Remove this Banner Ad

Training Saints preseason 2026

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

If anything, the argument should always be Max vs Rozee, because Max vs Ben was never a consideration.
I do feel that Rozee would look damn good in a number 4 guernsey at St Kilda.
 
I've been a bit out of sight lately but cant stay quiet with the King brothers. Ben was only chucked up forward when Max was injured. Ben also had injury queries.

Sure Ben and Max both played forward in school footy at times but Max was always considered the better prospect - early days in his draft year he was entrenched in the pick 1 conversation.

If anything, the argument should always be Max vs Rozee, because Max vs Ben was never a consideration.
Yep, and we should've taken Rozee as planned, rather than Lethlean's broken legacy/vanity pick.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I've been a bit out of sight lately but cant stay quiet with the King brothers. Ben was only chucked up forward when Max was injured. Ben also had injury queries.

Sure Ben and Max both played forward in school footy at times but Max was always considered the better prospect - early days in his draft year he was entrenched in the pick 1 conversation.

If anything, the argument should always be Max vs Rozee, because Max vs Ben was never a consideration.
Geez the Max king talk is sooooooo tiresome. Lets look forward people to the boys that are going to take us forward and celebrate when Max can join in the party.........so much more positive stuff to be discussing.
 
Crows v St Kilda Game at Adelaide Oval.

Does anyone know what Bays that St Kilda Fans sit in.

Google suggests Bays 146/147 are typically used by away fans?
 

“Collingwood coach Craig McRae said that captain Darcy Moore and Jeremy Howe are "unlikely" to play in Opening Round against St Kilda.”
Angry Conan Obrien GIF by Team Coco
 
Rozee is one of the most overrated players in the competition

If we had our time again I'd still take Max every time with his upside even knowing his injury risks
150 games, 124 goal, captain of his club and 2x All Australian. I'm sorry, but his career says otherwise in comparison to King. Who is still a project player at best 8 years into his career.

Anyway, it's moot. We don't have either playing for us at the moment.
Hopefully we look at a Shanahan type, or someone youthful and energetic, who has some legitimate forward nous and craft, and who actually compliments our exciting list going forward.
 
Last edited:
Every sucessful club needs at least one dominant key forward to make it. I profess to not being Max Kings greatest fan over time, but without a shadow of a doubt we are a much better side with him playing.

At the time of his last contract signing, nobody could foresee his current injury run. That's footy and the risks clubs have to take with keeping lists together. I'm sure many would be tearing up their memberships if the club didn't get him signed.

It has been a frustrating period, as we have had a 'lions share' of bad luck with injuries and poor injury management. But in Max's case there is still plenty of time for him to return and a have significant career. Even lead us to our next flag...

The club has never been in a better position and more professionally run, so have faith they will be doing everything possible to get him playing again.

This Max stuff is just a blip in road, fed by some in the media who take every opportunity to take a swing at our beloved club. Let's not get sucked into their insecurities that the Saints might actually be on the cusp of something great.

Like most I love this club, they are an extension of my family and when things are going well the club fills us with the greatest enjoyment and pride.

I have a sense this year is going to be an absolute cracker, so lets sit back and enjoy every minute.

Go Sainters ❤️🤍🖤
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Rozee is one of the most overrated players in the competition

If we had our time again I'd still take Max every time with his upside even knowing his injury risks
I’d still take McCartin over Trac too…

Cause I’m an idiot.
 
Rozee is one of the most overrated players in the competition

If we had our time again I'd still take Max every time with his upside even knowing his injury risks
He is a bit overrated but at least he plays.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Dont know where the King v Rozee stuff came from.
This current LM group had no say in his selection.
The discussion was about the long extension, and if it was a success, so far.
It was a pretty easy line to follow.

Was Max or Ben the better draft choice. Clearly in hindsight you’d say Ben has worked out better to date but NO ONE would have said that at the time.

Given no one would have said that at the time the discussion became was Max or Connor the better draft choice.

Again, no brainer to date.
 
Rozee is one of the most overrated players in the competition

If we had our time again I'd still take Max every time with his upside even knowing his injury risks
Cmon
He’s a gun and actually plays
 
Every sucessful club needs at least one dominant key forward to make it. I profess to not being Max Kings greatest fan over time, but without a shadow of a doubt we are a much better side with him playing.

At the time of his last contract signing, nobody could foresee his current injury run. That's footy and the risks clubs have to take with keeping lists together. I'm sure many would be tearing up their memberships if the club didn't get him signed.

It has been a frustrating period, as we have had a 'lions share' of bad luck with injuries and poor injury management. But in Max's case there is still plenty of time for him to return and a have significant career. Even lead us to our next flag...

The club has never been in a better position and more professionally run, so have faith they will be doing everything possible to get him playing again.

This Max stuff is just a blip in road, fed by some in the media who take every opportunity to take a swing at our beloved club. Let's not get sucked into their insecurities that the Saints might actually be on the cusp of something great.

Like most I love this club, they are an extension of my family and when things are going well the club fills us with the greatest enjoyment and pride.

I have a sense this year is going to be an absolute cracker, so lets sit back and enjoy every minute.

Go Sainters ❤️🤍🖤

I'm confident that Max gets back this year and puts this all behind him. I reckon he plays at least half the season but there was every reason not to give him a long contract seeing as he was already showing that he had a less than resilient body at that point. I understand if there were other offers and it was the only way to keep hold of him but there wasn't.

It could end up still being a masterstroke if he gets through the knee and gets to play the bulk of this season at the level of Ben even, but it was a extremely high risk move with hard to see benefits other than hoping to sign him on less coin than we thought he'd be able to ask in the future. Alister Lynch did it back in the day and it ended up being an incredible move but it's a high risk gamble.
 
What’s ridiculous is that WCE gifted that 3rd pick in the draft to them
It was stupid then and it’s still stupid now. Is Charlie Banfield also making our list manager look like a total dickhead yet again by not leaving a list spot open for him?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom