IMO.

You obviously never saw him being interviewed while at Freo, he made Adrian Barich sound intelligent.

There was one interview where he said something like "Duuuh you have to mark it when it's your turn or you look like a pansy."

 

[Stronzo]

Are we talking dumbarse as in dumbarse brigade, or dumbarse as in dumbarse?

 

[dominguez]

lol, whose on first?

I meant dumb arse as in Steve Malaxos and Peter Sumich, people who when they speak you think "That guy's a ****ing moron!"

 

[Stronzo]

lol, whose on first?

I meant dumb arse as in Steve Malaxos and Peter Sumich, people who when they speak you think "That guy's a ****ing moron!"

Ah, yeah probably all the cones he used to allegedly smoke..

He'd be sharp as a tack these days.

 

[Moo]

Who cares if he dropped a few flippers the kid can play, looked very good for us at CHB until cuddles had a brain fart and tried to convert him to a forward.

He has been less than impressive since he has been at Richmond.

 

[Freo Shark]

His field kicking was decent, just his shot for goal was shit. Solve that problem, put him at CHB, he'd be better than the shittrucks McPharlin & Grover.

Disagree. Put McPharlin at CHB and leave him there and he's near elite and AA quality.

Polak had discipline and other issues at Freo and walked out on the club. He is not needed here.

 

[footyfix]

I am absolutely flabbergasted that any Freo fan would ever under any circumstances even consider letting that...Polak back in to our club. I can only assume it is because it's the off season and we just need something, anything to kick around until there is something actually worth pondering. I am really sorry Polak got hit by a tram and truly, I'm happy he has lived but He was a rotten egg here and good riddance. Forever. End of story.

 

[Stronzo]

Disagree. Put McPharlin at CHB and leave him there and he's near elite and AA quality.

Polak had discipline and other issues at Freo and walked out on the club. He is not needed here.

He's on a downward slope now, those days are well behind.

Plenty of upsides with a young Polak though.

 

[Stronzo]

I am absolutely flabbergasted that any Freo fan would ever under any circumstances even consider letting that...Polak back in to our club. I can only assume it is because it's the off season and we just need something, anything to kick around until there is something actually worth pondering. I am really sorry Polak got hit by a tram and truly, I'm happy he has lived but He was a rotten egg here and good riddance. Forever. End of story.

No need for cynicism.

 

[Moo]

Since his accident - his form has been woeful to the point where one club who actually has a worse list than us is delisting him.

He has had discipliine issues and he walked out on us.

Why the hell would we want him?

 

[dominguez]

He's on a downward slope now, those days are well behind.

I agree, hope we're wrong though.

 

[Superkoops]

Also can't see his accident helping with his decision making, remember how he used to mark at CHB then go back off the Dennis Lillee run up allowing the opposition to flood back.

I'm not going to comment on his attitude. Great effort from him in making a comeback.

Dom has summed up my greatest frustration with Polak. I think I could actually hear a clock ticking in his head as he hesitated 5 times before bombing long. His first season at Richmond was ok, second average and his last gone by unfortunately looked totally out of his depth.

Big no from me.

 

[Angus McFuttock]

I'm not going to comment on his attitude. Great effort from him in making a comeback.

Dom has summed up my greatest frustration with Polak. I think I could actually hear a clock ticking in his head as he hesitated 5 times before bombing long. His first season at Richmond was ok, second average and his last gone by unfortunately looked totally out of his depth.

Big no from me.

And that was before he suffered a serious head injury.
McPharlin was and still is an infinitely better footballer than Polak who is too slow to play anywhere but loose man in defence, unless you want him kicking his flourbags up forward.
Anyway, it's not going to happen - at best he'll spend a year on Richmond's rookie list before being delisted again.

 

[eagles92]

Thats a F@#king Classic...lol haha...couldnt stop laughing

 

[Stronzo]

Thats a F@#king Classic...lol haha...couldnt stop laughing

Glad someone didn't take me seriously

 

[sabre_ac]

Would have more to offer than Murphy that is for sure, however I don't want them both on our list.

 

[Moo]

Would have more to offer than Murphy that is for sure, however I don't want them both on our list.

I'd rather have Murphy on the list than Polly.

 

[Stronzo]

I'd rather have Murphy on the list than Polly.

Ouch.

 

[estibador]

I'd rather have Murphy on the list than Polly.

That's like having to choose whether you'd rather have AIDS or cancer.

 

[Tombopoliner]

In the new era of anti-retrovirals i would take AIDs. Would also depend on the type of cancer though i guess...