Captains Round 4 VC/Captain

[WaynesWorld19]

Thinking of going Sloane VC.

It looks like it'll be Wet & Wild tonight .....that's Sloane's perfect scenario to score big .....but i'm not game to take that gamble

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Fyfe is in beast mode at the moment , VC for me

That's a yes from me too

 

[Kadog]

Buddy vc
Danger/Tich c

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Safe option with Titch C or risky with Buddy C?

got no loophole

 

[pulpdriver]

Safe option with Titch C or risky with Buddy C?

got no loophole

Without a loophole I think you've gotta go Titch. Only live once though

 

[Huttabito]

Thanks Barry. Loophole opened.

Dusty/Buddy into Titch. I'll drink on it tonight.

 

[toxic]

It looks like it'll be Wet & Wild tonight .....that's Sloane's perfect scenario to score big .....but i'm not game to take that gamble

Pendles to Gibbs locked
Crocker to Laird probably

Sloane = 120+

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Without a loophole I think you've gotta go Titch. Only live once though

Gone Buddy

Buddys best is 40+ more than Titch

Titch 140 + Buddy 170 (320) = 460
Titch 280 + Buddy 170 = 350.

Possible 110 point difference


Now watch Buddy kick 1 and score 40

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Pendles to Gibbs locked
Crocker to Laird probably

Sloane = 120+

Surely Pendles to Sloane at the coal-face would be the go ??

 

[pulpdriver]

Gone Buddy

Buddys best is 40+ more than Titch

Titch 140 + Buddy 170 (320) = 460
Titch 280 + Buddy 170 = 350.

Possible 110 point difference


Now watch Buddy kick 1 and score 40

Hey, I'm rooting for ya. Got the VC on Buddy so if he goes large we're both happy.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Gone Buddy

Buddys best is 40+ more than Titch

Titch 140 + Buddy 170 (320) = 460
Titch 280 + Buddy 170 = 350.

Possible 110 point difference


Now watch Buddy kick 1 and score 40

 

[samFFC]

Gone Buddy

Buddys best is 40+ more than Titch

Titch 140 + Buddy 170 (320) = 460
Titch 280 + Buddy 170 = 350.

Possible 110 point difference


Now watch Buddy kick 1 and score 40

 

[pulpdriver]

170 doubled is also 340 but we knew what he was getting at.

 

[pincrusher]

Gone Buddy

Buddys best is 40+ more than Titch

Titch 140 + Buddy 170 (320) = 460
Titch 280 + Buddy 170 = 350.

Possible 110 point difference


Now watch Buddy kick 1 and score 40

Oh dear. Someone didn't do maths at school did they??? Buddy 170 x 2 = 340. 280 + 170 = 450.

 

[toxic]

Surely Pendles to Sloane at the coal-face would be the go ??

Nope.
Gibbs killed us at the blues

We cant afford to let him run free

 

[samFFC]

170 doubled is also 340 but we knew what he was getting at.

It's a 30 point difference at most if Buddy scores 170 and Titch scores 140

Titch captain = 280 + 170 = 450
Buddy captain = 340 + 140 = 480

No where near 110 point difference.
Common fallacy that heaps of people make in AF/SC captaincy scoring - your choice of captain affects you only by the number of points between the players in their scoring, NOT the doubled amount. If Buddy outscores by 30 then you miss out on 30, not 60.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Wet track adel tonight

Not sure now on laird vc

Just came to post this.
Not a lot of rain but wet night games and all that

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

It's a 30 point difference at most if Buddy scores 170 and Titch scores 140

Titch captain = 280 + 170 = 450
Buddy captain = 340 + 140 = 480

No where near 110 point difference.
Common fallacy that heaps of people make in AF/SC captaincy scoring - your choice of captain affects you only by the number of points between the players in their scoring, NOT the doubled amount. If Buddy outscores by 30 then you miss out on 30, not 60.

Not if your captain is Hurn

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Oh dear. Someone didn't do maths at school did they??? Buddy 170 x 2 = 340. 280 + 170 = 450.

thx....

im sick

 

[samFFC]

thx....

im sick

Buddy is still a good choice but I don’t have the guts.

 

[Squiba]

Dusty into titch

 

[samFFC]

Same.

Not going to get cute.
Happy if Dusty/Buddy/Crippa all crack 150+ and I'm left taking Laird 125 x 2 as VC. Still going to grab the points.

Dangerfield/Olango C

 

[keithrichards]

Looking to do Dusty into Titch.

But as I’m currently set up, if I want to take Dusty’s score, I’ll need to bring Barry on, so therefore also take Banfield(e) over Holman. Is that too big a risk?

 

[Gavin Excell]

129 Laird good enough for me

 

[samFFC]

129 Laird good enough for me

Ditto.

Looking to do Dusty into Titch.

But as I’m currently set up, if I want to take Dusty’s score, I’ll need to bring Barry on, so therefore also take Banfield(e) over Holman. Is that too big a risk?

Could you potentially have Barry on field and Holman (E). If Dusty is good you put the C on Barry, if not then you put the C on Titch and Holman scores in place of Barry? This just risks a donut if you have a late out.

Holman v Banfield should only be around 15-20 points max I would have thought.