Discussion Round 7: St Kilda V Carlton

[CHBench]

In the side, McEvoy was awesome with Hickey in the side sharing a lot of the ruck duties.

Allowed us to swing McEvoy into the defensive 50 for the final 5 minutes which was huge for us.

 

[CrashTestDummy]

Oh yeah, sorry. That wasn't put there tonight believe me

But really, well done. I'm happy to give kudos where they are due.

**** off campaigner

 

[joop]

The more I think about it, the more I'm amazed at Jamo's efforts. Reiwoldt was good early, but really didn't have much impact on the game... not in any real way... Jamo was sensational... shame he won't play again for a month.

was on the carlton board and saw this. sorry in advance if im not meant to post it but found it pretty hilarious. i also thought jamieson was good in the way he kept going, but to say rooey had no impact on the game really made me laugh.

 

[Tragic sainter]

was on the carlton board and saw this. sorry in advance if im not meant to post it but found it pretty hilarious. i also thought jamieson was good in the way he kept going, but to say rooey had no impact on the game really made me laugh.

Classic scum delusion.

 

[ODNBlue]

was on the carlton board and saw this. sorry in advance if im not meant to post it but found it pretty hilarious. i also thought jamieson was good in the way he kept going, but to say rooey had no impact on the game really made me laugh.

Truth hurts I guess... Playing on a player with only one functioning arm... sure... Roo was awesome.

 

[joop]

Truth hurts I guess... Playing on a player with only one functioning arm... sure... Roo was awesome.

truth hurts. 16 out of 18. seeya!!

 

[saintsrfreak]

Truth hurts I guess... Playing on a player with only one functioning arm... sure... Roo was awesome.

25 touches, 13 marks and 3 goals not good enough for you?

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Truth hurts I guess... Playing on a player with only one functioning arm... sure... Roo was awesome.

Since when was Henderson injured? He played one Roo for 3 quarters and Roo shit on him. Bit mad Carlton don't have a good tall forward bud? Instead rely on that spud Hampson.

 

[ODNBlue]

25 touches, 13 marks and 3 goals not good enough for you?

To be honest, considering how much I respect him as a player, and considering his form coming in, and considering he was playing on a one-armed man... nope, thought he could have had more impact. But I suspect we'll have to agree to disagree.

 

[joop]

To be honest, considering how much I respect him as a player, and considering his form coming in, and considering he was playing on a one-armed man... nope, thought he could have had more impact. But I suspect we'll have to agree to disagree.

read all the newspapers tomorrow and watch the brownlow count mate, you'll be on your own in your thinking, hence why we've had a number of different supports come on the board and praise riewoldt. i look forward to Waite having these stats but you discounting them

 

[Baldur]

25 touches, 13 marks and 3 goals not good enough for you?

And a number of goal assists. But yea was poor very poor.

 

[Thurlow2Mackie]

Glad to finally see Jimmy Webster debut. Was pretty solid too. Hopefully he can get a full game next week.

 

[DontArgue4]

Well done guys, mum goes for the SAINTERS so got a big soft spot, love big boy mcevoy, and riewoldt is an absolute champion of the game. Always fun seeing the blues get beaten, especially by a team I like. Gotta say though, the majority of the blues supporters who have come on this thread have been pretty good sports, apart from the obvious moo's of course

 

[sauce_head]

To be honest, considering how much I respect him as a player, and considering his form coming in, and considering he was playing on a one-armed man... nope, thought he could have had more impact. But I suspect we'll have to agree to disagree.

Ahh the Blues supporters. Think they deserve to win because they used to be a rich club but are no longer relevant. They all stand around expecting to win. FFS your best player tonight was a Melbourne reject.

Even Mick Makthouse cannot firm up a soft soft pile of crap like you guys. It's true what they say, you cannot polih a turd and you cannot harden up Carlton to win hard ball. You may not like it, you might not even agree with it, but deep down you know it. You are a fast team of receivers who like to fly pasts packs. The while comp knows to play tight and hard vs Carlton and you will likely win. Even Mick cannot get accountable defensive football out of you.

You are soft like putty. Work it hard and it moulds to the will of your hands.


Soft soft soft. An old club with no more relevance. The original cheats - salary cap, third party deals, tanking.

You told the league you were coming many season ago. Whilst your soft soft soft players all stood around believing it, the rest of the league went past you. At least ou have your excuses in place early tonight. And Mich gets his fat salary. All is normal at The Bloated Blues. Old. Soft. Bloated Blues. So bloated - they never get let down.

