Round 14 Trades

[Jiska]

Thinking Touk -> Steele and Krak -> Gawn.
Second guessing my week long plan last Sat is going to cost me 70k but it continues my season of pain.

Saad to Rance (400k) as a straight sideways trade costing $0 really starting to appeal.

 

[buttox]

rocky back this week?
if so,
cey ---> rocky
nothing else.
attempting to save 4 trades for sc finals.

 

[stevebbb]

Hamling/Lever to Edwards if he does well again

otherwise none

 

[Jiska]

rocky back this week?
if so,
cey ---> rocky
nothing else.
attempting to save 4 trades for sc finals.

You've got a big set of balls mate.
I'd be waiting 2-3 weeks on Rocky given his history this year.

 

[NinjaSwan]

Dumont/Dale > Steele, McKenzie > B Smith

 

[buttox]

You've got a big set of balls mate.
I'd be waiting 2-3 weeks on Rocky given his history this year.

last mid needed. ceys 365 odd + 130k cash
leaves me bugger all breathing room for waiting.
only 8 trades left any rooky - premo trades i can do in one trade need to be done while i can imo.

 

[Krujan]

Thinking Touk -> Steele and Krak -> Gawn.
Second guessing my week long plan last Sat is going to cost me 70k but it continues my season of pain.

Saad to Rance (400k) as a straight sideways trade costing $0 really starting to appeal.

I thought you were really short on trades?

 

[Krujan]

Hopefully no Rd14 trades for me. Will sit on 100k and remaining 6 trades until GAJ is cheap enough to upgrade whoever is spudding up at the time. Othewise, only injury trades from here on.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Hopefully no Rd14 trades for me. Will sit on 100k and remaining 6 trades until GAJ is cheap enough to upgrade whoever is spudding up at the time. Othewise, only injury trades from here on.

Hurn or Oxley > Gawn/ShielD
Webb > H Goddard
Makes my team all wibbly wobbly, 5 trades left for the rest of the season or could just do the 1 trade of
Hurn/Ox > Gawn and have 100k for GAJ.
Anyone think Buddy will be gone for 2 weeks?.

 

[Krujan]

Hurn or Oxley > Gawn/ShielD
Webb > H Goddard
Makes my team all wibbly wobbly, 5 trades left for the rest of the season or could just do the 1 trade of
Hurn/Ox > Gawn and have 100k for GAJ.
Anyone think Buddy will be gone for 2 weeks?.

I think Buddy will cop 3 weeks, minimum.

Those 2 trades seem kind off pointless to me, especially when you have so few to play with.

 

[Hairy Lager]

I think Buddy will cop 3 weeks, minimum.

Those 2 trades seem kind off pointless to me, especially when you have so few to play with.

 

[Krujan]

View attachment 147308

2 with a guilty plea. That's why we have bench cover, though.

 

[leng jai]

No trades.

Buddy 2 down to 1 hopefully. He plays for Sydney though so I'm still holding on to the chance he'll get 0

 

[Hairy Lager]

2 with a guilty plea. That's why we have bench cover, though.

Steele, Lambert or Webb, no so appealing .

 

[stevebbb]

I think Buddy will cop 3 weeks, minimum.

would be nice if he only got 1, week off then come back vs the Lions and kick 8

one can dream

 

[saint_nick]

Thinking about two different approaches. Would like to see what the community out the thinks.

Current defence: shaw picken simpson newnes oxley smith (brown hamling)

Oxley to hodge - leaving brown as cover

Or

brown to rance
Leaving: oxley/rance/smith as cover

 

[Jiska]

I thought you were really short on trades?

Yeah I am. You're right, I should probably ignore Rance for now and save the trade. Saad is doing a good enough job. Only non-Premo left.

I should probably not trade, but Gawn as a F6-7/R3 backup is hard to ignore and J Martin is proving unreliable and I should probably move him to Gawn instead of Krak and bank the 80k savings. I just can't bring myself to dump him though. I feel that Gawn + J Martin is better than Gawn + Krak.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Yeah I am. You're right, I should probably ignore Rance for now and save the trade. Saad is doing a good enough job. Only non-Premo left.

I should probably not trade, but Gawn as a F6-7/R3 backup is hard to ignore and J Martin is proving unreliable and I should probably move him to Gawn instead of Krak and bank the 80k savings. I just can't bring myself to dump him though. I feel that Gawn + J Martin is better than Gawn + Krak.

As a Melbourne supporter do you see Gawn as fools gold as one poster put it this week?

 

[Krujan]

Steele, Lambert or Webb, no so appealing .

Steele goes alright.

 

[Keg on legs]

Thinking Touk -> Steele and Krak -> Gawn.
Second guessing my week long plan last Sat is going to cost me 70k but it continues my season of pain.

Saad to Rance (400k) as a straight sideways trade costing $0 really starting to appeal.

Do you think Gawn can keep it up jiska? I'm thinking dumont- ANB and lonie to Gawn as F6, but im worried he will fall in a screaming heap

 

[Jiska]

As a Melbourne supporter do you see Gawn as fools gold as one poster put it this week?

Do you think Gawn can keep it up jiska? I'm thinking dumont- ANB and lonie to Gawn as F6, but im worried he will fall in a screaming heap

Have been pretty consistent with my thoughts on Gawn all year.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2015-supercoach-rucks.1081949/page-38#post-37269755
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/round-12-trades.1100783/page-9#post-39107461
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/posts/39204251/

 

[Krujan]

Yeah I am. You're right, I should probably ignore Rance for now and save the trade. Saad is doing a good enough job. Only non-Premo left.

I should probably not trade, but Gawn as a F6-7/R3 backup is hard to ignore and J Martin is proving unreliable and I should probably move him to Gawn instead of Krak and bank the 80k savings. I just can't bring myself to dump him though. I feel that Gawn + J Martin is better than Gawn + Krak.

Saad > Rance isn't much of an upgrade anyway. 5-10 points per game, tops. Definitely not worth doing if you only have 6 or so trades left.

 

[Jiska]

Saad > Rance isn't much of an upgrade anyway. 5-10 points per game, tops. Definitely not worth doing if you only have 6 or so trades left.

Agreed, good call. Thanks for calming me down

I'm just still in regret mode for not starting with Rance and for taking him out of my team two days before the season to get that ****ing spud of a player Goodes.

 

[Krujan]

Agreed, good call. Thanks for calming me down

I'm just still in regret mode for not starting with Rance and for taking him out of my team two days before the season to get that ******* spud of a player Goodes.

No probs, I'm in the low trades club myself after I do an upgrade trade tonight, will only have 6 left.

 

[stevebbb]

will definitely look at Lonie to McKernan
provide ruck cover and with Reid up forward I can loophole my F6/F7