Remove this Banner Ad

SANFL Player reports.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Stiffy_18
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Joined
Dec 14, 2002
Posts
38,214
Reaction score
13,242
Location
who cares
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Sacramento Kings
A bit one sided I know but it makes an interesting read anyway. Maybe Rowan Adrews is a bit of late developer. Speaking to a couple of "scouts" they say that his improvement from 2002 to 2003 has been astronomical. However, we all agree there is a lot of work to do especially with his kicking. he can take a good grab and will have a genuine crack a bit like hudson

SANFL Player Reports - trial matches 20/3/04
Andrew Montesi
afc.com.au
3:26:46 PM Mon 22 March, 2004


WEST VS GLENELG

Brad Dabrowski (West, Rookie List)
Playing the majority of the match at centre half forward and in the ruck, Dabrowski would have left the field more than happy with his performance on Saturday. Brad looked to make the most of his large physique, working hard to play in front and use his body accordingly. He managed to take some very strong marks while also working hard at ground level. Dabrowski’s work rate for the entire four quarters was impressive, always managing to compete at every contest. Every match reveals significant improvement from Brad Dabrowski.

Luke Jericho (West)
Playing at full forward in the first half, Jericho showed signs of being able to fill the vacancy in West Adelaide’s goal mouth. Luke provided a target for the running players and worked hard to bring the ball to ground for the crumbers. However, when moved to centre half back, Jericho displayed the confidence of one beyond his years. Whilst displaying the discipline to spoil from behind, Jericho also managed to take some telling marks deep in defence. Luke read the ball well, and always looked to kick long and direct. Overall an impressive effort from Luke Jericho.

Rowan Andrews (Glenelg, Rookie List)
Coming on just before half time, Andrews was thrown straight into the ruck. Rowan had an immediate impact on the match, rucking aggressively and displaying precision tapwork. As a result of Andrews’ efforts, Glenelg was able to score several times. During the third term Rowan continued to have an influence on the efforts of his team, continuing to jump hard at the ball and tap with both left and right hands. Throughout the remainder of the match Andrews impressed with his energy and aggression. For a man of his size, Rowan chases and tackles hard, looking to be involved in as many contests as possible.

Jacob Schuback (Glenelg)
Running off from a half back flank, Schuback displayed the dominance of a would-be AFL footballer. Jacob gathered multiple possessions by both hand and foot, and was strong at the football both on the ground and in the air. Particularly in the second half, Schuback managed to find a significant amount of space continuing to be involved in all aspects of the game, whether it be attacking or defending. 2004 looks to be a ground breaking season for Jacob Schuback.

NORWOOD VS NORTH

James Gallagher (Norwood)
Gallagher produced an excellent performance on Saturday. Whilst playing on the ball for the first three quarters, James found an enormous amount of the ball while working hard both up and down the field. Against disappointing opposition, Gallagher stamped his authority on the match from the first siren and found little competition from his opponents. James was moved to the back pocket for the final quarter, where he displayed excellent discipline and teamwork. He showed respect for his opponent by giving him little space. Coaching staff were impressed with Gallagher’s understanding of the team concept.

Tim Hazell (Norwood, Rookie List)
Hazell’s work rate and attitude was fantastic for the entire four quarters on Saturday. Tim looks to be becoming a fine SANFL footballer and in time could step up to the next level. The running midfielder looked to relish in the opportunity to play on ball for the entire match, gathering countless possessions and was always a step ahead of his opposition. Tim Hazell will most certainly play a major role in Norwood’s premiership campaign this year.

PORT VS SOUTH

Ronnie Burns (Port)
Playing up forward all day, Ronnie Burns’ performance was a class above the rest. In true “Ronnie” tradition, the experienced goal sneak displayed typical bursts that can crush the opposition. Throughout the day Ronnie shared the ball amongst his team mates, setting up goals while also kicking two himself. Burns’ skills were excellent by either hand or foot, and when the opposition gained possession he maintained the pressure with great examples of chasing and tackling. Overall Ronnie Burns would be well satisfied with a fantastic team effort.

Jason Torney (South)
Jason Torney had a solid day out on Saturday, working hard for the entire four quarters. The former Tiger displayed excellent skills, with his precision clearing kicks a feature. Torney looked to provide run out of defence and through the centre, and his decision making skills were very sound. Jason’s second efforts and “one percenters” were again fantastic, his chases and tackles were a fine example of this. With the extra match practice, Torney’s return to the senior side looks to be sooner rather than later.

EAGLES VS CENTRALS

Hayden Skipworth (Eagles)
Skipworth produced a great effort over the weekend and looks to be emerging as a fine young footballer. Hayden didn’t put a foot wrong for the entire match, making the most of every disposal. When attacking, he was consistently able to display clean ball handling and was able to take the ball and dispose of it whilst under pressure with precision. When defending, Skipworth was excellent in that he chased and tackled hard at every opportunity. Hayden also managed to work extremely hard to get to every contest and worked to receive the ball.

