Round 3 trades

[dlanod]

Kicking this off early because of the Monday game. Have to figure out what, if anything, to do with Broughton and Montagna, whether to bring in decent rookies for Ledger, Hall, Dickson, etc...

At the moment it looks like:
Broughton > ???
Montagna > Milera

I then have a metric shitload of cash to upgrade with, but will I be losing out on points in the next few weeks?

 

[Mattrox]

I'll sacrifice one rounds score a little... not that Broughton's scores were setting the world on fire, and a rookie might score more points anyway! But trading him out to free up cash. Then doing upgrades in the back line next round.

Need to be careful. I want to maximise the cash cows this round. I'll be deliberating all week until teams are listed before final decisions.

 

[warney7]

Big week.

I'm considering Broughton > Dempsey. I huge difference in price, but the fact is, Dempsey is putting the scores on the board.

Ledger was really disappointing for me, as I used him in my starting 22 instead of Shiel and Coniglio, may hold him because he's not vital.

Not sure what I'd do with a spare 200k....

 

[GOAUS!]

Big week.

I'm considering Broughton > Dempsey. I huge difference in price, but the fact is, Dempsey is putting the scores on the board.

Ledger was really disappointing for me, as I used him in my starting 22 instead of Shiel and Coniglio, may hold him because he's not vital.

Not sure what I'd do with a spare 200k....

Maybe just go Broughton -> Birchall instead?

 

[V23]

Looking at something like:

Broughton -> Birchall/Malceski

Hall/Dickson -> Milera (has only played Port and GC so not sure if he can sustain his output)

 

[FAKE_HAIR]

Hi I have both hall and Dickson thinking of trading one out for either millera or Kennedy From GWS what are everyone's thought on Kennedy?

 

[RWnBluey]

Big week.

I'm considering Broughton > Dempsey. I huge difference in price, but the fact is, Dempsey is putting the scores on the board.

Ledger was really disappointing for me, as I used him in my starting 22 instead of Shiel and Coniglio, may hold him because he's not vital.

Not sure what I'd do with a spare 200k....

Ive got Ledger too Warny, was thinkink about offloading him but after seing him last night he looked really good even though it was for just over a quarter. I think its just a matter of time before he starts matches

 

[demon_fanatic]

hey guys is there a site that has value projections after next week..... eg if milera scores 60 what will his value rise to etc.... hypotheticals like that

 

[BLUES9898]

Thinking of doing

Hall -> Milera
Ledger -> Crouch

 

[Clunk]

hey guys is there a site that has value projections after next week..... eg if milera scores 60 what will his value rise to etc.... hypotheticals like that

Tooserious.net

Go to stats

 

[BigKev2]

To keep Shaw or not to keep Shaw....that is the question?

I know in SC he scores better than in DT, but have to keep both comps in mind. Have not traded just yet, and had in mind that my first trade will be in rnd5. Now I come across Shaw who is letting me and many others.... down.

Thinking of trading Shaw out and bring in Birchall and downgrade L.Parker to T Greene. Not worried about my second trade atm...but it's Shaw that's playing with my mind. Do I...or do i not?

I originally posted this in round 2 trades..this morning. Sorry for repeating the same question.

 

[Mattrox]

Might just do Golby out Bower in and trade Greene in and wait and pray re Broughton and Shaw.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Maybe just go Broughton -> Birchall instead?

Am thinking Broughton to Dempsey myself and hanging onto the cash. If Dempsey is doing the same job as Birchall (and the job Broughton should be doing) and getting around 100pts a week for about 200k less he is worth a look, I think the bombers have Gold Coast next week too.

My back line is a problem at the moment and am also thinking of swapping Boumann for Lake but might hold off on that one. Alternativley I have enough to bring in Brad Ebert for a midfield rookie as i have been burnt from the sub jacket this round.

Had Dempsey in my team prior to round one and kicking myself for dumping him. Will watch Birchall today though

 

[dread and might]

Seriously considering the annoyingly sideways trade of Swan to JKennedy which will give me 140K. Had kennedy in and out prior to rd 1 and got rid of him because I thought my red and white blinkers were blinding me

 

[warney7]

Am thinking Broughton to Dempsey myself and hanging onto the cash. If Dempsey is doing the same job as Birchall (and the job Broughton should be doing) and getting around 100pts a week for about 200k less he is worth a look, I think the bombers have Gold Coast next week too.


Had Dempsey in my team prior to round one and kicking myself for dumping him. Will watch Birchall today though

The extra cash could be so valuable in a couple of weeks. However, if Dempsey gets injured, there won't be much you can do with him if you've already spent the proceeds.

Might check out what his projected rise could be. Will also be interested in what Birchall can muster against the Cats today.

 

[SirJimi05]

Thinking of doing

Ledger -> Crouch

This trade makes no sense at all to me.

Ledger was sub and looked good when he came on.
He looks like he will score well once he avoids the vest.
If Crouch comes in how do you know he wont spud it up?
Why not sit back for 2 weeks on that trade to see how both players go?
If Crouch rips it up and Ledge fails you can get Crouch in before his price rise, whilst also making a few dollars on Ledger.

 

[warney7]

Who the hell is crouch?

 

[GOAUS!]

Who the hell is crouch?

I'm guessing it's Couch not Crouch.

 

[shaun1800]

Dickson to Milera definitely.

The other big question for me is my backline. Have Lake, Ellis, Morris, Mohr and Bugg as my non premos and I feel like a Clarke, Guthrie or Bower type could strengthen it. The problem is which rookie would I trade and who would I bring in...

 

[Judd_Magic]

Out - Half my team. LOL!


Seriously though - Golby, Broughton and Coniglio are all doing squat.

I'll most likely go Golby > Dempsey and in a couple of weeks Coniglio > Mcdonald as he's a better scorer.

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

I have Dangerfield and Martin mid/fwd in the midfield and Chapman and Goodes mid/fwd in the forward line and around $280,000 left in the bank.

The only change I'm thinking about making is Martin out for Josh Kennedy in. It will give me more cash too.

I really need to work on my backline but think I will hold off for another 2 or 3 weeks. I want Bock in my side so hopefully give him 2 weeks and then by them some of the other players may have risen nicely to let me buy him in. Birchall is another I would like.

If I was going to bring anyone into my backline this week it might be Paul Bower. I had him in all preseason but when I tweeked the side a week before the season I couldn't afford him, I wanted to keep the cash for when Bock was available again.

I've averaged around 2300 points the first 2 weeks, if I could get that backline sorted I reckon I could be getting closer to the 2400 to 2500 mark.

 

[Adz]

I have Cameron and Hampton. Should I trade one?

 

[mrbewbs]

Probably Pffeifer to Milera. Then leave my team, not overly happy with Broughton or Martin but I selected them to be keepers so I will hang onto them for a while atleast.

 

[gh172]

I'm thinking of dropping Martin for Whitecross.

 

[ozzyoslo]

I'll sacrifice one rounds score a little... not that Broughton's scores were setting the world on fire, and a rookie might score more points anyway! But trading him out to free up cash. Then doing upgrades in the back line next round.

Need to be careful. I want to maximise the cash cows this round. I'll be deliberating all week until teams are listed before final decisions.

Dont have to do that now mattrox
you have to unlimited moves this week