Irrelevant Carltank. A win etched in stone before the season even starts - even if we blood youngsters like never before.

 

[CrashTestDummy]

Truth hurts I guess... Playing on a player with only one functioning arm... sure... Roo was awesome.

Your mob could only wish.

 

[CrashTestDummy]

Carlton will struggle to make the 8

 

[CrashTestDummy]

Ahh the Blues supporters. Think they deserve to win because they used to be a rich club but are no longer relevant. They all stand around expecting to win. FFS your best player tonight was a Melbourne reject.

Even Mick Makthouse cannot firm up a soft soft pile of crap like you guys. It's true what they say, you cannot polih a turd and you cannot harden up Carlton to win hard ball. You may not like it, you might not even agree with it, but deep down you know it. You are a fast team of receivers who like to fly pasts packs. The while comp knows to play tight and hard vs Carlton and you will likely win. Even Mick cannot get accountable defensive football out of you.

You are soft like putty. Work it hard and it moulds to the will of your hands.


Soft soft soft. An old club with no more relevance. The original cheats - salary cap, third party deals, tanking.

You told the league you were coming many season ago. Whilst your soft soft soft players all stood around believing it, the rest of the league went past you. At least ou have your excuses in place early tonight. And Mich gets his fat salary. All is normal at The Bloated Blues. Old. Soft. Bloated Blues. So bloated - they never get let down.

Irrelevant Carltank. A win etched in stone before the season even starts - even if we blood youngsters like never before.

You are a fast team of receivers who like to fly pasts packs. The while comp knows to play tight and hard vs Carlton and you will likely win. Even Mick cannot get accountable defensive football out of you.

this

 

[Defacto]

i seriously cannot wait for these younger players to really build that strong base and develop their tank. the quality is seriously there, they just need the tank

seb is getting better with each game, steven is slowly getting more consistent. theres no surprise that dal was able to perform with the other mids around him lifting

 

[CrashTestDummy]

i seriously cannot wait for these younger players to really build that strong base and develop their tank. the quality is seriously there, they just need the tank

seb is getting better with each game, steven is slowly getting more consistent. theres no surprise that dal was able to perform with the other mids around him lifting

Be patient Defacto. The Sam and Dave show isn't that far away. Give it a year or two. Time to talk to friends about The Saints and the success that will flow. Old School to New School.

 

[sauce_head]

i seriously cannot wait for these younger players to really build that strong base and develop their tank. the quality is seriously there, they just need the tank

seb is getting better with each game, steven is slowly getting more consistent. theres no surprise that dal was able to perform with the other mids around him lifting

Maybe they can get some tanking tips from Carltanks. Oh Waite, nope he is a headbutter. I mean, oh wait, that us not the tank you mean is it?!

 

[Confuscius]

To be honest, considering how much I respect him as a player, and considering his form coming in, and considering he was playing on a one-armed man... nope, thought he could have had more impact. But I suspect we'll have to agree to disagree.

BOG not good enough for you? You're entitled to your view, but it's weird

 

[CrashTestDummy]

Maybe they can get some tanking tips from Carltanks. Oh Waite, nope he is a headbutter. I mean, oh wait, that us not the tank you mean is it?!

St.Kilda don't need to tank like Carlton or Melbourne. They don't even need to employ the likes of 'The Weapon' like Essendon or Geelong.

St.Kilda doesn't even need to bet on Grand Finals like Tyson Goldsack or during the season like Heath Shaw.

St.Kilda needs to stay focused playing games and the results will flow.

GO SAINTERS

 

[Squizz]

Saad shits me

God I love Saad

Let us know what you really think!

 

[Speck]

Well thank god we got away with that.

Not sure if has been mentioned before but WTF was going on with only having THREE players at the centre bounce twice late in the last quarter? Cost us a clearance the first time and almost happened again. Inexcusable to only have 3, at one stage Dal was running to go in but stopped on the wing? How hard is it to count!

 

[sammm]

Well thank god we got away with that.

Not sure if has been mentioned before but WTF was going on with only having THREE players at the centre bounce twice late in the last quarter? Cost us a clearance the first time and almost happened again. Inexcusable to only have 3, at one stage Dal was running to go in but stopped on the wing? How hard is it to count!

too much panicking. at one point in the last quarter , i am muttering the leaders need to stand up and be counted. I think they were for the most part in the tackle count, smothering etc. but only after 3-4 quick goals by carlton.