MVP Round 5 Votes vs Fremantle

[GordonBlue]

5. Henderson
4. Scotland
3. Simpson
2. Gibbs
1. Robinson

BYP: Curnow

 

[Stamos]

Coaches' Votes
Fremantle vs Carlton

10 Simpson (Carl)
4 Scotland (Carl)
4 Walker (Carl)
3 Gibbs (Carl)
3 Murphy (Carl)
2 Duffield (Frem)
2 Hill (Frem)
1 Joseph (Carl)
1 Robinson (Carl)


No votes for Henderson? Only one coach giving Scotland and Gibbs votes?
And personally, I'm very surprised about Simpson getting 10, given his first half.

 

[Silvagnis]

Crowley was robbed.

The AFLCA needs to list who each coach voted for.

Such a wank to keep it in house to cover up bias.

Or Mister Carlton doing Ratten's votes.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

My Guess would be

Ratten:
5- Simpson
4- Walker
3- Gibbs
2- Hill
1- Joseph

Lyon:
5- Simpson
4- Scotland
3- Murphy
2- Duffield
1- Robinson

 

[Vamos Juddamente]

My Guess would be

Ratten:
5- Simpson
4- Walker
3- Gibbs
2- Hill
1- Joseph

Lyon:
5- Simpson
4- Scotland
3- Murphy
2- Duffield
1- Robinson

I love Simpson but that first half was one of his worst for the club he made 5 massive changers all of which led to a shot on goal. Then Hendo wins one on one contests all night against Pav and gets no votes.

 

[rolemodel133]

pav got alot of junk ball maybe the coachs looked at the stats an thought hendo got done.. just a guess

 

[Stamos]

Given Ratts' Plays of the Week, I'd hazard a guess that Ratten gave Mitch the 1.

 

[blue gunslinger]

Coaches' Votes
Fremantle vs Carlton

10 Simpson (Carl)
4 Scotland (Carl)
4 Walker (Carl)
3 Gibbs (Carl)
3 Murphy (Carl)
2 Duffield (Frem)
2 Hill (Frem)
1 Joseph (Carl)
1 Robinson (Carl)


No votes for Henderson? Only one coach giving Scotland and Gibbs votes?
And personally, I'm very surprised about Simpson getting 10, given his first half.

how can that be? hendo bog easy

 

[Just Kreuzing]

Given Ratts' Plays of the Week, I'd hazard a guess that Ratten gave Mitch the 1.

Probably correct but I just couldn't see why Lyon would of gave Joseph a vote, then again Joseph probably fits into Lyon's style of play!