Rutten/Mattner/Bock

[CaptainDangerfield]

If these 3, at the very least, maintain this years form for the next couple of years, where do you think they would have been drafted if we didn't rookie list them. Ignore hindsight.

Mattner - 11-20,
Rutten - 15-25,
Bock - 20-30.

Thoughts?

 

[noddy]

If these 3, at the very least, maintain this years form for the next couple of years, where do you think they would have been drafted if we didn't rookie list them. Ignore hindsight.

Mattner - 11-20,
Rutten - 15-25,
Bock - 20-30.

Thoughts?

In my opinion.

Mattner & Rutten both late 1st round or at least 2nd round picks.

Bock 3rd round.

Then again the quality of the draft at the time would also have a bearing.

 

[Cap]

In my opinion.

Mattner & Rutten both late 1st round or at least 2nd round picks.

Bock 3rd round.

Then again the quality of the draft at the time would also have a bearing.

I don't know about that

Rutten apparently had an inury during the u/18's and scouts weren't to interested (similar to knights), not sure on bock and mattner but you may find they probably would have went fairly high. sometimes people that are made to work for it relish the opportunity more. from what I heard Mattners main talent early on was tackling and Bocks was being athletic.


Imagine this board if bock, Matter and Rutten were all taken top 25 - there would have been even louder screams for their delisting a few years back.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

If these 3, at the very least, maintain this years form for the next couple of years, where do you think they would have been drafted if we didn't rookie list them. Ignore hindsight.

Mattner - 11-20,
Rutten - 15-25,
Bock - 20-30.

Thoughts?

Hard to say, but will give it a go.

Rutten - early 2nd round pick
Mattner - late 2nd round pick/early 3rd round pick.
Bock - late 3rd round pick/early 4th round pick.

At least we have benefited from the rookie list unlike the F&S rule (yet).

 

[macca23]

If these 3, at the very least, maintain this years form for the next couple of years, where do you think they would have been drafted if we didn't rookie list them. Ignore hindsight.

Mattner - 11-20,
Rutten - 15-25,
Bock - 20-30.

Thoughts?

Mattner - yes.

Rutten - 20-30

Bock 35-50

 

[Crowz Gal]

I don't know about that from what I heard Mattners main talent early on was tackling

Really???

 

[rayven]

My guess is as follows based on what I have seen and heard during their career.
Mattner> his defensive skills being obvious and not so much his attacking/playmaking ability I would say a third round.

Bock> his athletisism would shine and being big with good skills he would go early ,at the latest a second round.

Rutten> He was a forward when young and they say he was not agile enough for afl level.Unless the potential drafter saw his abilities as a full back I would say he was at the earliest a third round.