Sam Mitchell vs Simon black

[juss]

Black for me, but not a lot in it.

 

[a_fighting_fury]

Watching both play, as a neutral I'd pick Black, just. But would've loved either or both in my team.

 

[Rainfall]

In the minds of many and not just Hawks mitchell was robbed because Essendon drug bull shit.
Also so was Cotchin that 2012 Brownlow

 

[Rainfall]

In the minds of many and not just Hawks mitchell was robbed because Essendon drug bull shit.
Also so was Cotchin that 2012 Brownlow

 

[Lethality]

Mitchell, more consistent for longer, also a better kick.

 

[HolyWars]

I will go with Mitchell only because I watch him every week - and biased.

Both are champions.

 

[pacman]

Why does this poll suck?
2 legends with similar styles.
If it's so hard to split, which I agree then it's a good poll?
Or would u rather Gary Ablett vs James polkinghorn?

It was tongue in cheek mate didn't want to split two great footballers.

 

[Trav 20]

Excellent comparison. Black, Mitchell and Diesel are the best handballers I've seen.

Black.

 

[mottrain]

Excellent comparison. Black, Mitchell and Diesel are the best handballers I've seen.

Black.

I have to guess you didn't see Kevin Bartlett play.

 

[TazHawk15]

Excellent comparison. Black, Mitchell and Diesel are the best handballers I've seen.

Black.

No way.

Arron Lord and Paul Hudson were fantastic handballers, I think at one stage they hired Kevin Bartlett for individual one on one coaching in this skill.

 

[Collingwoodity]

Mitchell Stands out more, had more positive effect on games than Black.

 

[drummond2fevola]

Mitchell Stands out more, had more positive effect on games than Black.

It is understandable that you had a lobotomy after 2003.