Round 1 v Essendon - Votes

[Mad Dog]

POTY -

5
4
3
2
1


BTM

3
2
1


Rookie of the Year

total of 2 points - either 1 player 2 points.....or 2 players 1 point each...




...post em here folks.......and are their any volunteers to tally the votes each week ???

cheers

 

[Eggzoi]

Rookie criteria?

POTY
5: Thompson
4: Reilly
3: Bock
2: Stiffy
1: Mcleod

Rookie: Assuming VB isn't allowed:
2: Griffin- Impressive for his first game, thought he looked too scared to kick a bit and just handballed instead. Want more kicking.
1: Knights.

 

[fightingdreamer88]

POTY

5: Thompson
4: Reilly
3: Johncock
2: Knights
1: van Berlo

Rookies:

2: Knights
1: Griffen

 

[rowdy37]

POTY -

5 – Scott Thompson
4 – Brent Reilly
3 – Chris Knights
2 – Tyson Edwards
1 – Jonathon Griffin


BTM

3 – Scott Thompson
2 – Ben Hudson
1 – Nathan Van Berlo


Rookie of the Year

2 – Jonathon Griffin
1 – Richard Douglas

 

[Mad Dog]

can someone post a list of eligiible rookies ?

 

[macca23]

Too disappointed to make individual comments today other than to say that was a pretty ordinary dysfunctional effort by our boys today.

POTY

5 – Scott Thompson
4 – Brent Reilly
3– Andrew McLeod
2 – Chris Knights
1 – Robert Shirley

BTM

3 – Robert Shirley
2 – Ben Rutten
1 – Nathan Van Berlo


Rookie

2 – Chris Knights
1 – Jonathon Griffin

 

[sapaul]

can someone post a list of eligiible rookies ?

Douglas, Griffen, Knights and VanBerlo(although 30 games might make him not?) today I think.


5- Thompson
4- Reilly
3- VanBerlo
2- Knights
1- Bock

3- Thompson
2- Rutten
1- Shirley

1- VanBerlo
1- Knights

If VB not eligible, make it 1 also to Griffen.

 

[Damp Squarie]

POTY:

5. Thompson - tried all day
4. Van Berlo - great early then went missing
3. Shirley - good game for his hundereth
2. Bock - apart from his kicking
1. Douglas - at the contest


BTM:

3.Thompson
2. Reilly
1. Shirley

ROTY:

3. Griffin -good debut game, wasnt over awed
1. Douglas - developing nicely and played better than a couple of "name" midfielders

 

[-CG-]

POTY:

5. Reilly
4. Thompson
3. Shirley - 100% effectiveness
2. Bock
1. van Berlo


BTM:

3. Reilly
2. Shirley
1. Rutten

ROTY:

3. Griffin - Also 100% effectiveness
1. Knights

 

[Alex99]

Adelaide Vs Essendon - Round 1

POTY -

5) Scott Thompson
4) Brent Reilly
3) Tyson Edwards
2) Chris Knights
1) Jonathon Griffin


BTM

3) Scott Thompson
2) Ben Hudson
1) Nathan Van Berlo


Rookie of the Year

2) Chris Knights
1) Jonathon Griffin

 

[AJ_No.4]

POTY:

5. Thompson
4. Reilly
3. Shirley
2. Van Berlo
1. Johncock


BTM:

3.Thompson
2. Reilly
1. Rutten

ROTY:

2. Knights
1. Griffen

 

[Markthirtytwo]

POTY:

5. Thompson
4. Reilly
3. Bock
2. Van Berlo
1. Johncock


BTM:

3.Thompson
2. Reilly
1. Bock

ROTY:

2. Griffen
1. Knights

 

[betterthanu]

POTY -

5 Thompson
4 Bock
3 Reilly
2 Johncock
1 McLeod


BTM

3 Thompson
2 Bock
1 Van Berlo


Rookie of the Year
Knights
Griffen

 

[Jarmayhem]

POTY -

5 Thompson
4 Bock
3 Reilly
2 McLeod
1 Johncock


BTM

3 Thompson
2 Bock
1 Van Berlo


Rookie of the Year

Griffen
Knights

 

[Mad Dog]

POTY -

5 - Thompson - it will give him some confidence to know he can play a game and be our stand out midfielder
4 - Reilly
3 - Johncock - only winner in defense
2 - Bock
1 - McLeod

BTM

3 - Thompson
2 - Bassett - tried all day
1 - McLeod

Rookie

1 point for Griffin

 

[Damp Squarie]

Thought it might be worthwhile publishing the votes perceived by the media as a comparison for what we think collectively ( POTY)

Adelaide: McLeod, Thompson, Johncock, Knights, Reilly, Van Berlo.

Im assuming they are in order of merit.

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/matchreport/Bombers-ready-for-takeoff/2007/04/01/1175366079649.html

 

[Cap]

My Votes

1) the red coat who helped my find my seat
2) The essendon supporter sitting next to me who put up with my frustration
3) The Lady in front of me who copped a knee or two during the game
4) John Meeson - was very polite in the Crows Tavern to all the old people
3) The guy who let me in the line while leaving

 

[tribey]

POTY

5: THOMPSON, Scott - Stood up in the absence of Goodwin. Plenty of contested possessions, clearances and a couple of goals.

4: JOHNCOCK, Graham - Nine contested possessions in a swamped defence, simply oozed class under maximum pressure.

3: SHIRLEY, Robert - The 100-gamer had 16 disposals - including 4 inside-50s - at 100% efficiency. The ultimate cool head in a crisis, never stopped working.

2: BOCK, Nathan - Probably deserves to be higher up but too often swung between the sublime and the ridiculous. If he can clean up his disposal and decision-making he will be an extremely effective key forward in 2007.

1: REILLY, Brent - After Thompson, looked most likely to spark a revival.

BTM

3: JOHNCOCK - As above.
2: SHIRLEY - As above.
1: RUTTEN, Ben - Did a good job on Lloyd under the circumstances.

Rookie

2: KNIGHTS, Chris - Solid outing, needs to build on it.

 

[Stiffy_18]

POTY
5. Scott Thompson
4. Brent Reilly
3. Graham Johncock
2. Nathan Bock
1. Robert Shirley

BTM
3. Graham Johncock
2. Robert Shirley
1. Ben Rutten

ROOKIES
1. Chris Knights
1. Jonathon Griffin

 

[WaynesWorld19]

FWIW ....Macleod didn't get the accolades from last weeks game he deserved and you could have blown me over with a feather on Shirleys nomination (not criticising him just that it wasn't a top 5 performace of our team)

 

[tribey]

... and you could have blown me over with a feather on Shirleys nomination (not criticising him just that it wasn't a top 5 performace of our team)

YA RLY

 

[WaynesWorld19]

YA RLY

sorry you'll have to elaborate

 

[tribey]

sorry you'll have to elaborate

Just what you said, didn't surprise me in the slightest, that's all.

 

[Damp Squarie]

I thought macca played off his opponent early and got shown out -Was it Monfries?

He also ran past a contest where I remember cursing the fact that he didnt go at the ball.

He did try to spark us into action late but the horse had bolted by then and he didnt have enough mates helping him.

Suffice to say he will burn this week despite his " bruised arm"

 

[Damp Squarie]

Round One TallY

POTY

Thompson 74
Reilly 53
Bock 25
Johncock 20
Shirley 14
Van Berlo 13
Knights 11
McLeod 8
Edwards 5
Griffin 2
Douglas 1

BTM

Thompson 27
Shirley 11
Reilly 9
Rutten 8
Johncock 6
Bock 5
Van Berlo 5
Hudson 4
Bassett 2
McLeod 1

ROTY

Griffin 20
Knights 17
Douglas 2
Van Berlo 1

If Ive miscounted please correct me but I think they are right