MVP Round 22 Votes vs Collingwood

[eaglespremiers]

Really tough because everyone was dead ordinary.
Here are my votes though none really deserve any:
5. Glass
4. Rosa
3. Cox
2. Mackenzie
1. JK

Thought Shepherd and Lycett were alright at times too.

 

[lmach]

5. Rosa
4. Masten
3. Glass
2. Mackenzie
1. Kennedy, at least he tried

DM: The rest, except maybe Cox and Selwood because they actually looked like they gave a ****.

 

[Agent93]

Players I like the best at the moment:

5. Scott Lycett
4. Darren Glass
3. Josh Kennedy
2. Eric Mackenzie (Are you ****ing serious?)
1. Patrick McGinnity

The midfield can **** right off until they get into a game whilst it's up for grabs. If you go and your 30 possession 2 goal game after it's been killed of, then GAGF.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

5. Rosa
4. Butler
3. Lycett
2. Masten
1. Mackenzie

Head nearly exploded doing this.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

5. Rosa
4. Butler
3. Masten
2. getting tough ... umm, Lycett
1. tougher still ... err, Glass for taking the angry pills before the game.

That was just woeful. Bring on the pre-season.

2. Eric Mackenzie (Are you ******* serious?)

Haha, is that what he said? Thought it must've been something good to earn 50.

 

[Dark Sharks]

5. Rosa
4. Lycett
3. Glass
2. Mackenzie
1. Masten

HM to JK

 

[Alphanumeric]

Masten????? He was pathetic!!!!

Yes he got alot of the ball, but all he did was handball to a teammate that was about to get tackled, or he called for the ball when he had someone on him.

Go back and watch his first 7 touches and everyone results in a turnover.

And no one gave Priddis a vote?? Bloke didn't stop trying all night, easily one of our best.

 

[ChampRevesby]

And no one gave Priddis a vote?? Bloke didn't stop trying all night, easily one of our best.

He's brave, tireless, blue collar, workman like. Get around him.

 

[Sw3Et]

Mackenzie got absolutely toweled up by Cloke. Unless he performed some miracles in the last quarter which I didn't watch.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Go back and watch...

No thanks!

 

[larrikin]

Masten????? He was pathetic!!!!

Yes he got alot of the ball, but all he did was handball to a teammate that was about to get tackled, or he called for the ball when he had someone on him.

Pathetic?

Nah. He was fumbly early on, I pay that. He was our best user by foot in the midfield by a mile as the game went on.
Wasn't a fan of his handballing for much of the game, but he was far from the lone ranger there.

And no one gave Priddis a vote?? Bloke didn't stop trying all night, easily one of our best.

Priddis always tries hard

 

[Masto]

Masten kicked 2 of our 5 goals lol

 

[buddymania]

5. Selwood
4. Rosa
3. Butler
2. Priddis
1. Masten

 

[Carbine Chaos]

5. Matt Rosa
4. Darren Glass
3. Chris Masten
2. Jamie Cripps
1. Scott Lycett

*shrugs*

 

[buddymania]

2. Jamie Cripps

 

[ChampRevesby]

I'm not voting in protest.

 

[placebo]

Mackenzie got absolutely toweled up by Cloke. Unless he performed some miracles in the last quarter which I didn't watch.

Uh, no, MacKenzie got toweled up by our atrocious midfield.

 

[placebo]

Masten????? He was pathetic!!!!

Yes he got alot of the ball, but all he did was handball to a teammate that was about to get tackled, or he called for the ball when he had someone on him.

Go back and watch his first 7 touches and everyone results in a turnover.

And no one gave Priddis a vote?? Bloke didn't stop trying all night, easily one of our best.

The fact that you can say Priddis was one of our best, after what you just criticised Masten for...well, buddy, I'm sorry to tell you you have a terrible understanding of footy and/or are blind. Masten had a poor 1st qtr but was good after that. Priddis had a decent 10 minutes and then was completely shown up by far, far better midfielders. Was supremely average.

 

[fidstar]

5. Rosa
4. Priddis
3. Glass
2. Cox
1. Masten

I love MacKenzie. He has been one of our top 3 players this year and I can't remember him being beaten this year, but he was thrashed tonight. Yes, Cloke had A grade service, but Cloke took a lot of marks when it was 1 on 1 and easily won the duel.

 

[Kaboodleer]

2. Jamie Cripps

*shrugs*

WHY GOD WHY!?

5. Rosa
3. Masten
1. Selwood

No one else gets any.

Mackenzie got absolutely toweled up by Cloke. Unless he performed some miracles in the last quarter which I didn't watch.

Did take a lot of marks but without two of the worst 50m paid this season Cloke only kicks 1 goals which is a Joe the goose handball in the square.

 

[TassieEagle]

Didn't see all the game (only til qtr time) so can't really vote this week. But from what I saw Cripps and Priddis were BOG for the Pies. In the first qtr the only highlight for me was a chase down and JD taking on a couple of guys.

 

[ziad]

Players I like the best at the moment:

5. Scott Lycett
4. Darren Glass
3. Josh Kennedy
2. Eric Mackenzie (Are you ******* serious?)
1. Patrick McGinnity

The midfield can **** right off until they get into a game whilst it's up for grabs. If you go and your 30 possession 2 goal game after it's been killed of, then GAGF.

good list. Scottie had a real crack - felt sorry for him at time with no support.
Priddis was about our best.

 

[Rids]

5 - Rosa
4 - Glass
3 - Priddis
2 - Masten
1 - Scooter
The midfield wasn't as badly beaten as what people think (beaten yes but not humiliated) - the flanks/pockets where they were lively and picked up touches at will up forward (J.Thomas, Sidebottom, B.Kennedy, Didak late) and the drive they got from their defenders (Shaw, Williams, Seedsman) compared to what our blokes in similar positions did (Masten was good across half forward - that's about it) was where we really got hammered in my opinion.

 

[QS]

Good to see Rosa do okay. Maybe drive up his value

 

[placebo]

5. Rosa
4. Masten
3. Hill
2. Scooter
1. Lycett