Nathan Bock (Eagles)
Playing at full back, Nathan Bock nullified the efforts of his opponent after returning from an ankle energy. Although only on the ground for the first half, Bock managed to prevent the opposition full forward from having an impact on the match, playing a true defender’s role. Bock also attempted to provide run out of defence and made the most of limited opportunities. Adelaide’s coaching staff would be pleased to see Nathan get through the match unscathed.
 
You would think they were all BOG & should be selected to play against the Roos. Hard to know what to make of the comments. Wish they gave a balanced view (ie. if they had an ordinary game, say so).
 
Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
You would think they were all BOG & should be selected to play against the Roos. Hard to know what to make of the comments. Wish they gave a balanced view (ie. if they had an ordinary game, say so).
I agree. I would rather hear it without sugar coating.

I remember last year, I watched Sturt Vs Eagles and Smith got absolutely spanked that game and only had 2 possesions (from memory). Reading the report during the week, the club painted a picture of how he played a fantastic game and one would be forgven for thinking that those 2 disposals were the classiest and best that were ever seen.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Originally posted by Scotty's_Girl
What happened to Lads? Did he not play for North?
Yeah, he did play for North. Think he got 30+ possessions & played well.
 
Originally posted by Stiffy_18
AWEST VS GLENELG

Jacob Schuback (Glenelg)
Running off from a half back flank, Schuback displayed the dominance of a would-be AFL footballer. Jacob gathered multiple possessions by both hand and foot, and was strong at the football both on the ground and in the air. Particularly in the second half, Schuback managed to find a significant amount of space continuing to be involved in all aspects of the game, whether it be attacking or defending. 2004 looks to be a ground breaking season for Jacob Schuback.


I could have SWORN he didnt play the second half.

I always keep my eyes peeled when it comes to watching our boys in the SANFL, and I am absolutely positive there was no #21 in Schuback out on that ground in the second half.
:confused:
 
Re: Re: SANFL Player reports.

Originally posted by RaDaR ReiLLy
I could have SWORN he didnt play the second half.

I always keep my eyes peeled when it comes to watching our boys in the SANFL, and I am absolutely positive there was no #21 in Schuback out on that ground in the second half.
:confused:
Might have been the Sunday Mail journalist...;)
 
Begley played got sturt, did ok i heard, Mattner for some reason didnt play :S, matthew smith played and played well along with Ladhams for North
 
Originally posted by Stiffy_18

Ronnie Burns (Port)
Playing up forward all day, Ronnie Burns’ performance was a class above the rest. In true “Ronnie” tradition, the experienced goal sneak displayed typical bursts that can crush the opposition. Throughout the day Ronnie shared the ball amongst his team mates, setting up goals while also kicking two himself. Burns’ skills were excellent by either hand or foot, and when the opposition gained possession he maintained the pressure with great examples of chasing and tackling. Overall Ronnie Burns would be well satisfied with a fantastic team effort.

try this for a more realistic appraisal of Ronnie's game from our Port friend Macca19
 
Re: Re: SANFL Player reports.

Originally posted by naughty monkey
try this for a more realistic appraisal of Ronnie's game from our Port friend Macca19
I would prefer Ronnie playing as a forward a kicking a few goals from not too many possessions, rather than taking someone else's spot in the midfield.
 
Dabrowski

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
You would think they were all BOG & should be selected to play against the Roos. Hard to know what to make of the comments. Wish they gave a balanced view (ie. if they had an ordinary game, say so).

G'day Kane and thanks for your help with my registration.

This is my first time on Big Footy and I would like to start by congratulating the Crows recruiting staff on the selection of Dabrowski. This boy has a lot of potential and IMO will make a very reliable key position defender. He is also tall enough to play in the ruck. As a Port supporter, he is a rookie I would not have minded at Alberton.
 
Re: Dabrowski

Originally posted by Mitch Power
G'day Kane and thanks for your help with my registration.

This is my first time on Big Footy and I would like to start by congratulating the Crows recruiting staff on the selection of Dabrowski. This boy has a lot of potential and IMO will make a very reliable key position defender. He is also tall enough to play in the ruck. As a Port supporter, he is a rookie I would not have minded at Alberton.
Welcome to Big Footy Mitch & I hope you are regular visiter to the Crows Board. ;)

The fact in the SANFL grand final the Big D gave Westies more in ruck than the delisted marshmellow means we are already in front! ;)
 
Dabrowski played centre-half-forward in the Grand Final. If he had a run in the ruck, it wasn't for very long. He only rucks at Westies if we've got injuries to the No 1 ruckman. Haven't seen him play as a key defender at all, although that might be a possibility in the future. He's had a slow start to the season in trial games, but will be good at CHF when the season starts.

