Round 13 Trades

[DT_35]

LOL firstly, Clark won't play because he has the bye this week.

Secondly, McIntosh, Lever, McKenzie, Glenn & Taylah Walker won't play from the non Rd13 bye players this week. That's 17 starters, champ.

Hardwick loves McIntosh, Lever listed as 'probable' and doubt Walker will miss as they need to win

 

[NinjaSwan]

??? Its actually 22. 7 in the backline if Lever plays, 8 in the midfield (not including Josh "Spud" Glenn), 1 in the ruck and 6 up forward if Clark plays. I think you need to check your maths

Judging by the Crows board I'd say Lever will miss again this week, and even if he does you can't have 7 on the field in the backline, McKenzie won't play and Clark has the bye so it's 19 before trades with a maximum of 21 afterwards. Tex might miss as well.

 

[Krujan]

Hardwick loves McIntosh, Lever listed as 'probable' and doubt Walker will miss as they need to win

McInspud had 4 disposals from a full game. No way he survives that this week, especially after a loss & half a dozen others having played really well in the ressies on the weekend..

Lever is at least 1 more week away. Plane trip to Brissy all but kills off any chance of him playing this week. Cabin pressure, sore ankle. not good. Plus, Hendo killed it in the ressies, so he will play that role this week.

Walker is struggling big time, even if he plays he won't be much if any help to his team. My prediction is he definitely doesn't play this week. If they can't win without him this week, then they never will.

 

[rocker_oz33]

What about Harvey and if you're going for a key forward, why not JJK?

I need to work my trades out.
Ive looking at Boomer for a while but taz and kmac didnt make enough/lost to much.
To make it happen with my first trade option.
I might have to do double downgrade insteed.
cheers for the feedback.

 

[Mullarkey]

I was thinking about it last night. I went to the game and he just gets zero help from his fellow mids. Reckon jimmy back will help him.

I hoping I'm right anyway.

He bloody well better, Jimmy already owes me for starting with him and getting injured

 

[the push up king]

lever - sloane via newnes
tarrant - lambert
griff - montagna

have to admit, loving the new look of my team

 

[rocker_oz33]

I'm unsure when Lever will return.
Hendo will come back and Hartigan did pretty well v the dorks.

 

[NinjaSwan]

Whoops, my bad on Clark. McIntosh will, why wouldn't he? Lever should, McKenzie should, he's important to our team and will be right to play, never said Glenn will, and Walker will, why the **** would he not play, it was only a corkie.

What? Reading on the Saints board and not one poster had him in their best 22 and no one is suggesting him to come in? I highly doubt he plays, with the likes of Gilbert and Fisher(?) coming back in I can't see him getting a spot.

 

[DraftGuru_]

What? Reading on the Saints board and not one poster had him in their best 22 and no one is suggesting him to come in? I highly doubt he plays, with the likes of Gilbert and Fisher(?) coming back in I can't see him getting a spot.

He is in our best 22. What thread are you reading? Gilbert and Fisher are key defenders, McKenzie is a wingman/half back flanker, they won't affect him coming into the side

 

[DraftGuru_]

LOL you have no idea. Enjoy your holiday, champ.

Okay. I have no idea. The fact that you don't bother arguing back proves you're clueless

 

[NinjaSwan]

He is in our best 22. What thread are you reading? Gilbert and Fisher are key defenders, McKenzie is a wingman/half back flanker, they won't affect him coming into the side

This one http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/what-does-our-best-22-look-like-now.1100590/ not in the team now and Shenton came in as an emergency ahead of him against Melbourne. (though I rate him higher than shenton)

 

[Hypnotiq]

So with Bellchambers and Colyer out for the season, Kavanagh and Giles look like possible good options?

 

[DraftGuru_]

This one http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/what-does-our-best-22-look-like-now.1100590/ not in the team now and Shenton came in as an emergency ahead of him against Melbourne. (though I rate him higher than shenton)

Shenton is a hack and should not be in our side. The fact is, Richo has already shown he'll play the kids, and McKenzie was previously in our side before he got a concussion. He'll play more games

 

[Krujan]

Shenton is a hack and should not be in our side. The fact is, Richo has already shown he'll play the kids, and McKenzie was previously in our side before he got a concussion. He'll play more games

I look forward to bumping this post on Thursday evening.

 

[DraftGuru_]

I look forward to bumping this post on Thursday evening.

Why would you? I said I'll have a maximum of 22 (revised to 21) playing but that's if everyone gets up to play. I'd say its more likely that I'll have 20, but not sure at this stage which one will miss. Go ahead and bump it on Thursday evening, it won't mean a thing because you can't deny that I could have a maximum of 21 players playing

 

[NinjaSwan]

Shenton is a hack and should not be in our side. The fact is, Richo has already shown he'll play the kids, and McKenzie was previously in our side before he got a concussion. He'll play more games

Yes but Shenton isn't best 22 either, and will likely be replaced by Roberton who is ahead of both of them. Plus with Fisher and Billings also coming back I can't see McKenzie getting a game. I'd like McKenzie to get a game as he's in my SC team but I can't see it happening unfortunately.

 

[DraftGuru_]

Yes but Shenton isn't best 22 either, and will likely be replaced by Roberton who is ahead of both of them. Plus with Fisher and Billings also coming back I can't see McKenzie getting a game. I'd like McKenzie to get a game as he's in my SC team but I can't see it happening unfortunately.

If McKenzie is good enough, he'll force his way into the side, he'll make them drop a player.

 

[Krujan]

So with Bellchambers and Colyer out for the season, Kavanagh and Giles look like possible good options?

Why would you even consider Giles at 394k? He's been struggling in the VFL all year, Bombers would rather play with no ruck. Besides even at his best he was only a 70-75ppg ruck. With the new ruck rules, he'd be luck to average 50.

If you're looking for value in a cheap ruck, Kreuzer is your man. Averaged 110+ from 16 games in-between the games he missed/subbed out with injury in 2013. Fully recovered from his last injury now. Been back for 2 weeks, could average 90-95+ from here. At 370k he's very good value.

 

[Hypnotiq]

Why would you even consider Giles at 394k? He's been struggling in the VFL all year, Bombers would rather play with no ruck. Besides even at his best he was only a 70-75ppg ruck. With the new ruck rules, he'd be luck to average 50.

If you're looking for value in a cheap ruck, Kreuzer is your man. Averaged 110+ from 16 games in-between the games he missed/subbed out with injury in 2013. Fully recovered from his last injury now. Been back for 2 weeks, could average 90-95+ from here. At 370k he's very good value.

It was more of a suggestive post, i wont be touching giles personally but regardless its a valid point you make.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Was having a chat with Seb Ross today, he and and a few of the saint boys usually come in every day at my local cafe, we usually have a good chat about footy and SuperCoach, I asked him about Mckenzie and he recons hes still struggling a bit and even he traded him out.

Good enough for me anyway.

 

[DraftGuru_]

Was having a chat with Seb Ross today, he and and a few of the saint boys usually come in every day at my local cafe, we usually have a good chat about footy and SuperCoach, I asked him about Mckenzie and he recons hes still struggling a bit and even he traded him out.

Good enough for me anyway.

Why would you trade him when his BE is 12? Plenty of cash to make still

 

[NinjaSwan]

Why would you trade him when his BE is 12? Plenty of cash to make still

Hard to make cash when you're not playing games.

 

[big bootaaaaah]

Whoops, my bad on Clark. McIntosh will, why wouldn't he? Lever should, McKenzie should, he's important to our team and will be right to play, never said Glenn will, and Walker will, why the **** would he not play, it was only a corkie.

Everything you said seemed a reasonable debate except the dickhead bit. Why would you insult a bloke who took the time to analize your team and offer their opinion even if you don't agree? Seemed a tad uncalled for.

 

[DraftGuru_]

Hard to make cash when you're not playing games.

He won't miss a chunk of games. If he does miss this week, he will probably play in the VFL and be back the following week. Can't see how he wouldn't be right this week though. He was knocked in round 9, meaning it was three weeks ago and it didn't seem like a severe knock

 

[NinjaSwan]

He won't miss a chunk of games. If he does miss this week, he will probably play in the VFL and be back the following week. Can't see how he wouldn't be right this week though. He was knocked in round 9, meaning it was three weeks ago and it didn't seem like a severe knock

The reason he isn't playing is not because he was concussed it's because he's not in the best 22. I'm sure he'll get a game later in the year but for now I can't see him getting a game. He didn't play vs. Melbourne and then Roberton, Fisher, Billings and whoever is promoted out of Sinclar/Schneider would all be ahead of him.