On the other hand, Jericho played well up forward last weekend, but was really good running out of defence in the second half. Keeps on getting better and is something to look forward to.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Originally posted by redandblack
Dabrowski played centre-half-forward in the Grand Final. If he had a run in the ruck, it wasn't for very long. He only rucks at Westies if we've got injuries to the No 1 ruckman. Haven't seen him play as a key defender at all, although that might be a possibility in the future. He's had a slow start to the season in trial games, but will be good at CHF when the season starts.

On the other hand, Jericho played well up forward last weekend, but was really good running out of defence in the second half. Keeps on getting better and is something to look forward to.

The more I think about it, the more I can see Jericho being the man to replace Smart in defence next year. Similar height, even better leap, pace, real mobility and will povide run out of the backlines. Looks a very likely type.

Question about Dabrowski.

Presuming Mark Stevens doesn't come up and has to go on the long term injured list, has Dabrowski got the ability to play the Robran type role at CHF at AFL level??

Do you think HE should be the one promoted from the rookie list if Stevens doesn't come good?
 
Originally posted by macca23
...<SNIP>...
Question about Dabrowski.

Presuming Mark Stevens doesn't come up and has to go on the long term injured list, has Dabrowski got the ability to play the Robran type role at CHF at AFL level??

No


Originally posted by macca23
Do you think HE should be the one promoted from the rookie list if Stevens doesn't come good?

No - Hazell or Parker (hopefully)
Smith (probably)
 
Originally posted by macca23
1. The more I think about it, the more I can see Jericho being the man to replace Smart in defence next year. Similar height, even better leap, pace, real mobility and will povide run out of the backlines. Looks a very likely type.

2. Question about Dabrowski.

Presuming Mark Stevens doesn't come up and has to go on the long term injured list, has Dabrowski got the ability to play the Robran type role at CHF at AFL level??

Do you think HE should be the one promoted from the rookie list if Stevens doesn't come good?
1. I was thinking the same thing. The jury is still out on the kid but I must admit I have been impressed by the little I have seen of him. BIG leap, lightening quick, very good overhead mark and can play small or tall. I think as far as height and athletic ability goes Jericho would be a perfect replacement for Smart. Hopefully he can play some good footy at AFL level. I find it strange that Chris McDermott has a positive thing to say about one of the Crows youngsters. I think he likes Jericho.

2. No. He is not a HCF type. If Stevo goes on the long term injury list then I agree with naughty monkey that it will be either Parker or Hazell will be promoted. I find it interesting that Parker has been played as a forward so far this year by South Adelaide. Maybe the AFC told them to play him there so they see how he is handling it if Stevo doesn't come up. What do you think about this??????
 
Originally posted by redandblack
Dabrowski played centre-half-forward in the Grand Final. If he had a run in the ruck, it wasn't for very long. He only rucks at Westies if we've got injuries to the No 1 ruckman. Haven't seen him play as a key defender at all, although that might be a possibility in the future. He's had a slow start to the season in trial games, but will be good at CHF when the season starts.
Well who was it who came into the ruck when marshmellow was being carpeted & gave Westies some much needed drive thtough the middle ... or am I thinking of the previous week???
 
Originally posted by macca23
Question about Dabrowski.

Presuming Mark Stevens doesn't come up and has to go on the long term injured list, has Dabrowski got the ability to play the Robran type role at CHF at AFL level??

Do you think HE should be the one promoted from the rookie list if Stevens doesn't come good?
If Stevo doesn't come up, I wouldn't promote any rookies at this stage. I would keep our options open as who knows how they will perform during the year in the SANFL or whether we get an injury run requiring one player over another.
 
Kane, the week before was the prelim final and Marsh was excellent and well up in Westies best players. He played the Grand Final with a broken hand and I think Dabrowski did some ruckwork, but not a lot. As ruckmen, Marsh is way ahead of Dabrowski, as you would expect,. Dabrowski is a young tall, developing nicely, but Shaun Rehn clearly thinks he is a CHF, not a ruckman.

I think I've detected a very slight bias against Marsh on here. That's OK, although I think he was given little opportunity at times. At West, he had a very good season last year and his attitude was excellent, as far as I could see.

As an aside, the contribution of a middle of the road SANFL club like Westies to Adelaide has been amazing. You could go close to naming a top Adelaide side from the players from Westies over the years. More to come, I think.

By the way, although he has been delisted, watch out for Jason Porplyzia as an on-baller in the SANFL this year.

Go the Crows!
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Originally posted by redandblack

I think I've detected a very slight bias against Marsh on here.

By the way, although he has been delisted, watch out for Jason Porplyzia as an on-baller in the SANFL this year.


A very slight bias against Marsh??? ;) Not true - it was a major bias!! :p

As for Porplyzia, I was disappointed to see him delisted from our rookie list. I thought he had a good year in 2003 and looks a player of the future.
 
Originally posted by redandblack
Macca, I had detected the overwhelming anti-Marsh sentiment. It was a deliberately tongue-in-cheek statement.

I did pick that up. ;)

I just couldn'r resist one last big jibe at that hopeless dud. :p
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom